Can we sort out the criteria for this once and for all?
The idea is players who had the big kahunas on the day - not who was the most worthy over their career.
So no Franklin, no Crawford, no Jarmen - think Gary Ayres, John Hendrie, Mort Arthur.
Blokes that somehow saved their best for last.
Think Dipper.
The earth is about to end, we agree on something TAITA.
I'm taking it as performances on Grand Final Day alone too. No offence to Crawford or Franklin, but Dew gets the nod because he changed a GF. Franklin's two goals were important, but then so was Hodges bomb from that free kick. Hodge was epic over the entire 100 mins.
Hodge and Dew are the only 2008 players to make my side. Apologises to Willo and Young if he played 100 minutes.
Please Hawks members, don't make it a side of your favourite current players combined with the 80s legends. The whole idea is to watch all the GFs and make a decision then. Moncrieff was a big game player, kicking 4 in 1978. He's in.