MVP Votes PF vs Dogs

Remove this Banner Ad

RossFC

Moderator
May 23, 2012
63,688
106,939
Alberton Oval
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Liverpool
5 - Bonner
4 - Wines
3 - Houston
2 - Bergman
1 - Marshall

RossFC PAFC 2021 POTY Leaderboard (Winner Ollie Wines)
(More or less votes compared to last year in brackets)

78 - Wines (+55)
33 - Aliir
27 - Boak (-20)
26 - Amon (+19)
24 - Drew
20 - Dixon (+1), Gray (+5)
15 - Houston (+6)
14 - Bergman
13 - Georgiades (+5)
12 - Jonas (+1)
10 - McKenzie (+10), Fantasia
8 - Ladhams (-2)
7 - Butters (-7)
6 - Bonner (+6)
5 - Motlop (-3), Lycett (+4), Marshall (+2)
4 - Clurey (+2), Powell-Pepper (-17), Rozee (-5)
3 - Farrell (-1)
2 - Duursma (-10), Burton (+2)
1 - Jones, Frederick, Mayes (-1)
0 - Byrne-Jones (-17), Rockliff (-16), Hartlett (-7), Woodcock (-2), Lienert (-1), Williams, McEntee


2020
47 - Boak
23 - Wines
21 - Powell-Pepper
19 - Dixon
17 - Byrne-Jones
16 - Rockliff
15 - Gray
14 - Butters
12 - Duursma
11 - Jonas
10 - Ladhams
9 - Houston, Rozee, Ebert
8 - Westhoff, Georgiades, Motlop
7 - Amon, Hartlett
4 - Farrell
3 - Marshall
2 - Clurey, Mayes, Woodcock
1 - Lycett, Lienert
0 - Burton, McKenzie, Bonner, Sutcliffe
 

RussellEbertHandball

Flick pass expert
Nov 16, 2004
69,508
107,023
SE Oz
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
The Mighty Blacks
5 Bonner
4 wines.

I will fill the rest out later.

Edit never did fill out last 3. My placings vs clubs. I gave DBJ 3 votes for equal 21st club gave him 125 for 8th.

Wines
65​
229​
1​
Aliir
32​
164​
3​
Drew
31​
Amon
27​
146​
4​
Dixon
24​
123​
9​
Jonas
21​
137​
5​
Boak
20​
167​
2​
Lycett
19​
120​
10​
Gray
16​
Georgi
12​
Berg
11​
Houston
10​
132​
6​
Mckenzie
8​
Burton
6​
132​
6​
 
Last edited:

Log in to remove this ad.

EskimoPAFC

Norm Smith Medallist
Dec 17, 2017
8,485
20,436
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Bonner
Marshall
Houston
Wines

Drew? Pistol? Who knows

Actually nah my fifth vote goes to Pep. The medi sub who came on late gets a vote.
 

PJ Power

Brownlow Medallist
Oct 13, 2003
22,818
30,549
Adelaide
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
5. Bonner
4. Wines

I thought Houston and Bergman had shockers. Houston was pathetic really - starting with that contested mark he conceded by falling over in the goal square in the first quarter and punctuated by countless dropped marks.
-5 Houston to offset any positive votes he gets given by other posters.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Papa G

Brownlow Medallist
Apr 13, 2006
28,199
61,804
The Bitter End
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really not understanding what people are seeing in Marshall's game. He took 3 marks and kicked 1 goal. As a key forward. Not being able to kick over the man on the mark from 25 metres out in front sapped anything we had left.
 

EskimoPAFC

Norm Smith Medallist
Dec 17, 2017
8,485
20,436
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really not understanding what people are seeing in Marshall's game. He took 3 marks and kicked 1 goal. As a key forward. Not being able to kick over the man on the mark from 25 metres out in front sapped anything we had left.
Its not so much what he did as what everyone else didnt do.

Riley for me was 8/10.

Id probably give Todd a 6/10.

Houston might get a 5.

Ollie a 4.

Nobody else above 2. Probably about five 0s.
 

VineValerian

Norm Smith Medallist
Mar 10, 2014
5,787
6,873
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Man Utd, Celtic, Tanunda
5. Bonner 9/10
4. Wines 7/10
3. Drew 5/10
2. Pistol 3/10
1. ........ no one worthy

Of the remaining 19 players: 6 get 2/10, 7 get 1/10 and 6 get 0/10.

PS: 10/10 to any supporters who stayed to the final siren. You have my total admiration.

Qualifier: Votes based up to half time only. Didn't watch the second half. Going purely on observations from others on this board, match report in the paper, and quick glance at some stats.
 

Sleezy

Club Legend
Mar 17, 2015
2,364
4,757
Melbourne
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Really not understanding what people are seeing in Marshall's game. He took 3 marks and kicked 1 goal. As a key forward. Not being able to kick over the man on the mark from 25 metres out in front sapped anything we had left.
Because for 5 minutes in the third quarter we almost looked a chance to make things interesting, and that was on the back of Marshall.

He also set up the Bonner goal, and hit up Fantasia just before half time (who missed). He was the only player able to consistently do damage kicking inside 50. A noteworthy performance in a team that, outside of Bonner, was unable to raise a yelp.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad