VOTES - rd 5

[Southerntakeover]

Southerntakeover, there must be a few rocks in your head if you think there is no one else worthy for ROTY besides Griffin. Does the surname of Douglas ring a bell at all?

Haha, thats nice. Dont really have to justify my votes to you, but i will anyway. Noticed a few things about Douglas, for example how often hes fumbled the last two weeks which have put me off voting for him this round.

 

[fightingdreamer88]

Haha, thats nice. Dont really have to justify my votes to you, but i will anyway. Noticed a few things about Douglas, for example how often hes fumbled the last two weeks which have put me off voting for him this round.

I call it "rain"

I also call it "FFS MCLEOD FUMBLED AS WELL!!!!"

 

[Southerntakeover]

I call it "rain"

I also call it "FFS MCLEOD FUMBLED AS WELL!!!!"

Did i give McLeod votes?

Its not just the fumbling, its the constant falling over and turn overs which appeared to come when he got the ball. My initial impression watching him and Vince out there in this particular game was 'damn i wish we had some big bodied experienced players out there'.

Like i said, i dont have to justify my votes to you, and im not bagging the kid, i love his work, but i didnt feel he deserved votes based on that performance.

 

[KUNG FU]

5 - Rutten
4 - McLeod
3 - Bassssettt
2 - Hudson
1 - Edwards

3 - Shirley
2 - Hudson
1 - Rutten

2 - Douglas
1 - Griffin

 

[fightingdreamer88]

Did i give McLeod votes?

Its not just the fumbling, its the constant falling over and turn overs which appeared to come when he got the ball. My initial impression watching him and Vince out there in this particular game was 'damn i wish we had some big bodied experienced players out there'.

Like i said, i dont have to justify my votes to you, and im not bagging the kid, i love his work, but i didnt feel he deserved votes based on that performance.

I was stirring ya.

Douglas definitely has problems with keeping his footing.

 

[AdelUniCrowFan]

I counted up the votes for Round 5 with 18 people voting.

POTY
5. Thompson 81
4. Rutten 44
3. Edwards 42
2. van Berlo 38
1. Mattner 30
Stevens 11
Hudson 7
McLeod 6
Bassett 5
Knights 4
Doughty 1
Shirley 1

BTM
3. Hudson 28
2. Shirley 20
1. Mattner 11
Rutten 10
Bassett 10
McLeod 7
Van Berlo 7
Douglas 6
Edwards 2
Stevens 1

ROTY
2. Griffin 25
1. Knights 15
Douglas 12

On the classification of the Knights as a rookie issue
Dandy go posted this in another thread
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showpost.php?p=7390231&postcount=12

I believe last year it was decided that a rookie would be any player under 21 as of the first of January and with 15 games or less AFL experience. Knights fits the bill.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=231965

 

[Damp Squarie]

Well done AUCF