MRP / Trib. Umpiring, MRO, Tribunal, Rule Changes - 50m penalties for raising arms?

[Lore]

I could sit down and happily explain 90% of decisions and why they were correct.

The ones that pissed me off at the ground were mostly players getting their heads ripped off and apparently no one doing anything about it. Seemed to piss off others in the crowd too from the reaction.

On reflection they were probably paid as advantage. Certainly one of them was as I've seen it in a 'last five minutes' clip and can hear the umpires mic in the broadcast, but the same is probably true of at least one other instance that turned into a shot at goal.

I wouldn't say the broadcast is always kind to the umpires, but letting the crowd get a bit crazy over umpiring because they don't fully know what is going on is probably not helpful. Next thing the umpires are getting booed and I'm sure for some of them that affects the decisions they make (for better or for worse).

 

[boncer34]

The ones that pissed me off at the ground were mostly players getting their heads ripped off and apparently no one doing anything about it. Seemed to piss off others in the crowd too from the reaction.

On reflection they were probably paid as advantage. Certainly one of them was as I've seen it in a 'last five minutes' clip and can hear the umpires mic in the broadcast, but the same is probably true of at least one other instance that turned into a shot at goal.

I wouldn't say the broadcast is always kind to the umpires, but letting the crowd get a bit crazy over umpiring because they don't fully know what is going on is probably not helpful. Next thing the umpires are getting booed and I'm sure for some of them that affects the decisions they make (for better or for worse).

Also not knowing the rules contributes to this.

 

[Yoda_]

Also not knowing the rules contributes to this.

Imagine having a senior umpire at the quarter time breaks explain an interpretation of why said decision was made?!

Would be bloody brilliant and something id enjoy not the 100s of gambling ads that tell me to gamble responsibly

 

[yodellinhank]

Also not knowing the rules contributes to this.

If they don't know the rules they shouldn't be umpiring.

 

[boncer34]

Imagine having a senior umpire at the quarter time breaks explain an interpretation of why said decision was made?!

Would be bloody brilliant and something id enjoy not the 100s of gambling ads that tell me to gamble responsibly

And have thousands boo him because they refuse to accept their initial take was wrong.

 

[eth-dog]

And have thousands boo him because they refuse to accept their initial take was wrong.

Think he's talking about on TV

 

[boncer34]

Think he's talking about on TV

And have thousands sit at home and melt about how he's clueless because they refuse to accept their initial take was wrong.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

i don’t read our board, i’m sure as s**t not going to read their board!

it's fun when they have a bad loss. Nothing like drinking the salty tears on an autopsy thread lol

 

[boncer34]

it's fun when they have a bad loss. Nothing like drinking the salty tears on an autopsy thread lol

I can't tell if you're talking our board or opposition boards?

 

[jmoo wan]

Also not knowing the rules contributes to this.

Baaaaaaaaaallllllllll!

 

[Lance Uppercut]

I can't tell if you're talking our board or opposition boards?

definitely not our board. I stay the * away from here after a loss, life's too short

 

[TheGrizz]

Generally speaking, if fans of both teams think the other got the best of the umpiring, then the umpires have probably done their jobs properly.

 

[Maddogm]

Generally speaking, if fans of both teams think the other got the best of the umpiring, then the umpires have probably done their jobs properly.

With the way some fans are that would mean that the umpires are perfect every game.

 

[Yoda_]

Well I look like a ripe dill. Get the perception we hardly get goals from frees. Turns out other teams are just screwed harder

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Knighta21]

Is that table confusing to anyone else? It says we have kicked the least from free kicks (11) then shouldn’t that number be in the ‘for’ category in the table? Which in turns mean we do have one of the worse differentials in terms of goals from free kicks compared to opponents?