UFC 309

[burge13]

I think if its meant to be current then Poatan is P4P.

MW/LHW and just wasting 3 guys a year.

Jones has Gane and a 42 year old Miocic in the last 4 years?

Jones is the GOAT and will remain unparalled IMO but RIGHT now, hes probably 3rd on the P4P list.

P4P is if both guys weighed the same, who wins
Not comparing resumes (but guess that can play a part)

Poatan gets his shit pushed in by Jones

 

[Topkent]

P4P is if both guys weighed the same, who wins
Not comparing resumes (but guess that can play a part)

Poatan gets his shit pushed in by Jones

Depends how you take the p4p list. I do agree that as an all round threat Jones is the P4P
If it's on resumes in a time period I think it's Topuria and Poatan #1

 

[phantom13]

P4P is if both guys weighed the same, who wins
Not comparing resumes (but guess that can play a part)

Poatan gets his shit pushed in by Jones

Its a made up list with at best fluffy criteria.

If its PURELY based on same weight who wins Jones probably does get it but if thats the case you may as well have retired fighters and guys who fight once a decade on there.

You have to take form and wins into account IMO. Not even sure how else youd assess it without looking at performances.

 

[burge13]

Its a made up list with at best fluffy criteria.

If its PURELY based on same weight who wins Jones probably does get it but if thats the case you may as well have retired fighters and guys who fight once a decade on there.

You have to take form and wins into account IMO. Not even sure how else youd assess it without looking at performances.

Take recent wins into account sure but Jones is still an active fighter (not as active as we'd like but is active and current champ) and none of the others could touch him

Topuria is fighter of the year, stopping Max wins that easily for mine but in the ridiculous made up world where he and Jones fight at the same weight, Jones wins easily.

P4P is dumb but that's the hypothetical, if 2 guys weighed the same, who wins...

 

[phantom13]

Take recent wins into account sure but Jones is still an active fighter (not as active as we'd like but is active and current champ) and none of the others could touch him

Topuria is fighter of the year, stopping Max wins that easily for mine but in the ridiculous made up world where he and Jones fight at the same weight, Jones wins easily.

P4P is dumb but that's the hypothetical, if 2 guys weighed the same, who wins...

Sure... I dont agree

 

[phantom13]

The first google result for P4P is as follows.

"Pound for Pound" rankings are subjective and often a matter of debate among fans, analysts, and experts. These rankings are not based on direct competition between the fighters but rather on an assessment of their individual skills, achievements, and performances relative to their weight class.

So much like the GOAT debate, theres not a consensus on the criteria.

 

[RobbyRoy]

There is no objective system for UFC or MMA rankings, so not phased at all by who sits where on any given list personally.