Votes vs. Carlton

[kretchy]

Post your 3-2-1

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Only listened to it on the radio.

3: Bowden
2: Stafford
1: Tivendale

Pathetic

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Though I admit to not watching the opposition very closely, I thought Chaffey provided a few frustrations for us. Tivendale early was killing us as well. Hilton in for Johnson .... we will take that one any day of the year.

 

[Rodan#18.]

*******s

3; tivvers
2 ; chaffey...unless he was playing on murphy
1...stafford

 

[mellowyellow]

3. Chaffey
2. Tivendale
1. Newman

 

[kretchy]

Originally posted by The Old Dark Navy's
Though I admit to not watching the opposition very closely, I thought Chaffey provided a few frustrations for us. Tivendale early was killing us as well. Hilton in for Johnson .... we will take that one any day of the year.

Post a 3-2-1 if you want its always good to get an oppostion supporters perspective.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

3. Mark Chaffey - 26 possessions, 10 marks. Good judge of a mark. Held the Blues forward surges up consistently.
2. Greg Tivendale - 22 possessions, 2 goals. Carved us up early, probably faded in the second half as he seemed to be playing more defensively but did enough early to get my votes.
1. This is a little harder and despite decent stats I didn't think Bowden or Coughlan put a stamp on the game. From an opposition point of view, the danger man is worthy of a vote and 11 possessions and 2 goals from David Rodan was enough to earn a vote from me. Scared the bejesus out of me the way he ran and eluded our players at times. An easy miss pegs him back a touch but in my view it makes him more endearing!

 

[TheFoxhat]

3 - Chaffey
2 - A.K
1 - Tiv

 

[wagstaff]

3. Chaffey
2. Tivendale
1. Coughlan

 

[CJH]

3. Chaffey
2. Tivendale
1. Bowden

 

[Foxtrot]

3. Chaff
2. Tivvers
1. A.K.

Very depressing!

 

[Keef]

3. Chaffey
2. Tivendale
1. Bowden

Midfield at stop plays continues to be a problem (even though Cogs was ok). No good having Richo & Ottens up forward if all they recieve is crap.

 

[peejay]

3 - Ray Hall (Absolutely destroyed McKernan)
2 - Chaffey (even though Murhy kicked two on him)
1 - Bowden (Did some good things)


Most disappointing

3 - Hilton (clearly showed why he was dropped)
2 - Otto (I know his is back from the back injury but christ he was weak)
1 - Krakeour (will have to learn how to lose jumper holders like Franchina et al if he wants to hang around for the long run)

I might also ask why Fleming only got 40 minutes in the park - don't you usually play a guy agaisnt his old team.

Really very disappointing.

 

[shawry]

3. Chaffey (he was on Murphy but savedus a ridiculous amount of times)
2. tivendale
1. Bowden

 

[CJH]

Re: *******s

Originally posted by Rodan#18.

...

2 ; chaffey...unless he was playing on murphy

Chaffey went to Murphy after most of his damage was done!

 

[TigerEmma]

3 Tivendale
2 Chaffey
1 Newman

 

[mighty tiges]

3. Tivs
2. Chaffey
1. Zantuck