Votes Vs Brisbane

[snakebite01]

POTY
5 - Perrie
4 - Gallagher
3 - Edwards
2 - Bickley
1 - Begley

TTM
3 - Perrie
2 - Hart
1 - Bickley

ROTY
1 - Mattner

 

[sapaul]

POTY

5-T.Edwards
4-M.Bickley
3-S.Goodwin
2-M.Ricciuto
1-J.Gallagher

TTM

3-M.Bickley
2-B.Hart
1-J.Begley

Rookie

NO!

 

[brent33brett33]

POTY
5- James Gallagher
4- Ian Perrie
3- Simon Goodwin
2- Ben Hart
1- Tyson Edwards

TTM
3- Ian Perrie
2- Matthew Clarke
1- James Begley

Rookie
- Mattner

 

[Jars458]

Why does Tyson Edwards keep getting votes after making the same mistakes, time after time after time.

He should be shot for that holding the ball decision. Get it on your boot man.


5 - Ian Perrie - brilliant game from Ian against one of the League's toughest defececes.

4 - K McGregor - won his position hands down

3 - B Hart - was brilliant for three quarters

2 - J Gallagher - kicing for goal cost us the game but he still played well.

1 - J Begley - excellent debut from James. Hope he comes up this week.


Team Man

3 - Ian Perrie
2 - Ben Hart
1 - Mark Bickley

Rookie

Mattner


Ricciuto Goodwin and McLeod went missing when the heat was on. Give me Voss Black and Lappin any day over these three. Leadership was sadly lacking when required on Saturday.

 

[PrideOf]

BOG

5 - Perrie
4 - Gallagher
3 - McGregor
2 - Begley
1 - Hart

Team Man

3 - Bickley
2 - Perrie
1 - Hart

Rookie

Mattner

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Final Votes

22 Voters

Best on Ground
84 Gallagher (5)
63 Perrie (4)
39 Edwards (3)
38 Bickley (2)
37 Begley (1)
25 McGregor
19 Goodwin
12 Hart
7 Clarke
4 Ricciuto
1 McLeod
1 Mattner
330 Total

Best Team Man
34 Perrie (3)
20 Begley (2)
19 Bickley (1)
12 Clarke
11 Gallagher
10 Hart
6 McGregor
5 Mattner
4 Ricciuto
3 Burns
2 Johncôck
2 Crowell
2 Goodwin
1 Torney
1 Edwards
132 Total

Best Rookie
18 Mattner (1)
4 Abstained
22 Total

 

[tribey]

Re: Final Votes

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
Best on Ground
84 Gallagher (5)

That disappoints me.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Re: Re: Final Votes

Originally posted by dyertribe
That disappoints me.

Yeah, IMO Perrie got stiffed, but Edwards (3) was more disappointing to me ... but majority rules!

 

[DaveW]

Well I didn't think a mere two goals was that impressive from our only tall forward... but each to their own.

 

[macca23]

Originally posted by DaveW
Well I didn't think a mere two goals was that impressive from our only tall forward... but each to their own.

You are joking I hope Dave.

Perrie wasn't the focal point of the attack. But he was the only tall. He was just the poor bastard that was expected to lead up the ground as a decoy, take marks or compete for any and every high bomb into the forward line, besides competing for the ball on the ground and holding the ball in the area.

I've been one of Perrie's greatest critics over the years, but personally I thought he was terrific against the Lions.

 

[DaveW]

Perrie toiled away and it was a much improved effort on the week before. But by no means was he best on ground.

 

[macca23]

Originally posted by DaveW
Perrie toiled away and it was a much improved effort on the week before. But by no means was he best on ground.

That's the beauty of everyone having the right to their own opinion.

I thought he was our best player.

Others are entitled to think what they want.

 

[napsyd]

I thought Perrie's efforts were outstanding and hence gave him the 5 votes.

None of our players had BOG type games last week in my opinion. They were all let down in some way.

Perrie didn't put the score on the board.

Gags couldn't finish.

Edwards holding the (foot)balls were very costly.

No one was the complete footballer last week.

 

[tribey]

Originally posted by napsyd
Gags couldn't finish.

Reminded me of Brayden Lyle and Grantley Fielke.