Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Vent & Offtopic

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sunny_
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

TJ Hendricks said:
Wouldn't the MCG ANZAC game be kinda hard to get into? I kinda figured that would be a hot ticket.
Click to expand...

They generally sell out within the first few days, but the re-release which doesnt quite sell out, 3 days before
 
I know I can be a bit doom and gloom from time to time but we seriously need to get our shit together ASAP. Many of our young guns are restricted free agents next year and even more the year after. If we aren't showing a significant up swing soon I can see many of these guys looking for greener pastures
 
Iva Bigun said:
I know I can be a bit doom and gloom from time to time but we seriously need to get our shit together ASAP. Many of our young guns are restricted free agents next year and even more the year after. If we aren't showing a significant up swing soon I can see many of these guys looking for greener pastures
Click to expand...

Just like last year, a really important period after the bye.
Just like last year, good chance we will be out of it by then, looking at our draw.

But last year we did show some good signs and there was enough optimism around the play.

Frustrating that we are back in the same place, having to show something in the back half of the year.

Need to play some good games down the stretch with some of the injured players getting a run. Otherwise it could get a bit ugly and we end up losing both the players that are not good enough and a few good players that have had enough.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

We showed some good stuff before injury woes once again stifled the team. But I do get the impression that free agency will cause some salt in the wound, although I am left wondering who would be interested in getting any of our heavily injury prone players. And if they'll suddenly become more awesome and less injury prone once they're at another club (notably, one thing I have noticed from Smith at Geelong is that he seems to be getting on the park more often than when he was at the Suns, hmm).
 
jackenny said:
We showed some good stuff before injury woes once again stifled the team. But I do get the impression that free agency will cause some salt in the wound, although I am left wondering who would be interested in getting any of our heavily injury prone players. And if they'll suddenly become more awesome and less injury prone once they're at another club (notably, one thing I have noticed from Smith at Geelong is that he seems to be getting on the park more often than when he was at the Suns, hmm).
Click to expand...
Smith played every single game for us last year mostly in Reserves.
Apart from the major knee injury (purely bad luck) he was virtually never injured.
 
eppo67 said:
Smith played every single game for us last year mostly in Reserves.
Apart from the major knee injury (purely bad luck) he was virtually never injured.
Click to expand...
Didn't see the game but champion data has Zac Smith 120 and Sam Jacobs 79 tonight, for whatever that's worth.
 
Fidel Cashflow said:
Didn't see the game but champion data has Zac Smith 120 and Sam Jacobs 79 tonight, for whatever that's worth.
Click to expand...
DT points has Jacobs 108 Smith 80.
I don't know why people think Smith is an example of the club player recruitment failures. Smith quit the club and asked for trade he was offered a contact by GCFC.
He rejected that because he didn't want to compete for his position at GC. So he chose to go to a club with no Rucks and would have zero competition for his position and would get a game pretty much regardless of how little he does.
 
eppo67 said:
DT points has Jacobs 108 Smith 80.
I don't know why people think Smith is an example of the club player recruitment failures. Smith quit the club and asked for trade he was offered a contact by GCFC.
He rejected that because he didn't want to compete for his position at GC. So he chose to go to a club with no Rucks and would have zero competition for his position and would get a game pretty much regardless of how little he does.
Click to expand...
More to do with development failure. DT is akin to NEAFL stats.
 
eppo67 said:
Are you suggesting Primus is not a good Ruck Coach . LOL
Anyway l think you might find the AAAAA midfield at his feet is grossly overinflating his performances.
Click to expand...
Primus couldn't teach a dog to bark.
You're right about the midfield making them look good though.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

TJ Hendricks said:
I share a birthday with Ablett and Boomer.... I'm destined for footy greatness.... Gold Coast I'm all yours don't waste this lottery ticket
Click to expand...
Another way to look at is 2 out of 3 ain't bad ;)

Happy Birthday
 
Iva Bigun said:
Is it time to dump our gurnsey, it has the stank of failure all over it, maybe a Power style reboot could break the stench and allow us to start tp heal, thoughts?
Click to expand...
yep, would agree with this. i've never been a fan of our guernsey, looks real basic. majority of professional sporting clubs don't have their main logo plastered front and centre on their shirt/guernsey.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

vide0n said:
Think it's best to just scrap all expectations at this point and take any improvement we can.
Click to expand...
Would stopping going backwards at such a huge rate of knots qualify as Improvement. We can't even claim that at the moment
 
Last year we had the usual stars out including Ablett & Prestia but at least we were really competitive. Something like 210 inside 50's to 108 the past 3 weeks.
It's draining watching the same players make the same skill errors every week for 6 years. Yet we have the same assistant coaches.
And if anyone can please tell me why Eade/Clayton would extend Seb's contract by 1 year if he can't get a game with the injuries we have?
We sign up Grant under free agency - only after his club delisted him because they couldnt gwt a trade. We sign up a 30+ player on 3 years when 17 other clubs said 2 maximum.
We reward mediocrity.
 
Until the Ashcroft/Clayton regime has been removed from the club, I'm not sure when the ship will turn around? How can they not come out and acknowledge that a change of direction is required? Half our players cant get the ball or tackle...we have got a list build issue.

I don't think it's necessary a culture or coaching issue anymore, this got resolved 12-18 months ago. Performances have been there, the coaching has been there. Only a month ago we beat one of the best clubs of the past few years, and one of the best coaches of the past decade - irrespective of form in Freo. I'm hanging onto that for now. I don't put so much heat on the playing group as a whole, because I think the majority "try". I just don't think we have enough footballers.
 
supernova_ said:
Until the Ashcroft/Clayton regime has been removed from the club, I'm not sure when the ship will turn around? How can they not come out and acknowledge that a change of direction is required? Half our players cant get the ball or tackle...we have got a list build issue.

I don't think it's necessary a culture or coaching issue anymore, this got resolved 12-18 months ago. Performances have been there, the coaching has been there. Only a month ago we beat one of the best clubs of the past few years, and one of the best coaches of the past decade - irrespective of form in Freo. I'm hanging onto that for now. I don't put so much heat on the playing group as a whole, because I think the majority "try". I just don't think we have enough footballers.
Click to expand...
If you add the 12 to 15 of the best 22 missing and playing injured into that team it is a completely different team. Completely different and unrecognisable to yesterday's team. We are in just as bad a position or worst player availability wise as Essendon.
 
eppo67 said:
If you add the 12 to 15 of the best 22 missing and playing injured into that team it is a completely different team. Completely different and unrecognisable to yesterday's team. We are in just as bad a position or worst player availability wise as Essendon.
Click to expand...
Oh I agree completely. BUT after our best 20 or so - the next 20 players on our list cant tackle or get the ball! Hence why I have been frustrated for a couple years on the players we recruit/list management.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom