Votes vs Brisbane (rd 14)

[wce4premiership]

Don't want to do this but

5. kerr
4. leCras
3. Cox
2. Waters
1. Judd

 

[Alphanumeric]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

How could you not give Cox votes??

 

[The_Eagles]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

LeCras
Kerr
Cox
Judd
Seaby

 

[Lion El'Johnson]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

How could you give Waters votes. Sure some hard hits, but appalling disposal and cost us two goals.

5. Le Cras
4. Cox
3. Kerr
2. Judd
1. Brett Jones

 

[TheBigUnit]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5 - M LeCras
4 - D Cox
3 - C Judd
2 - D Kerr
1 - M Priddis

 

[eaglerock]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5.lecras
no one else deserves a votes shocking

 

[wce4premiership]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

How could you not give Cox votes??

whoops, i was doing it and i had cox and i realised i'd forgot lecras so i added him but i forgot to push everyone down i just replaced them

 

[Biggie]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5 - D Cox
4 - D.Kerr
3 - M LeCras
2 - C.Judd
1 - M Priddis

 

[West Coast 06]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5. LeCras
4. Cox
3. Judd
2. Priddis
1. Seaby

How do you pick out votes from that???
Four goals buys LeCras some, Cox was everywhere early but too slow with decisions later, Judd was good without being great, Priddis tried hard later in the game and Seaby did some good things.

 

[larrikin]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

Don't wanna give votes but I will

5 - Cox
4 - LeCras
3 - Kerr
2 - Judd
1 - Rosa (actually thought he did quite well - or was it just on my wing?)

 

[Keys]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5 - LeCras - Kicked half our goals - made the most of his possessions.
4 - Kerr - Worked the hardest of our mids
3 - Cox - Won the ruck
2 - Judd - got plenty of the ball so deserves to be in the votes even thogh I can't remember a 30+ possession game from from him being less influential
1 - Glass - battled manfully against Brown and won the first half before getting swamped in the second.

 

[BarcaRulz]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5 - Cox
4 - LeCras
3 - Kerr
2 - Judd
1 - Priddis

 

[Embers]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

How could you not give Cox votes??

Because he directed tap after tap down Brisbane players throats. His form is becoming very overrated on these boards. We won more centre clearances with Seabs rucking then Cox which says something

5. Kerr
4. LeCras
3. Priddis
2. Chick
1. Seaby

 

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5. M. LeCras
4. D. Kerr
3. D. Cox
2. C. Judd
1. D. Chick

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

I can't vote but:

5. LeCras

Everyone else was crap and couldn't hit a teammate by hand or foot to save their lives (or careers).

 

[Embers]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

If Dean Cox was BOG then that was the worst performance in our 20 year history. Cant believe how overrated hes becoming. Seaby was ten times better then Cox last night

 

[Magnum27]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5.Judd
4.Kerr
3.Glass
2.Cox
1.LeCras

 

[The Made Guy]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5. D Kerr
4. C Judd
3. M Le Cras
2. D Cox
1. M Seaby

 

[Juddism]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

5. LeCras
4. Priddis

Judd may have had 30+ touches but some of them were frightful to say the least, to many passengers lastnight.

 

[Fletchers Girl]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

So hard to do votes based on that performance....but here goes

5. Kerr
4. LeCras
3. Cox
2. Seaby
1. Judd

 

[wce4premiership]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

If Dean Cox was BOG then that was the worst performance in our 20 year history. Cant believe how overrated hes becoming. Seaby was ten times better then Cox last night

You say this nearly every game, but the fact is cox is better then seaby.

 

[Embers]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

You say this nearly every game, but the fact is cox is better then seaby.

Just for the past month mate because its true. I acknowledged Cox stunning game vs Adelaide but he took 2 steps backwards last night. He was very poor last night with his ruckwork. Even my bro and uncle agreed with me and that is a rare occurence

 

[TheBigUnit]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

If Dean Cox was BOG then that was the worst performance in our 20 year history. Cant believe how overrated hes becoming. Seaby was ten times better then Cox last night

It was the worst performance I've seen by WC with a decent team on the park (I'm ignoring Skilled 2005, because that was at a bogey ground). I thought Cox was very good around the ground last night (mainly the first half), won a lot of contested ball and his disposal was better than most of our other mids (which is saying something in itself).

 

[Embers]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

It was the worst performance I've seen by WC with a decent team on the park (I'm ignoring Skilled 2005, because that was at a bogey ground). I thought Cox was very good around the ground last night (mainly the first half), won a lot of contested ball and his disposal was better than most of our other mids (which is saying something in itself).

Its a valid point. His work around the ground was fine. His ruckwork wasnt though which is my problem. Seaby won more effective hitouts then Cox last night

 

[wce4premiership]

Re: Votes vs brisbane:

Just for the past month mate because its true. I acknowledged Cox stunning game vs Adelaide but he took 2 steps backwards last night. He was very poor last night with his ruckwork. Even my bro and uncle agreed with me and that is a rare occurence

Now i don't claim to count everyones minutes on the ground or in the ruck but surely cox was very tired, i thought he spent more time in the ruck and seaby came in fresh maybe?

Seaby didn't stand out last night but i don't remember him being one of the crap players last night.