Votes For The Lions Game

[CatFan79]

I cannot believe some of you don't have Scarlett in the votes

Or Bartel..

But they have Mackie. He played way too loose on Notting and turned the ball over constantly.. I guess people are fooled by possession counts??

5. Bartel
4. Scarlett
3. Kelly
2. Corey
1. Taylor

 

[Cohzee]

Or Bartel..

But they have Mackie. He played way too loose on Notting and turned the ball over constantly.. I guess people are fooled by possession counts??

5. Bartel
4. Scarlett
3. Kelly
2. Corey
1. Taylor

Mackie had some sloppy disposals, but showed alot of signs that he is on track to getting back into last years form.

 

[bingle]

5. David Wojcinski
4. Andrew Mackie
3. James Kelly
2. Jimmy Bartel
1. Paul Chapman

 

[Partridge]

5. James Kelly
4. Matthew Scarlett
3. Joel Corey
2. Andrew Mackie
1. Jimmy Bartel

Thought Kelly was brilliant again. Last year's finals series has been the making of him, he's getting more possessions, using it better, and his workrate when he doesn't have it is sensational. I think he's now the best tackler in the side. Always pins the guy, and virtually never gives away frees.

Overall, crap first quarter (as usual), but the last half was pretty solid. Still a long way short of our best though. Forwards need to do a lot more.

 

[djlowz]

Mackie? You have to be kidding.. Had a lot of disposals but every single one of them was pus.. I thought he played one of his worst games. Scarlett was very good one on one against Bradshaw but didn't show his usual flair coming out of defence.

My votes are as follows -

5. Bartel (was one of the only players who made good decisions all day and had clean hands)
4. Corey (workhorse as usual and I thought played well)
3. Ling (Did his job against Power and chipped in for some handy and good possessions)
2. Rooke (Showed why he should be part of the team with his intensity - when you want the ball that bad you get it)
1. Kelly (Continued his consistent form)

I was also very impressed with Taylor and Mumford, signs look good..

 

[Last Line Hero]

Mackie? You have to be kidding.. Had a lot of disposals but every single one of them was pus.. I thought he played one of his worst games. Scarlett was very good one on one against Bradshaw but didn't show his usual flair coming out of defence.

My votes are as follows -

5. Bartel (was one of the only players who made good decisions all day and had clean hands)
4. Corey (workhorse as usual and I thought played well)
3. Ling (Did his job against Power and chipped in for some handy and good possessions)
2. Rooke (Showed why he should be part of the team with his intensity - when you want the ball that bad you get it)
1. Kelly (Continued his consistent form)

I was also very impressed with Taylor and Mumford, signs look good..

Geez mate.

Scarlett had 20 touches at 90% efficiency, and held the game's most in- form and dominating full- forward to 1 goal off 3 kicks. If he hadn't, the result may very well have gone the other way.

He was sensational.

What more does he have to do? Your'e a harsh critic.

 

[djlowz]

Geez mate.

Scarlett had 20 touches at 90% efficiency, and held the game's most in- form and dominating full- forward to 1 goal off 3 kicks. If he hadn't, the result may very well have gone the other way.

He was sensational.

What more does he have to do? Your'e a harsh critic.

Harsh? I'd hate to think what you think of me when I actually criticize someone. I said he was good but didn't show his usual flair, which I think is true - made a few sloppy decisions (possibly moreso because of the lack of forward movement). But I certainly never said nor thought he played badly.

 

[thegerman]

F*k a lot of the voters here are worse than the umpires.
Scarlett kept the 2nd best forward this season to 1 goal, & racked up some quality possesions.

What is worse is that most have given Mackie 4 or 5. Sure he did get a lot of the ball, however his possessions in the first half were well below par. Several handballs were direct turnovers or put his team-mate under severe pressure.

He took a backwards step in the first half, back to the style he was playing in 06. If memory fails you, that was packing himself whenever he took possession and giving it up.

Luckily he turned it around enough in the last, though IMO not enough to get the major points.

 

[rocker_oz33]

my votes

jimmy great game jimmy
joel worked hard all day
Scarlett great game kept bradshaw to one goal,but did make sum mistakes
kelly got heaps of ball and did some good things
makie got heaps of ball but turned it over to much still needs to get better

also harry,mummy,rooke were good as well

 

[ripitup27]

5. J.Bartel
4. M.Scarlett
3. J.Kelly
2. J.Corey
1. D.Wojcinski

 

[noclashjumpers]

5. Kelly
4. Corey
3. Bartel
2. Scarlett
1. Stokes