Two most valuable players?

[malpaso]

Right now? Luke and Johnno. Period. The end. We don't have anyone available who could realistically play their position.

Exactly. Right now at this moment these two are our most valuable (important) players.

 

[poshman]

Sandi - Fyfe

I get the argument on Macca and Johnson. But without our midfield and clearance dominance those guys would be swamped down back. Dawson is a week away from fitness, I am not sure if he will get in the team such is our form... crazy good isn't it!

 

[Bicco]

My slightly leftfield answer is C Pearce and Mundy. Clancy is giving us possessions and distance that we've never had before, I can't see Crowley ever getting back in. He's totally changed our midfield structure, he's playing his role superbly. If he went down a youngster would get a game ( which is good) but right now he has a massive impact on our performance.
Mundy has been fantastic this year, flying a bit under the radar due to Fyfe. His body work around stoppages is unbalancing opposition midfielders allowing Fyfe/Neale precious seconds to gather and dispose (or just smash your way through in Fyfes case).
A smokey for the list would be Ibbo who's intercept marking is league best. He has a talent that can't be taught.

 

[Purpletown]

Silvagni has always tended to come in and do a good job. Dawson and Pearce also acceptable options.

Whilst Sandi hugely important, we have 2013 to show that he isn't be all and end all.

In answer to OP: probably Fyfe and Hill.
Or maybe a trick question: no player is irreplaceable!!

Fyfe and Hill for me too - a dominant midfield is the No 1 requirement to be a good/great team and these two deliver in spades.

 

[purplepassion82]

McPharlin and Sandilands

 

[clivenator26]

Is RTB even more important?

 

[masai]

For the structure :-

Ibbo + Mayne

 

[Danny Cullen]

For the structure :-

Ibbo + Mayne

I was thinking Ibbo and Tabs.

 

[Fred Ziffel]

Stephen Hill and Luke Mcpharlin.

 

[mike91]

Fyfe and McPharlin.

 

[Righteo]

Fyfe and Hill as well.