MVP Votes Rd 4 WCE vs St Kilda

Remove this Banner Ad


Club Legend
Oct 7, 2011
AFL Club
West Coast
Genuinely surprised by the Naitanui votes, thought he was awful (by his own standards). But I ain't going back to watch again

All my votes should have a asterisk too

5 - Barrass
4 - Pertch
3 - Allen
2 - Brander
1 - Shep
Totally agree. Had hitouts to advantage against him on occasions that allowed them to waltz out of contests. Some by Carlisle who isn't even a ruckman.

Connection with the mids was miles off, not all his fault but far from one of our best.

On SM-G973F using mobile app


Old enough to know better, too drunk to try.
Feb 12, 2008
A Quantum Universe
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
West Coast Wonders
5 - Barrass
4 - Petch
3 - Allen
2 - Sheppard
1 - Brander

fu** you Tim Kelly...Pull your socks up son!
We really needed you to stand up for this one.

Log in to remove this ad.


Brownlow Medallist
May 9, 2013
AFL Club
West Coast
5. Petch
4. Barrass

No idea after that...

3. Allen
2. Branders first quarter
1. JK

Not sure how NN is getting votes. It felt like he was rucking for the Saints outside 2 or 3 good hit outs.


Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 29, 2005
AFL Club
West Coast
5. Petruccelle
4. Allen
3. Rotham
2. Brander
1. Barrass

At least Gaff had a better second half rather than skiing through the first.
Statistically Naitanui did a lot, but for impact, far less than you'd expect against the Saints rucks.
Part of this was the lazy games from Kelly & Sheed in the middle (the latter, apparently sick)

Can't give votes to Gov, struggled for Barrass 1 vote due to the kicking errors for both but Tommy's marking was great.


Team Captain
Oct 11, 2016
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Swan Districts
5 Petruccelle
4 Allen
3 Sheppard
2 Naitanui
1 Kennedy

I’m a lot less happy with Barrass’s game than most on this thread. First job of KPDs is to shut down KPFs, and King and Membrey were too prominent.

Sent from my iPhone using

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad