News Update: Confirmed - Victoria v Allstars, February 28th, Marvel Stadium, broadcast on 7 & Fox

Remove this Banner Ad

Official game day thread for the Vic v All-Stars match:

 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The newly revealed All Stars logo is an aesthetically pleasing and clever concept. However, it shouldn't be used as the central focus of the jumper. The individual player's State of Origin should be the central display, housed neatly on a shared white and gold uniform. In addition, Allies is a nice name than All Stars. It generates comradeship between states while the SoO element enforces individual state pride.

Here's something I've whipped up as an example.

View attachment 824819

Good to see a map of Tassie on a jumper again
 
Those 3 have good enough excuses.

Kelly has never played a game for us, we probably want him to get some time with the team in proper match practice.

Kennedy has had plenty of injury issues in last few years and he isn't getting any younger. Hawkins, Tex and Riewoldt plus Lycett as Grundy will be rocking more often than not is tall enough for the forward line.

Hurn probably snubbed the AFL like they snubbed him last 2 years for the AA captain! :)


Gil pretty much admitted Hurn was originally selected as AA captain..but his failure to attend led to a last minute change to the claytons captain
 
It's just a shame so many "all-stars" are injured. Buddy, Heeney, McGovern, Darling, Tom Mitchell & Mitch Duncan would make them much better if fit.

It's disappointing West Coast haven't come to the party like Richmond & GWS though. Tim Kelly, JJK & Hurn would be handy.

Rampe & Zac Williams should be there too.


Good on the Richmond players...a game at Marvel is a rare away game..hope the 10 min taxi ride is not to daunting for them
 

Log in to remove this ad.

It's just a shame so many "all-stars" are injured. Buddy, Heeney, McGovern, Darling, Tom Mitchell & Mitch Duncan would make them much better if fit.

It's disappointing West Coast haven't come to the party like Richmond & GWS though. Tim Kelly, JJK & Hurn would be handy.

Rampe & Zac Williams should be there too.

Daniel Rich would have been handy in the back line linking up with Harris

Surprised McCluggage wasn't picked for the Vics
 
No has had a go at the actual lineup-

Victoria:

B: Houli Moore Sicily

HB: Whitfield Haynes Saad

C: Macrae Martin Kelly

HF: Greene Cameron Gray

FF: Papley Lynch Dangerfield

R: Goldstein Bontempelli Pendlebury

Bench: Blicavs, Cunnington, Cotchin, Gresham, Higgins, Lloyd, S.Martin, Sidebottom, Sloan.



Allstars:

B: Laird Andrews Jetta

HB: Johannisen Howe Edwards

C: Hill Cripps Coniglio

HF: Yeo Riewoldt Breust

FF: Cameron Hawkins Zorko

R: Grundy Fyfe Neal

Inter: lycett, Mills, Sheppard, I.Smith,B.Smith, Tuohy, Walker, Walters, Weller.
 
Ablett should be omitted as his last few months in 2019 were not exactly impressive. He isn't in the top level of midfielders anymore. At best he can show glimpses every so often of the player he once was.
That Ablett was omitted after publically stating he wanted to play indicates that they are taking it a little bit seriously. Given injuries etc, I think the squads are very impressive.
 
Last edited:
All tickets are $20. Expect it'll get a healthy crowd and fools go "SeA PeOpLe WAnt Itt mAyke it PermANENT!" but the AFL won't.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Quick stab at potential line ups

VICS

B - Jake Lloyd - Darcy Moore - James Sicily
HB - Bachar Houli - Nick Haynes - Lachie Whitfield
C - Josh Kelly - Patrick Dangerfield - Steele Sidebottom
HF - Dustin Martin - Jeremy Cameron - Shaun Higgins
F - Toby Greene - Tom Lynch - Robbie Gray
R - Todd Goldstein - Marcus Bontempelli - Scott Pendlebury
INT - Mark Blicavs - Ben Cunnington - Trent Cotchin - Jade Gresham - Jack Macrae - Stefan Martin - Tom Papley - Rory Sloane - Adam Saad

ALL STARS

B - Brad Sheppard - Jeremy Howe - Rory Laird
HB - Shane Edwards - Harris Andrews - Zac Tuohy
C - Stephen Coniglio - Patrick Cripps - Elliott Yeo
HF - Michael Walters - Jack Riewoldt - Dayne Zorko
F - Charlie Cameron - Tom Hawkins - Luke Breust
R - Brodie Grundy - Nat Fyfe - Lachie Neale
INT - Bradley Hill - Neville Jetta - Jason Johannisen - Scott Lycett - Callum Mills - Isaac Smith - Brodie Smith - Taylor Walker - Lachie Weller
 
Because its a state of origin game AND a charity game, hence the name "State of Origin". People are criticizing the state of origin part, not the charity part. If it was a true state of origin, you'd probably see even more money raised. I'd have my WA jersey on preorder already.
Relax mate. It's just a game and a form of entertainment. Think of those who have suffered through this fire s**t.
 
Tex being selected is taking the P155
Josh Kennedy said he would have liked to play but the Eagles quota had been filled and he had missed out.That was a few weeks ago in the news here so Longmire likes Tex and wants to lose so the Victorians can have a feel good wank session for charity. spose.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top