Umpiring [vs Eagles Mega Thread]

[Artaxx]

It was really only gonna end one way, wasn't it?

was there a doubt.

 

[detox]

The thing was, about 3 or so instances in the last few minutes of north blokes getting clipped borderline high, play on (and rightfully so) then to pay it for a selwood in the most ridiculous circumstances...

I'd be pissed

 

[Maddox]

Absolutley disgraceful.

 

[Elite Master]

The fact that we are aregueing about a couple of umpiring decisions is telling. Should have never even come down to the umpires, it just makes the loss hurt more.

 

[Stranglers]

As a neutral even I was absolutely filthy at a few of those calls. Can't believe West Coast supporters are happy about winning a game that way; I'd be embarrassed.

 

[QueenslandRoo]

Derm said on Fox Footy that in the past 5 years, the six players to have received the most free kicks for high tackles include THREE Eagles players and THREE Selwoods.

 

[King Corey]

Free kicks were there. Just sloppy tackling.

Get over it. Whether the umpiring in the Port game was on or not, only a peanut would argue tonight was fairly adjudicated.

Take your bogan prose back to your own board.

 

[Egga]

Oh...and one more thing....the umpires owe me a new coffee mug because I just threw mine 50 meters down the street. Pay up Geischen you prick!

 

[Husk]

It was really only gonna end one way, wasn't it?

Thats the sad thing, you just expect it now when you play in Perth and it ruins what otherwise could be a good game.

 

[benchpress71]

Didn't see anyone crying when we got all the free kicks vs Port. Don't be a bunch of pussies.

We copped what we deserved for letting them back in the game and bringing the crowd back into it. Ask Brad why he brought in two guys who could barely run (Grima and Swallow). Ask Spud why he got outbodied by a peanut like Hill. Ask Petrie why he can't kick a regulation goal when the pressure is on late in a game. Ask Fumbles (Adams) what he has done to get a game of footy. Why do we continue to allow Atley to play soft roles down back, especially on a wide ground like Subi.

I am not very happy with our coach.

You have got to be joking, the coach has been outstanding

There were at least 12 poor decisions tonight.

6 alone in the last quarter.

If you are not in agreeable wi that. Don't post

 

[Egga]

Derm said on Fox Footy that in the past 5 years, the six players to have received the most free kicks for high tackles include THREE Eagles players and THREE Selwoods.

Well there's a massive bloody coincidence!

 

[Hearts to hearts]

Didn't see anyone crying when we got all the free kicks vs Port. Don't be a bunch of pussies.

We copped what we deserved for letting them back in the game and bringing the crowd back into it. Ask Brad why he brought in two guys who could barely run (Grima and Swallow). Ask Spud why he got outbodied by a peanut like Hill. Ask Petrie why he can't kick a regulation goal when the pressure is on late in a game. Ask Fumbles (Adams) what he has done to get a game of footy. Why do we continue to allow Atley to play soft roles down back, especially on a wide ground like Subi.

I am not very happy with our coach.

Maybe you can take that off-topic whinge to a different thread.

 

[scottywiper]

The advantage one Basti clearly wasn't keen on taking it.
By far the worst was the Black non-mark, he is our best kick on goal and was 25 out straight in front to put us more than 20 points up. Wasn't even close to touched.
Absolute joke.

 

[Tas]

Maybe you can take that off-topic whinge to a different thread.

Maybe you can give posting advice to people who want it?

 

[smasha]

Bad luck North fans.Your team was the better all night.We copped it with Peter Cech playing for Freo.
That's the way it is playing over there.
Brad Scott showed class in the presser.

 

[Kangapirate]

Umm the free was actually given against Swallow...he doesn't even touch him! I was reasonably content with the high but that's an absolute disgrace to pay that!

 

[Mav]

free was for Swallow not Adams. Even worse!

 

[Tas]

You have got to be joking, the coach has been outstanding

There were at least 12 poor decisions tonight.

6 alone in the last quarter.

If you are not in agreeable wi that. Don't post

That isn't the point, the umpiring would have been a non-factor if we could get our shit together.

We KNOW how the umpiring is going to pan out if we don't put them away.

 

[Maddox]

There's a lot of broken things that were in arms reach of me after that horrendous last call.

 

[shintemaster]

The advantage one Basti clearly wasn't keen on taking it.
By far the worst was the Black non-mark, he is our best kick on goal and was 25 out straight in front to put us more than 20 points up. Wasn't even close to touched.
Absolute joke.

Players are to decide when it's an advantage, except you know when we decide for them and stuff.

 

[kool kangas]

Go and get screwed!

Tut Tut Tut..........good comeback.
Adams did bugger all for the game, 6 kick,3 marks, 1 handball and 1 tackle....the tackle by Adams was to high. He needs to be dropped to find some form and then come back in.
l cant stand behind the play incidents by opposition players or us and l would be very surprised if Thompson got off.
On a positive note: great game by Hansen . l hope its the start of bigger and better things from him.
: these losses are only going to make us stronger
On a whole while not happy we lost I'm seeing improvements every week and things are looking better for the future.

 

[Ry009]

Reminder to West Coast posters, play dumb and you'll do the time.

 

[QueenslandRoo]

Umm the free was actually given against Swallow...he doesn't even touch him! I was reasonably content with the high but that's an absolute disgrace to pay that!

Just watched that free kick replayed over and over and over.

And every time, from every angle ... it was no where NEAR a free kick.

Unbelievable.

 

[Ashley B]

Didn't watch the game until last 5 minutes and went mental, the game I love can be a flipping c**** of a game.
Proud of the boys but it hurts
Go The Mighty Roos

 

[Horace]

The advantage one Basti clearly wasn't keen on taking it.
By far the worst was the Black non-mark, he is our best kick on goal and was 25 out straight in front to put us more than 20 points up. Wasn't even close to touched.
Absolute joke.

I'm surprised that you and a few other Perth based North supporters aren't locked up over there Scotty. How did you all contain yourselves in the face of that shocking umpiring?