?????
MVP Votes Rnd 19 v Sydney
- Thread starter PapaJ
- Start date
- Tagged users None
?????
Kennedy was the clear BOG and had half the tackles Mundy did.
Mundy had the ball 44 times - it's a lot harder to lay tackles when you've got the ball.
chasing and applying pressure is great, but if you're nowhere near it, you're just burning energy and not impacting the play. Walters was a good example of this today. part of the reason Sydney get the ball up their end so quickly is our players have overcommitted to unrealistic runs at the ball, leaving them offside, cooked, and with a paddock behind them.
as for Clarke being our BOG today... what are you smoking? he took a few marks and hit the ball to the ground a bunch of times. numerous times he absolutely gave up on the play and others he showed zero awareness of the players around him. i used to be a big wrap for ZC in his early years and thought he would come good as he learnt the game, but he just hasn't improved and, frankly, looks bored. his football IQ is below ordinary.
Let's not derail the votes thread. People are entitled to vote for whoever they want. Watching the game I thought Mundy was our hardest worker and after checking the stats they also support that theory - he can't run 100% of the time. Apart from the general stats (disposals, clearances, tackles etc) he was also in our top 5 for intercepts, pressure acts and score involvements. His heat map is also ridiculous - he was everywhere! But you are entitled to a different opinion and not to vote for him.
5. Ibbotson
4. Silvagni
3. Langdon
2. Collins
1. Neale
BYB: Langdon
We all watch the game differently, but from where I sit Mundy was only ok. I really didn't notice him that much.
4. Silvagni
3. Langdon
2. Collins
1. Neale
BYB: Langdon
We all watch the game differently, but from where I sit Mundy was only ok. I really didn't notice him that much.
you need new seats.
Still a bit off to give a player votes because he wasn't as terrible as usual.
I saw nothing to indicate he was in our top five at all.
3. Mundy.
3. Neale.
2. Crozier
2. Silvagni
2. Langdon
2. Collins.
1. Pav.
3. Neale.
2. Crozier
2. Silvagni
2. Langdon
2. Collins.
1. Pav.
- Jul 15, 2007
- 9,634
- 7,239
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Boston Celtics, Patriots
- Thread starter
- #35
Votes not easy. Mundy was standout (thought even that not everybody seems to agree with), but after that it was a very even spread of good moments mixed with mediocrity. I'll go:
5. Mundy
3. Langdon - Though he wasn't in your face all the time, he bobbed up throughout and looked like a solid AFL player.
2. Ibbo - faded a fair bit, but for 2/3 of the game he seemed quite switched on. Not just marking, but making quicker decisions by foot and executing. Glad to see him in at least moderate form.
2. Croz - Was played in a few different roles. Thought he battled hard. Did some nice things.
2. SCOS - Such a competitor. He would have really helped us out as a backup through the last few years if fit. He gives his all and is more skilled than many think. Silvagni held up his end of the bargain on the day.
1. Neale - he got the ball, that's a good start.
BYB: Langdon
5. Mundy
3. Langdon - Though he wasn't in your face all the time, he bobbed up throughout and looked like a solid AFL player.
2. Ibbo - faded a fair bit, but for 2/3 of the game he seemed quite switched on. Not just marking, but making quicker decisions by foot and executing. Glad to see him in at least moderate form.
2. Croz - Was played in a few different roles. Thought he battled hard. Did some nice things.
2. SCOS - Such a competitor. He would have really helped us out as a backup through the last few years if fit. He gives his all and is more skilled than many think. Silvagni held up his end of the bargain on the day.
1. Neale - he got the ball, that's a good start.
BYB: Langdon
I'm usually pretty good at dishing out full votes ever week but from where i was sitting i didn't see enough vote worthy performances and there's no way I'm going to rewatch that
3 Neale
3 Langdon
2 Collins
2 Crozier
1 Mundy
BYB Langdon
3 Neale
3 Langdon
2 Collins
2 Crozier
1 Mundy
BYB Langdon
- Jul 15, 2007
- 9,634
- 7,239
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Boston Celtics, Patriots
- Thread starter
- #39
Last call for votes. Will count them up for results to be posted tomorrow.
- Jul 15, 2007
- 9,634
- 7,239
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Boston Celtics, Patriots
- Thread starter
- #40
This was a tough game to watch and, as is usual with big losses, finding the better players is not always that easy. Having said that, it was nice to finally see Mundy return to something of his best and he was comfortably (though not unanimously) considered our better player on the day. Always good to see young guns do well and it was Langdon this week who impressed and was second followed closely by regular vote getter Neale who rounded out the top 3. Here are the numbers:
Rnd 19 vs Sydney
Score Name - Votes (Number of People who Voted)
7 David Mundy - 91 (22)
6 Ed Langdon - 48 (20)
5 Lachie Neale - 44 (16)
4 Hayden Crozier - 37 (17)
3 Sam Collins - 29 (13)
2 Garrick Ibbotson - 19 (8)
1 Alex Silvagni - 18 (10)
1 Matthew Pavlich - 15 (10)
- Chris Mayne - 6 (4)
- Zac Clarke - 5 (3)
- Shane Yarran - 3 (2)
- Stephen Hill - 3 (1)
- Lachie Weller - 2 (1)
- Tom Sheridan - 1 (1)
25 voters participated
BYB:
Langdon - 17
Collins - 2
Weller - 1
The results and standings thread has been updated with latest results.
Rnd 19 vs Sydney
Score Name - Votes (Number of People who Voted)
7 David Mundy - 91 (22)
6 Ed Langdon - 48 (20)
5 Lachie Neale - 44 (16)
4 Hayden Crozier - 37 (17)
3 Sam Collins - 29 (13)
2 Garrick Ibbotson - 19 (8)
1 Alex Silvagni - 18 (10)
1 Matthew Pavlich - 15 (10)
- Chris Mayne - 6 (4)
- Zac Clarke - 5 (3)
- Shane Yarran - 3 (2)
- Stephen Hill - 3 (1)
- Lachie Weller - 2 (1)
- Tom Sheridan - 1 (1)
25 voters participated
BYB:
Langdon - 17
Collins - 2
Weller - 1
The results and standings thread has been updated with latest results.
Last edited:
