Bumped Unpopular Opinions: Collingwood (new posts start at #691)

[Shaneprice97]

I'll start.
Paul Seedsman is currently a better footballer than Heritier Lumumba.

[Mod Edit] Poll added

 

[MeisterBot]

Broomhead may displace Sidebottom in 2015. Rusty may end up being trade bait.

 

[Vicky Park]

Another split round thread, but thats OK.

I never liked Brodie Holland and hate that he played for us. There, I've said it.

Oh - and now I'm really in trouble - congrats to Caro for winning Australian Journalist of the Year yesterday for her outstanding work in 2013 on the Essendon drugs saga.

 

[Jonno94]

We could easily miss the 8 this year.

 

[Baird]

Nick Maxwell will 20&3 this season

 

[mike123]

Tony Armstrong should play against Sydney

If this isn't the most unpopular opinion what is?

 

[Jonno94]

Tony Armstrong should play against Sydney

If this isn't the most unpopular opinion what is?

Well done Tony, you win the thread.

 

[pies1958]

This year feels like 1999 all over again.

Bucks was given a premiership team and did nothing with it.

Bucks = Tony Shaw

The Collingwood team is like a merry go round, young kids getting on, young kids getting off. Every time I turn around there's another new player.

I'm afraid st kilda will beat us this year.

 

[Bring_Back_Brad]

Is there some sort of amnesty for expression of unpopular opinions in this thread?

 

[Baird]

Josh Thomas > Taylor Adams

Good thread Pricey btw

 

[Maggie5]

Another split round thread, but thats OK.

I never liked Brodie Holland and hate that he played for us. There, I've said it.

Oh - and now I'm really in trouble - congrats to Caro for winning Australian Journalist of the Year yesterday for her outstanding work in 2013 on the Essendon drugs saga.

Sorry VP, only half a "like", Brodie is a great guy, met him several times and he loves the pies.

 

[Maggie5]

Trade the Fas to Carlton for Gibbs.

 

[blaze036]

Swan and Seedsmen are heavily overrated because no one takes into account their terrible defensive games

 

[blaze036]

Trade the Fas to Carlton for Gibbs.

They would ask for a 1st rounder as well

 

[mike123]

Josh Fraser should have played in 2010 not Leigh Brown

 

[Markfs]

Another split round thread, but thats OK.

I never liked Brodie Holland and hate that he played for us. There, I've said it.

Oh - and now I'm really in trouble - congrats to Caro for winning Australian Journalist of the Year yesterday for her outstanding work in 2013 on the Essendon drugs saga.

Very good call. Collingwood players should never do modelling. He looked like Pat Cash too.... which is another problem

 

[Maggie5]

They would ask for a 1st rounder as well

No way! They don't want him any way and he also wants to play finals with good team.

 

[Scodog10]

I would move Gary Pert on at years end.

IMO he has taken too much of a back seat since the handover to Buckley and hasn't done enough publicly to smooth over potential frayed relations. It's compounded by the fact that whenever we hear public comment on a Collingwood related matter it always comes from our president. It isn't good business for mine!

Due to the massive support we lend as supporters the club practically runs itself and we are now seeing ever diminishing benefits from the money we invest in the club. A change of direction at management level would do us some good.

 

[Seedsfan]

Trade the Fas to Carlton for Gibbs.

Fas is going to be 10 times the player Gibbs is

 

[Seedsfan]

Josh Fraser should have played in 2010 not Leigh Brown

They would have let him if he wanted it, he wanted to be the number one ruck not the second ruck. I felt so bad for him on grand final day always one of my favorites growing up and I thought he gave so much in 02 as well

 

[TradeDraft]

I'll start.
Paul Seedsman is currently a better footballer than Heritier Lumumba.

and I agree with you

 

[blaze036]

No way! They don't want him any way and he also wants to play finals with good team.

Fasolo doesn't have much value at the moment

 

[TradeDraft]

Josh Thomas > Taylor Adams

Good thread Pricey btw

That is a very interesting one there and at the moment you may be right but in the Long Run I see Adams being the better player

 

[mike123]

I'll start.
Paul Seedsman is currently a better footballer than Heritier Lumumba.

Seedsman must be pretty good then cause Lumumba is coming off his career best season

 

[SApies]

Goldsack + Sidebottom should be used as trade bait at season end.