Viney, Oliver, Petracca, Brayshaw...have a go at picking the order of best

[Marc_Remillard]

...Because I have nfi. Every time I think one is better than the others, the other three smash it

Good problem to have

 

[Cannon82]

Hard to list them at the moment because they're all playing terrible football. Putting it on paper right now - not one of them will be on an AFL list in two years' time.

 

[ABray10]

The only thing I can say for sure is that Petracca does not currently deserve to have his name mentioned with the other 3.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Hogan

 

[cougar000]

Didn’t roosey say once he always thought Brayshaw should have been pick 1. Kids a gun. This I seen on the saints thing about today. Brayshaw and Petracca 59 disposals 6 goals between them. FMD.

 

[DeesFanTheMan]

Too hard atm

 

[TheCount]

They're all ours, so I honestly don't care.

 

[Proper Gander]

Hogan/Brayshaw
Viney

Lever/Hibberd
Track

Others

I have no idea

 

[Johnny Karate]

The four horsemen of the Deepocalypse ramming it down Jesus Hogan’s throat. Sounds about right.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

The four horsemen of the Deepocalypse ramming it down Jesus Hogan’s throat. Sounds about right.

That sounds like a dodgey 1970's Swedish pr0n movie.

But then again, was there any non-dodgey 1970's Swedish pr0n movies?

 

[sledbomber]

1. Oliver
2. Viney
3. CP5
4. Gus

 

[schmuttt]

Oliver is still the best but far out I'm so happy Brayshaw has come on, and Viney looks like the foot hasn't affected him long term at all.

 

[Fork n Hell]

I reckon we shouldn't underestimate Vineys leadership, attack on the ball, and the man, and his ability to break clear of the contest with raw power. he's our no1 imo. Oliver a close 2nd, so consistent at winning the ball and competing all day. Brayshaw 3rd, he has the best mix of an inside/outside game of all our mids. Petracca has a few things to work on but with his mix of power, size and talent, could easily go past them all with another season or 2 under his belt.

 

[Cannon82]

1. Oliver
2. Viney
3. CP5
4. Gus

If we're going off the last month:

1. Oliver
2. Viney
3. Gus
...
4. Petracca

Long term, I think Oliver and then Petracca have the higher ceilings. Viney and Gus will keep doing what they're doing, hopefully more consistently.

 

[Robos]

Olivers hands are amazing, a true midfielder
Viney, adds some real grunt in the engine room the Dees really need
Gus, doesnt quite have the 2 above, but might gather possessions like Mitchell
Petracca, Love him as a forward with a strong grab and leap, can only see him as a part time mid.

 

[Tempy Tiger]

Right now I’d say Clarry first by miles, then Gus, Viney and Trac in that order. All guns.

 

[Tempy Tiger]

Clarry had ten tackles yesterday. It’s not possible for me to love him more.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Clarry had ten tackles yesterday. It’s not possible for me to love him more.

He’s still hugely underrated outside of the club. A lock for AA at this stage

 

[jhong]

Our very own Rat Pack . Viney the leader of the pack . Nice

 

[harry000]

The only thing I can say for sure is that Petracca does not currently deserve to have his name mentioned with the other 3.

Respectfully as possible, I think this is BS

 

[stEdy]

Oliver is the number one

In the next year or two he'll realise he can just run through/around everyone with his speed and power and get out in space where he can use his really good leg and then he'll be Judd 2.0 with his ball winning/handling ability. He's also surprisingly good overhead

 

[Captain Jack]

Too hard atm

Sorting them is difficult too

 

[DeesFanTheMan]

Sorting them is difficult too

At least my blood flow has redistributed and I can think on the problem clearly now. Still no idea.

 

[LeverPuller]

Need more Salem love in here.

 

[liamjurrah]

Petracca is probably best suited to the josh caddy type.