So now that Buckley she coaching career is basically done who was the best coach of the three?
Does their coaching contributions change how you rate them in regards to overall football cotnribution?
Do you think clubs will now learn from hiring favourite sons to head coaching positions only a couple of years after retirement?
I will rate crazy Vossy the best coach simply cos he didn't take one of the youngest premiership teams of all time and completely dismantled it. And yet Buckley still rates higher then Hirdy for obvious reasons.
After their playing careers I had them ranked 1) Voss, 2) Hird and 3) Buckley.
As for their contribution to football it's now 1) Voss, 2) Buckley 3) Hird.
As for the last question. The answer is No. Pendlebury will be coaching the pies in 5 years time. Just like favourite sons Buckley and Shaw before him.
Does their coaching contributions change how you rate them in regards to overall football cotnribution?
Do you think clubs will now learn from hiring favourite sons to head coaching positions only a couple of years after retirement?
I will rate crazy Vossy the best coach simply cos he didn't take one of the youngest premiership teams of all time and completely dismantled it. And yet Buckley still rates higher then Hirdy for obvious reasons.
After their playing careers I had them ranked 1) Voss, 2) Hird and 3) Buckley.
As for their contribution to football it's now 1) Voss, 2) Buckley 3) Hird.
As for the last question. The answer is No. Pendlebury will be coaching the pies in 5 years time. Just like favourite sons Buckley and Shaw before him.
Last edited: