Roast Under 23's AA team.

[ThisIsJake]

Has Sidebottom become underrated? His year was exceptional, a lock for top 3 in the copeland and in my count 12 brownlow votes.

How is it at all possible that they have both Guthrie and Duncan in before him, it's not even a close call it's just nonsensical.

I laughed at people who said we should trade him, he has developed heaps in the last 2 years and is now a gun. Obviously the rest of the footy world haven't caught up.

 

[Unknown Identity]

View attachment 80103
Has Sidebottom become underrated? His year was exceptional, a lock for top 3 in the copeland and in my count 12 brownlow votes.

How is it at all possible that they have both Guthrie and Duncan in before him, it's not even a close call it's just nonsensical.

I laughed at people who said we should trade him, he has developed heaps in the last 2 years and is now a gun. Obviously the rest of the footy world haven't caught up.

Yeah its because Sidebottom isn't under 23.. He is 23! haha..

Ollie Wines not being in there is ridiculous.

 

[TradeDraft]

Sidebottom is over 23 and this team was players under 23

 

[BoxMatrix]

Yeah its because Sidebottom isn't under 23.. He is 23! haha..

Ollie Wines not being in there is ridiculous.

Sidebottom is over 23 and this team was players under 23

Dustin Martin is 23... So Sidebottom was left out

No Elliott?

 

[Unknown Identity]

Dustin Martin is 23... So Sidebottom was left out

No Elliott?

Sidebottom turned 23 before the season started. Martin turned 23 during.

Elliott maybe a little unlucky but all 4 small forwards had better years than him.

 

[Kirby]

Elliott is the one who is stiff

 

[TradeDraft]

Dustin Martin is 23... So Sidebottom was left out

No Elliott?

Elliot plays for Collingwood would make it hard for him

 

[BoxMatrix]

Sidebottom turned 23 before the season started. Martin turned 23 during.

Elliott maybe a little unlucky but all 4 small forwards had better years than him.

I thought it was if you were born before after 1st of january 1991 you were counted? Would only be fair...

Chad Wingard was better? No way. He play alright for about 8 games then went missing until the past couple of weeks...

 

[ThisIsJake]

Haha, can someone delete this and save me the embarrassment.

 

[Unknown Identity]

I thought it was if you were born before after 1st of january 1991 you were counted? Would only be fair...

Chad Wingard was better? No way. He play alright for about 8 games then went missing until the past couple of weeks...

Still managed to kick more goals than Elliott and is a match winner.
Elliott isn't quite there in terms of turning games, but definitely has the potential.

 

[ThisIsJake]

Actually no, Sidey was in last years under 22's AA team. So maybe I am right.

 

[loki04]

Yeah its because Sidebottom isn't under 23.. He is 23! haha..

Jamie Elliott not being in there is ridiculous.

Fixed for you.

 

[PepperFace]

Haha, can someone delete this and save me the embarrassment.

No. This is funny

 

[ThisIsJake]

No. This is funny

Haha alright, i'll cop it.

 

[Baird]

Sidebottom turned 23 this year so he should be eligible.

 

[TradeDraft]

How about we have a Ruckman in the U-23 AA Team

 

[DWil6]

How about we have a Ruckman in the U-23 AA Team

But otherwise not not a whole lot. No future at Collingwood? Probably a bit harsh. Maybe not a lot of 22 year old guns.

 

[jackcass]

Elliott and Langdon both made the U22 team.

The 45 man squad with the final 22 in bold.

DEFENDERS

Brodie Smith (ADE), Daniel Talia (ADE), Jack Hombsch (PA), Shaun Atley (NM), Ryan Lester (BL), Tom Langdon (COL), Steven May (GC), Trent McKenzie (GC), Kade Kolodjashnij (GC), Luke McDonald (NM), Jack Newnes (STK), Jarman Impey (PA)

MIDFIELDERS

Adam Treloar (GWS), Dyson Heppell (ESS), Dion Prestia (GC), Jaeger O’Meara (GC), David Swallow (GC), Jackson Macrae (WB), Brandon Ellis (RIC), Ollie Wines (PA), Luke Parker (SYD), Tom Liberatore (WB), Dom Tyson (MEL), Luke Dahlhaus (WB), Lachie Neale (FRE), Brad Hill (HAW), Jared Polec (PA), Cam Guthrie (GEE), James Aish (BL), Harry Cunningham (SYD)

RUCKS

Billy Longer (STK), Jarrod Witts (COL)

FORWARDS

Chad Wingard (PA), Jack Gunston (HAW), Harley Bennell (GC), Jamie Elliott (COL), Jake Carlisle (ESS), Jack Darling (WC), Devon Smith (GWS), Tom Lynch (GC), Jack Billings (STK), Marcus Bontempelli (WB), Jeremy Cameron (GWS), Lewis Taylor (BL), Troy Menzel (CAR)

Is there a squad for th U23?

It's a social media driven selection process so I'm not too put out.

 

[Shaneprice97]

Its only AFL.coms all australian team, it means nothing, its basically the same as there phantom draft or there phantom All Australian team.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Don't we always over rate our young players?

 

[rose jam]

Elliot not being there is a joke. Teams are always selected on your last 6 weeks of the season

 

[Shaneprice97]

Sidebottom wasnt eligible because he turned 23 before round 1 against fremantle, for those curious.

 

[JOELY]

Don't we always over rate our young players?

every club's supporters do. every one.

 

[Good_Old]

Mitch Duncan? Have I missed something?

 

[Baird]

Mitch Duncan? Have I missed something?

Been very good this year. Averaging something like 24d and 1g per game.

So I have nfi why he is named in defence.