Unleash the truth ....

[sickzau]

This is not another murph thread its all the player's i think that dont deserve to ever put the hawthorn jumper as of immediate.


murph is by far the worst hawthorn player in a decade, he makes luke macabe look like voss, he makes kummel look like ablett, the simple fact the bloke can't do anything right. He Trips over his own feet, so bloody uncordinated, and his decision making is disgracefull, let alone his awareness around him.

Everytime murph has the ball i quiver, everytime his going up one on one in the square i concede it's a goal before the contest has even begun.

The bloke needs to be sent to the efl let alone vfl, i for one can not stand him and if this bloke get's another game at hawthorn then i must say that our selection commitee has to be the most ******ed commitee.

How simon Taylor gets a game is beyond me, i don't think anyone respects him as a player because his just as bad as barry hall * minus the punching etc. The bloke is a dead set moron. How can you justify a bloody ruckman conceding the most free kicks in the afl more then any other player just not on, and his bloody hitout work seems to always go to the opisition. Again i quiver and also am so bloody peeved off we keep giving him chance.

Dowler, has had to many bloody opurtunties and imo has showed NOTHING. He was recruited for his tank, overhead marking and his long accurate kicking. Apart from a semi size tank the bloke is also another player who has dumb decision making, can't kick for shite and can not read the play. Has had to many shots at it, cya mate off to trade you go.

Mitch Thorpe, Well we can we begin? Promise promise promise, yet all i see is SHIT, can't get on the park and when he does he just goes down again, another player we should look to trade for anything we can get for him.

Renouf, this elbow clapping clown is a spliting image of simon taylor, you cant blame the kid tho as he is learning for the dud himself, again his decision making, kicking and the bloke can not hit a dead set handball to a team mate from 3 mtrs.

Lets be frank here, most of you will jump out and say there young, they have havnt had the support of so and so, bottom line is our recruiting staff have made some woefull decisions as of late.

Imagine our side with the follow from past trades.

Selwood - Thorpe
Ryder - Dowler
Okeefe - Shoenmakers
We should have thrown the kitchen sink at carlton for thornton

Our list as of this year is over rated, apart from sewell, rioli and franklin everyone on our list is tradeable.

NOT A SINGLE PLAYER on our list has had a better season individually this year then they did last.

 

[macdaddio]

Re: unleash the truth

This is not another murph thread its all the player's i think that dont deserve to ever put the hawthorn jumper as of immediate.


murph is by far the worst hawthorn player in a decade, he makes luke macabe look like voss, he makes kummel look like ablett, the simple fact the bloke can't do anything right. He Trips over his own feet, so bloody uncordinated, and his decision making is disgracefull, let alone his awareness around him.



You must not have been following the hawks for very long then, i can tell you i am 37 years old and have seen the hawks rise in the late 70,s and 80,s and i can tell you there have been much much worse players than Murphy.
People like you who come in these forums and state claim to who is and who is not a good or bad player should go to the club and ask to speak to these players and tell them to their faces how you feel about them.

I am so over this Bigfooty forum and i have had enough of insults of our players, we are not the family loved club any more we are now the Ritchmond haters club that eat their own.

 

[TalkBox]

Re: unleash the truth

Lock it up mate. So we have a few under achieving blokes on our list, no one knew that already.

 

[sickzau]

Re: unleash the truth

haha well im sorry ive only been a supporter for 14 years and in that time i dont think ive seen anyone worse.

 

[macdaddio]

Re: unleash the truth

haha well im sorry ive only been a supporter for 14 years and in that time i dont think ive seen anyone worse.

In 14 years you have not seen any one worse then Murphy, so when you sat at the ground watching Dawson getting killed each week you thought he was a great asset to our club and at no stage you did not want him gone?
He is now playing good football but at hawthorn he was known as Zac the Hack.....

I cant honsetly beleive you have not seen any one worse sorry i but realy dont beleive you.........

 

[Roger Rogerson]

Re: unleash the truth

This is not another murph thread its all the player's i think that dont deserve to ever put the hawthorn jumper as of immediate.


murph is by far the worst hawthorn player in a decade, he makes luke macabe look like voss, he makes kummel look like ablett, the simple fact the bloke can't do anything right. He Trips over his own feet, so bloody uncordinated, and his decision making is disgracefull, let alone his awareness around him.

Everytime murph has the ball i quiver, everytime his going up one on one in the square i concede it's a goal before the contest has even begun.

The bloke needs to be sent to the efl let alone vfl, i for one can not stand him and if this bloke get's another game at hawthorn then i must say that our selection commitee has to be the most ******ed commitee.

How simon Taylor gets a game is beyond me, i don't think anyone respects him as a player because his just as bad as barry hall * minus the punching etc. The bloke is a dead set moron. How can you justify a bloody ruckman conceding the most free kicks in the afl more then any other player just not on, and his bloody hitout work seems to always go to the opisition. Again i quiver and also am so bloody peeved off we keep giving him chance.

Dowler, has had to many bloody opurtunties and imo has showed NOTHING. He was recruited for his tank, overhead marking and his long accurate kicking. Apart from a semi size tank the bloke is also another player who has dumb decision making, can't kick for shite and can not read the play. Has had to many shots at it, cya mate off to trade you go.

Mitch Thorpe, Well we can we begin? Promise promise promise, yet all i see is SHIT, can't get on the park and when he does he just goes down again, another player we should look to trade for anything we can get for him.

Renouf, this elbow clapping clown is a spliting image of simon taylor, you cant blame the kid tho as he is learning for the dud himself, again his decision making, kicking and the bloke can not hit a dead set handball to a team mate from 3 mtrs.

Lets be frank here, most of you will jump out and say there young, they have havnt had the support of so and so, bottom line is our recruiting staff have made some woefull decisions as of late.

Imagine our side with the follow from past trades.

Selwood - Thorpe
Ryder - Dowler
Okeefe - Shoenmakers
We should have thrown the kitchen sink at carlton for thornton

Our list as of this year is over rated, apart from sewell, rioli and franklin everyone on our list is tradeable.

NOT A SINGLE PLAYER on our list has had a better season individually this year then they did last.

I dont think you follow us very closely if you think Schoenmakers is a waste of a pick. The kid is a gem - YOU ARE NOT.

 

[Rioli magic]

Re: unleash the truth

Lol Murphy doesn't even play and he cops it. Look I understand your 14 and probably to immature to see the bigger picture, but this club delivered you a flag last year so you should be grateful and thanking them for it, they're obviously doing something right. If we're still performing like this when you are 19 feel free to whinge. And don't worry mate, we're the most successful club of the last 50 years, we're winners at Hawthorn you'll see plenty more flags in your lifetime, just not every year.

 

[macdaddio]

Re: unleash the truth

Lol Murphy doesn't even play and he cops it. Look I understand your 14 and probably to immature to see the bigger picture, but this club delivered you a flag last year so you should be grateful and thanking them for it, they're obviously doing something right. If we're still performing like this when you are 19 feel free to whinge. And don't worry mate, we're the most successful club of the last 50 years, we're winners at Hawthorn you'll see plenty more flags in your lifetime, just not every year.

This has been the best post i have read all year, you should hang around here more often.

 

[lethalselbow]

Re: unleash the truth

Unleash the puke.

What a steaming pile of embarrassing newbie dribble.

 

[Boot Studder]

Re: unleash the truth

Lol Murphy doesn't even play and he cops it. Look I understand your 14 and probably to immature to see the bigger picture, but this club delivered you a flag last year so you should be grateful and thanking them for it, they're obviously doing something right. If we're still performing like this when you are 19 feel free to whinge. And don't worry mate, we're the most successful club of the last 50 years, we're winners at Hawthorn you'll see plenty more flags in your lifetime, just not every year.

Thank you, Rioli magic!

 

[hawkstars]

Re: unleash the truth

Dodgy opening post.

 

[BaliHawk]

Re: unleash the truth

haha well im sorry ive only been a supporter for 14 years and in that time i dont think ive seen anyone worse.

you never watched Austin McCrabb....by far the WORST player to ever pull on a Hawks jumper, Murphy's OK he just is not up to the standard we expect or need, he is much better when his job is to cover the 3rd forward.

 

[Number 24]

Re: unleash the truth

Lol Murphy doesn't even play and he cops it. Look I understand your 14 and probably to immature to see the bigger picture, but this club delivered you a flag last year so you should be grateful and thanking them for it, they're obviously doing something right. If we're still performing like this when you are 19 feel free to whinge. And don't worry mate, we're the most successful club of the last 50 years, we're winners at Hawthorn you'll see plenty more flags in your lifetime, just not every year.

Perfectly said. I've only been following the Hawks for 55 years so I'm too old to know anything, the 14 year olds have it all over me

 

[rdhopkins2]

Re: unleash the truth

I really don't give a flying who is or has been our worse player. A little more positivity please.

Or maybe go set up your own forum called Emo Hawks?

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

I am fed up with reading anti-Murphy threads and posts on this forum. Anyone would think it is entirely his fault why we aren't playing finals in 2009. Give it a rest people.

 

[mustardnugget]

You're right... Now that we've broken Murphy in and he has 50 odd games under his belt we should delist him for StKilda to pick up next year so he come into his own like Dawson.

In case you missed the message in my post, you have no foresight.

 

[pricefixer]

You're right... Now that we've broken Murphy in and he has 50 odd games under his belt we should delist him for StKilda to pick up next year so he come into his own like Dawson.

In case you missed the message in my post, you have no foresight.

No club would consider picking up Murphy.

I don't blame Murphy as he is glaringly short of being an AFL footballer but rather Clarkson's stubbornness in continuing to pick him. And yes, Murphy has definitely cost the club games this season - a season that has been marked by some level of misfortune with injuries but despite this the club should still should have played finals with the blue chip assets it has.

For the record, Maccdadio I've been following the club longer then you and Murphy would be up there with my all time worst players to pull on a Hawthorn jumper.

 

[halfback dasher]

This is not another murph thread its all the player's i think that dont deserve to ever put the hawthorn jumper as of immediate.


murph is by far the worst hawthorn player in a decade, he makes luke macabe look like voss, he makes kummel look like ablett, the simple fact the bloke can't do anything right. He Trips over his own feet, so bloody uncordinated, and his decision making is disgracefull, let alone his awareness around him.

Everytime murph has the ball i quiver, everytime his going up one on one in the square i concede it's a goal before the contest has even begun.

The bloke needs to be sent to the efl let alone vfl, i for one can not stand him and if this bloke get's another game at hawthorn then i must say that our selection commitee has to be the most ******ed commitee.

How simon Taylor gets a game is beyond me, i don't think anyone respects him as a player because his just as bad as barry hall * minus the punching etc. The bloke is a dead set moron. How can you justify a bloody ruckman conceding the most free kicks in the afl more then any other player just not on, and his bloody hitout work seems to always go to the opisition. Again i quiver and also am so bloody peeved off we keep giving him chance.

Dowler, has had to many bloody opurtunties and imo has showed NOTHING. He was recruited for his tank, overhead marking and his long accurate kicking. Apart from a semi size tank the bloke is also another player who has dumb decision making, can't kick for shite and can not read the play. Has had to many shots at it, cya mate off to trade you go.

Mitch Thorpe, Well we can we begin? Promise promise promise, yet all i see is SHIT, can't get on the park and when he does he just goes down again, another player we should look to trade for anything we can get for him.

Renouf, this elbow clapping clown is a spliting image of simon taylor, you cant blame the kid tho as he is learning for the dud himself, again his decision making, kicking and the bloke can not hit a dead set handball to a team mate from 3 mtrs.

Lets be frank here, most of you will jump out and say there young, they have havnt had the support of so and so, bottom line is our recruiting staff have made some woefull decisions as of late.

Imagine our side with the follow from past trades.

Selwood - Thorpe
Ryder - Dowler
Okeefe - Shoenmakers
We should have thrown the kitchen sink at carlton for thornton

Our list as of this year is over rated, apart from sewell, rioli and franklin everyone on our list is tradeable.

NOT A SINGLE PLAYER on our list has had a better season individually this year then they did last.

You , my friend need to PISS OFF...iTS ONE THING TO BE DISILLUSION'D BY THE CLUB AND IT'S PLAYER'S...IT'S ANOTHER TO POST SHIT LIKE THIS.......HEAVEN HELP US IF AND WHEN YOU HAVE KIDS THAT ARN'T QUITE WHAT YOU HAD HOPED FOR .....IS THIS THE TYPE OF SUPPORT THEY CAN EXPECT.......????

 

[halfback dasher]

This is not another murph thread its all the player's i think that dont deserve to ever put the hawthorn jumper as of immediate.


murph is by far the worst hawthorn player in a decade, he makes luke macabe look like voss, he makes kummel look like ablett, the simple fact the bloke can't do anything right. He Trips over his own feet, so bloody uncordinated, and his decision making is disgracefull, let alone his awareness around him.

Everytime murph has the ball i quiver, everytime his going up one on one in the square i concede it's a goal before the contest has even begun.

The bloke needs to be sent to the efl let alone vfl, i for one can not stand him and if this bloke get's another game at hawthorn then i must say that our selection commitee has to be the most ******ed commitee.

How simon Taylor gets a game is beyond me, i don't think anyone respects him as a player because his just as bad as barry hall * minus the punching etc. The bloke is a dead set moron. How can you justify a bloody ruckman conceding the most free kicks in the afl more then any other player just not on, and his bloody hitout work seems to always go to the opisition. Again i quiver and also am so bloody peeved off we keep giving him chance.

Dowler, has had to many bloody opurtunties and imo has showed NOTHING. He was recruited for his tank, overhead marking and his long accurate kicking. Apart from a semi size tank the bloke is also another player who has dumb decision making, can't kick for shite and can not read the play. Has had to many shots at it, cya mate off to trade you go.

Mitch Thorpe, Well we can we begin? Promise promise promise, yet all i see is SHIT, can't get on the park and when he does he just goes down again, another player we should look to trade for anything we can get for him.

Renouf, this elbow clapping clown is a spliting image of simon taylor, you cant blame the kid tho as he is learning for the dud himself, again his decision making, kicking and the bloke can not hit a dead set handball to a team mate from 3 mtrs.

Lets be frank here, most of you will jump out and say there young, they have havnt had the support of so and so, bottom line is our recruiting staff have made some woefull decisions as of late.

Imagine our side with the follow from past trades.

Selwood - Thorpe
Ryder - Dowler
Okeefe - Shoenmakers
We should have thrown the kitchen sink at carlton for thornton

Our list as of this year is over rated, apart from sewell, rioli and franklin everyone on our list is tradeable.

NOT A SINGLE PLAYER on our list has had a better season individually this year then they did last.

OH....and yes im wait'n for the CARD IN THE MAIL......

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Well you don't have to like everyone, and people have a right to an opinion, but slagging the shit out of people is pathetic.

Mods - any chance we can stop this guy starting threads? Forever?

 

[macdaddio]

No club would consider picking up Murphy.

I don't blame Murphy as he is glaringly short of being an AFL footballer but rather Clarkson's stubbornness in continuing to pick him. And yes, Murphy has definitely cost the club games this season - a season that has been marked by some level of misfortune with injuries but despite this the club should still should have played finals with the blue chip assets it has.

For the record, Maccdadio I've been following the club longer then you and Murphy would be up there with my all time worst players to pull on a Hawthorn jumper.

You are about lose this arguement if you wana go down that path, but i will let you believe what you want to believe your opinion does not make it true..

All i can say is that in over 27 years that i have supported this great club i have seen far worse players than Murphy, and i will give you 1 example, Josh Thurgood now if you are going to tell me that Josh thurgood was a better player than Murphy then you are seriously talking crap.

 

[pricefixer]

Josh Thurgood was a better footballer than Murphy.

 

[macdaddio]

Josh Thurgood was a better footballer than Murphy.

Like i said you can believe what you want to believe but it won't make it any difference to me at all.

 

[HChawk72]

For what its worth, I will see all the Thomas Murphy's and Austin McCrabb's and Greg Madigan's and I will raise you a

SIMON CRAWSHAY....

and I'm going all in...

Without a doubt the greatest cabbage to ever play senior football at the hawks. Just Horrible...

 

[pricefixer]

Like i said you can believe what you want to believe but it won't make it any difference to me at all.

You obviously didn't see Thurgood at BHHs in 2004. He was everything you could want in a HBF - courageous, great run, terrific in the air, fantastic decision making on when to take the game on. Probably, the best season I've seen from a BHHs player, hence the reason he got up-graded for 2005 onto the main list. Was still a good player until he had his jaw smashed by Lloyd in 2005, after being roughed up in the pre-season by St.Kilda. Admittedly, it was a brief window in which his star shone but I'd rather that then to be given 19 games in the firsts and to have been a liability in all of those games.

Whilst, I don't care for the OP's overall spray, I'll say this about Murphy's 19 games this season, they are as close to the worst I can remember from a player getting a regular game for this club.