Underated/Overated

[audas]

strawberry pancakes...

 

[blue_cookie]

Overrated: Thornton, Betts, Hartlett. Russell, Carazzo (most wont aggree, but for the amount he gets the ball, he barely uses it well), wiggins(absolute hack)

Underrated: Fisher, Simpson, Murphy

 

[BlueWorld]

Overrated: Bret Thornton, Jordan Russell
Underrated: Brad Fisher, Jordan Bannister

Underrated by most- especially andain!!!, over rated by DC by a mile!!!!

 

[BlueYoss]

strawberry pancakes...

Underrated or overrated?

 

[Artie Bucco]

Underrated or overrated?

lol I thought I'd try your Sig URL just in case there was an actual site

 

[Silvagnis]

Not sure of the stats, but I doubt he had many goals kicked on him this year.

How many touches do his opponents average a game?

Thomas and Scotland both got a heap of the ball when they played on each other last year.

I hate downhill skiers.

 

[Bluebear]

How many touches do his opponents average a game?

Thomas and Scotland both got a heap of the ball when they played on each other last year.

I hate downhill skiers.

Didn't see the first game - listened on the radio, but our second game vs Pies, Houlihan played on Thomas.......Scotty just about BOG, unsure who his opponent was.

The point of how many touches your opponent gets has limited validity.

If you are a very good ball user and you are being tagged, generally, unless the tagger is Ling or Cornes, they have a lower skill base than you.

30 possessions to judd or Scotty will be much better than 30 possession to Pevril or Lockyer.......and they rarely get equal or more possessions, so usually it would be 30 to 20.

 

[one_twelve112]

Overrated: Thornton Russell Bentick
Underated: Fisher Saddington

 

[BlueYoss]

lol I thought I'd try your Sig URL just in case there was an actual site

AWESOME!!!!

It's the official unofficial Jarrad Waite fan club that I have done absolutely nothing about getting up and running -but I'm nonetheless fully committed to the cause.

Another few precious messages like yours and I might even make Audas (after seeing his work with those Carlton wallpapers) an indecent proposal to write some coding in exchange for warm flat beer -if he's drunk enough he may just go for it! Here's to hoping...

 

[Jimmy 2 Shoes]

strawberry pancakes...

underrated

 

[TorresIsGod]

underrated

Certainly a very interesting bump. Especially coming from a Geelong supporter, searching the depths of the greatest board of them all.

 

[I LOVE THE CFC]

Underated: Carlton FC

Overated: The bumping of this thread

 

[thylacine60]

Under: BF
Over: BF

Where's the balance?

 

[Silvagnis]

strawberry pancakes...

His ability as a flog was overrated.

 

[celtic_pride]

Underrated - Carrots, seriously he doesn't deserve all the flack and garbage he seems to cop week in, week out about his disposal, he gets the ball 30 - 35 times each week so he's bound to have a few clangers here and there (you will notice that Robert Harvey and Scott West weren't exactly the most reliable kicks of the footy either)

Overrated - Andrew Walker, I know he's had injuries but has yet to deliever on this talent and potential, and sometimes I wonder if he ever will.

 

[Blueinblood]

Under: Thornton

Over: Fisher

 

[Silvagnis]

Underated: Simpson and Thornton.

Overated: Stevens and Houlihan.

 

[Blue Dimension]

Underated - Thornton (all supporters) Bentick (amungst Carlton supporters) and Houlihan (amungst opposition supporters)

Overated - Wiggins (amungst Carlton supporters)

Adding to this...

Underated: Pfeiffer (cops a lot of crap and a fair bit of it is uncalled for tbh...he's not anywhere near as bad as everyone makes out)

Overated: Cameron Cloke (amungst Carlton supporters)

 

[Dustyjackman]

Under: Hadley.

Over: Stevens.

 

[Weiterbot23]

Underated = Gibbs, it would be impossible to overate him

 

[gbatman]

Overrated: Definitely Andrew Walker. His performances dont justify the massive wraps he gets on here.

A young player that has been injury plagued for at least the last two years and having to play in a crap team his whole career.
Dumb statement.

P.S. We are underrated as a team and most of our players are underrated as we are a young side, yet to make a name for ourselves. Things will change this year I recon.

 

[Sublime]

A young player that has been injury plagued for at least the last two years and having to play in a crap team his whole career.
Dumb statement.

The quote was made in 2007... a year and a half ago. I still think he is overrated compared to his output when on the park personally, not saying he is a bad player though of course.

 

[Artie Bucco]

The quote was made in 2007... a year and a half ago. I still think he is overrated compared to his output when on the park personally, not saying he is a bad player though of course.

I was saying that back then, and copped a caning

Let's hope he can make us look silly this year

 

[juzza316]

Underated: Carrazzo, Scotland and Simpson
Overated: Walker and Hampson

 

[barnesy_78]

Underated: Hadley

Overrated: Houlihan

Extremely Overrated: Cloke!!!!!