VFL VFL Round 16 v Geelong - Saturday July 13th. 1:05pm @ Victoria Park

[3066]

Yarra Council seems to hate Vic Park

Why do you think that?

 

[TradeDraft]

Why do you think that?

Refusal to make it better

They Knocked back an Upgrade at Vic Park to have a Home for the AFL Umps

 

[stormskye]

Is Macrae any better now than he was 3 years ago?

Unfortunately hasn’t tracked as a mid is required to.

When you look at players like Warner (pick 39…) and gulden for Sydney running around who are basically fins age, you realise the stark difference that exists. Can’t argue pick range, you either have it or you don’t.

Macrae is a good vfl mid, like sillivan. But will never match it with the best.

We’ve tried a few this year, but the quality of them just ain’t there

 

[Magnanimous]

Reef just has to be played.
The exact type of player wearegoing to need moving forward.

Just play him and give him a decent opportunity.

Sent from my SM-A556E using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The Kaiser Chief]

Most VFL listed player last are Crap and just Local Footballers

yep - blame the VFL lads..........

 

[The Kaiser Chief]

How do you know that?

would you take him if you were in charge at another club?

 

[jmac70]

would you take him if you were in charge at another club?

I think there would be some interest. Clearly has talent.

 

[The Kaiser Chief]

I think there would be some interest. Clearly has talent.

27 years old. Absolutley has talent but age goes against him.

 

[BillyElliott]

27 years old. Absolutley has talent but age goes against him.

Age goes against him at 27?

 

[Fat Jesus]

27 years old. Absolutley has talent but age goes against him.

At his prime age "IF" he can get his head together. Has the talent but perhaps not the drive.
I'd try him off HB in the VFL.
It can't hurt

 

[The Kaiser Chief]

Age goes against him at 27?

if you are wanting to trade him

 

[Fat Jesus]

if you are wanting to trade him

At his current output he is not worth much. Sadly

 

[Jen2310]

Someone get this man on a list

 

[No SPIN]

Someone get this man on a list

No right foot gets him regularly exposed which as a backman is my concern.
But can play fwd so versatility is a plus.

 

[TW Sherrin]

Unfortunately hasn’t tracked as a mid is required to.

When you look at players like Warner (pick 39…) and gulden for Sydney running around who are basically fins age, you realise the stark difference that exists. Can’t argue pick range, you either have it or you don’t.

Macrae is a good vfl mid, like sillivan. But will never match it with the best.

We’ve tried a few this year, but the quality of them just ain’t there

Warner and Gulden both have something you can't teach. speed.

Macrae and Sullivan are average at best.

 

[Jen2310]

Onya Reef! He was brilliant once they unleashed him up the ground

 

[Robroy22]

No right foot gets him regularly exposed which as a backman is my concern.
But can play fwd so versatility is a plus.

Like Benny Reid? Maynard, Kiddy Coleman, Saad, Newman, there's been a few...particularly of late. He's not quick enough for a forward but he's pretty safe behind the ball and he uses it particularly well.

 

[No SPIN]

Like Benny Reid? Maynard, Kiddy Coleman, Saad, Newman, there's been a few...particularly of late. He's not quick enough for a forward but he's pretty safe behind the ball and he uses it particularly well.

Saad, Newman Coleman are all smaller quicker and more evasive, and can turn out of trouble.
Maynard can kick on his right.
As a tall but less mobile back man I think Glover will unfortunately be exposed.