MVP Votes vs carlton

[Red Bomber]

5 - Crameri
4 - Hurley
3 - Carlisle
2 - Prismall

It was a stretch to give anybody other than Hurley and Crameri votes.

 

[Childish Gambino]

Just got home. Smashed a Haci's kebab on the way home. It deserves the 5 votes, it was delicious.

5. Hurley
4. Crameri - really needs to work in his set shot kicking
3. Prismall
2. Zaharakis
1. Dyson

 

[AtomicBlonde]

Can I ask (seriously) why we bother giving votes for losses? It seems ridiculous, especially when we get pumped like we did last night.

 

[pandorian]

5 Crameri
4 Hurley
3 Prismall
4 Carlisle
1 Ryder

 

[blitzer]

3. Hurley - Was pretty damn good considering how few inside 50's we got, they weren't able to contain him at all in actual contests. If we had a regular 50-60 inside 50 games, Hurley could have had a huge bag.
2. Crameri - Other than his wayward goal kicking at times he was superb marking everything and again Carlton had no matchup for him.
1. Prismall - Ok it was hard to find to find a 3rd decent player but Prismall was one who I thought really tried to lift their game in the absence of some of our first string midfielders. Also used the ball fantastically in the first half which was rather surprising after 18 months of pretty crap ball use. It will be interesting to see if he can continue on with his form. It would be great if can because an extra physically mature midfielder would really help us out in the future while our kids develop.

Special Mention: Carlisle - Liked what he showed today in his marking. You can just see that he has fantastic hands. That mark going back with the flight, facing the wrong way was gold. Other than a 1 minute patch where he seemed to lose concentration to Kreuzer/get outbodied he was pretty bloody good all game. Needs to spend some serious time in the gym though, we won't see the best of him for a few years but he's got real genuine talent. Best of all - can swap with Hurley forward and back in the future.

 

[DapperDon]

5. Hurley
4. Crameri
3. Prismall
2. Carlisle for that running back mark
1. Coyler for that goal.

 

[anf06]

5. Prismall
4. Hurley
3. Zaharakis
2. Stanton
1. Hille

 

[Loonerty]

5. Hurley
4. Crameri
3. Stanton
2. Prismall
1. Colyer (run was fantastic and that goal)

 

[sup3rfish]

5- Hurley
4- Crameri
3- Prismall
2- Carlisle
1- Delayed Telecast.... so i could cheat and didnt have to watch the last quarter....

Special Mention to Cadel Evans for providing something worth staying up for...

 

[Darealrath]

Special Mention to Cadel Evans for providing something worth staying up for...

5. Hurley
4. Crameri
3. Prismall
2. Stanton
1. Colyer

Really clutching at the end there but I thought Colyer showed a bit and was trying to make things happen.

 

[Mad Bomber Sean]

5. Hurley
4. Crameri
3. Stanton
2. Prismal
1. Zaha

Two things I learnt from this game.
-Prismall should no longer be called Dismal Prismall, his last month has been pretty good.
- We are very unlikely to win another game this season unless we can get four of Watson, Hocking, Hibberd Fletch, Hocker & Belly into the side.

 

[Kong]

After thinking about it, I've decided to change my 1 vote to Reimers.

Coming on as the sub, he made an immediate impact and was one of the few in the side to probably do so.

 

[eth-dog]

Hurley
Crameri
Prismall
Stanton
Umm. Colyer, for that goal

 

[pazza]

The first group of votes go to the only 4 quarter players of the night and the last 2 go to the next best after that.

5 - Travis Colyer
4 - Ricky Dyson
3 - Michael Hurley
2 - Brent Prismall
1 - Brent Stanton

Ben Howlett the player stiff to miss. Laid 12 tackles and did the seemingly impossible. Got Judd pinged twice for holding the ball!!!!! Didn't think Crameri had a good game at all and it drops away dramatically from there.

 

[Smyth94]

5. Hurley
4. Crameri
3. Prismall
2. Hille
1. Melksham

Hille? Very interesting. I thought he was terrible and he's been poor for quite a while, I personally think he's finished.

One word: Judd

Too bad Juddy isn't going to be there for Carlton's next flag.

 

[Burzum]

It was quite funny watching most of Judd's kicks fail to hit the target. At least he can handball.

 

[yaco55]

Yeah

Judd had a lazy seven score assists !

 

[Ricky]

3. Hurley
2. Prismall
1. Crameri

No one else deserves any

 

[Blind Turn]

5/ Hurley
4/ Prismall (on the back of a first half that had him as second best midfielder on the ground)
3/ Stanton (his ability to read the play and win the ball at stoppages is a little underrated. Got us going forward more than any other player).
2/ Zaharakis (his new-found consistent weekly output of 20+ possessions is worthy of recognition)
1/ Crameri (presented well, kept his feet and gave off possession well when under the pump.)

 

[Lord Nicholson]

After thinking about it, I've decided to change my 1 vote to Reimers.

Coming on as the sub, he made an immediate impact and was one of the few in the side to probably do so.

Where a 7 point ball game turns into a 73 point ball game?

Some impact.

 

[Kong]

Yeah we probably should heap all of that on one guy, except people have already played that card with Slattery.

 

[Burzum]

Yeah

Judd had a lazy seven score assists !

Cool, cause I said kicks, champ.

 

[table tennis]

Yeah we probably should heap all of that on one guy, except people have already played that card with Slattery.

Your right.

What We have seen though, is that Slatts is unable to shut down players when they get a run on. This is not a blight on him, but a coaching decision that keeps throwing him to the wolves. At the moment there are not too many other candidates. Slatts tries hard, but at the moment, he is deadwood that will not be apart of the clubs next premiership, as he doesn't have enough bows to his game.

Riemers had a crack when he was on, and in a period where everyone went missing, that is a credit in the bank.

 

[raskolnikov]

I can't believe the lack of love for Colyer. Thought he was very good. One of the few highlights of the night for mine.

5. Hurley
4. Prismall
3. Colyer
2. Zaharakis
1. Ryder

 

[Ben the Gooner]

Still needs a lot of work on his decision making, but I thought it was his best game for us for a while.