Votes v Croweaters

[windyhill]

3. Hird.
2. Umm.
1. Ahhh.

 

[windyhill]

Apologies to Ted Richards. I`ll drop Umm out and give him two.

 

[Stealth bomber]

3. Hird
2. Richards
1. Peverill

Everyone else should hang their heads in shame, INCLUDING Sheedy. Absolutely bush-league tactics.

I'm not proud of this club at all tonight.

 

[Darealrath]

3. Hird
2. Richards
1. Pev

If the behind post had a red and black jumper on i'd give it 2.

 

[IceTemple]

3 Hird

2 Lucas (has as much as Hird but spent the game at CHB & probably should have been given time up forward)

1 Bear

 

[Hosko]

3. Hird
2. Bear
1. Lucas

* Pev was OK
* WTF happened to Jacobs?
* Any reports on JJ other than it is related to his back ?
* Both reports were pretty soft in my opinion although reckless and certainly unnecessary
* Watson was never going to play in Sheedy's mind, if he was going to then he would have after the withdrawal of JJ

 

[Essendon Fan]

3--Hird
2--Richards
1--Peverill

 

[topdon]

3. Hird - by so far its not funny
2. Bullen - top effort son!
1. The Bear - looked the only player likely to kick a goal

 

[Da Bomberman]

How about McGrath? That guy is LEGENDARY!

 

[Lethal]

3. Hird
2. Richards
1. Pev

Applogies to the post, if it got involved earlier in the game it could have gotten votes.

 

[TD]

3. Lucas
2. Teddy
1. Hird
-1. M Johnson
-2. Cupido
-3. Fletcher

 

[coxon]

3. hird
2. lucas
1. richards

 

[Dave]

3 hird
2 bear
1 scotland

 

[M29]

3: Hird
2: Richards
1: Peverill/Lucas/McGrath

 

[SydneyBomber]

3 Jim
2 Bear
1 Pev

 

[rednugget]

3- Hird
2- Richards (he's got talent)
1- Bullen (should have started in the middle with Misiti & JJ out, not on the ****ing bench)

 

[Jars458]

You have got to admire James Hird

Thought he was excellent Friday night and really the only player who won his position. Was hard at it all night and played it pretty smart to win the ball out of the contests.

That goal after he hurt his arm was inspirational.

The trainer who tried to drag him off via the sore elbow should be shot.

Can't imagine how good he would have been without the injuries.

Richards was ok but I think Bassett gives his man a chance as he often leaves him to help out teamates etc.

Good win for us though.

Cupio should get off and Flether's will depend on what Burton says. IF he says he was staging fro a free of the contact was to the shoulder he may get off.

 

[pazza]

3 - Sir James
2 - Teddy
1 - Scotty

Others considered: Peverill, McGrath, Bullen.

 

[mongrelpunt]

Originally posted by Jars458
Cupio should get off and Flether's will depend on what Burton says. IF he says he was staging fro a free of the contact was to the shoulder he may get off.

Yeah good. Trial by media. AGAIN!

Channel Slime made sure they got every angle of Fletch's bump, and by the end of the game (granted he did it with 50 seconds to go) he had 6 weeks from the commentators.

He'll get 3, even with Burton's good word.

Anyways, back to topic:

3 - Jim
2 - Ted
1 - McGrath

 

[dodgey]

3: Hirdy
2: Hirdy
1: Hirdy



apologies to Scotty, Teddy and Bully