MVP Votes vs St Kilda

[Flawed Genius]

All in here

 

[G0ther00s]

3. Simpkin (Thought he was amazing all throughout the game).
2. Cunnington
1. Goldstein

 

[silent duck]

3. Cunnington
2. Simpkin
1. Higgins

 

[brettman135]

3. Cunners
2. Goldy
1. Simpkin

Hon mention Superfly

+1

 

[andana]

Simpkin
Cunners
Larkey

 

[Wels Eicke]

3 - Goldy (No way we would have been within striking distance had it not been for his 1st half)
2 - Cunners (Won the game at the end, but his 1st half wasn't great
1 - Simpkin

I agree with these votes (and the summation)

 

[CunnyTarryn]

3 Cunnington
2 Simpkin
1 Taylor

 

[muttley45]

3, Cunners

2, Goldy

1, Jy

Huge apologies to many, Curtis and Tarryn especially, and well coached Rhyse.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Goldstein
Cunners
Simpkin

Polec, Taylor, Atley all good-very good.

 

[north_lad]

3. Cunners
2. Jyza
1. TT

HM: KING CURTIS TAYLOR, Jazzy P, Goldstein's cleanness below his knees for a giant.

 

[Keith Ape]

3. Cunnington
2. Simpkin
1. Goldstein

Taylor was great and deserves half a vote

 

[Mav]

3. Cunners
2. Dumont
1. JMac
Dumont and JMac were the only players to play well in the first half and kept us in the game.

 

[ferball]

These might need to be merged.

 

[shintemaster]

3. Cunnington
2. Simpkin
1. McMillan (had to play tall with walker going down. was very solid in defence I thought)

I'm well known of recent as not loving Jmac's form but - while I wouldn't have him in our best 3 - I thought he played a great game. One of the best and most physical I've seen out of him in years.

 

[Orange Peanut]

3. Cunnington
2. Simpkin
1. Goldstein

 

[ferball]

Might be the only votes this year. I'll probably do em on Friday.

 

[shinboner magic]

3- Goldy
2-Cunners
1-Simpkin

 

[CarnaKangas]

3. Cunnington
2. Goldstein - The guy spent 98% of the game on the field. That is an incredible effort, especially when going up against Marshall and Ryder who are two quality ruckmen. On top of that he was still super productive. Fantastic game.
1. Simpkin

 

[tazaa]

3 Goldstein
2 Cunnington
1 Jy

I’ll be keen to see who gets the brownlow votes for this game

 

[tazaa]

2 threads?

 

[Bigeasy]

I'm well known of recent as not loving Jmac's form but - while I wouldn't have him in our best 3 - I thought he played a great game. One of the best and most physical I've seen out of him in years.

Good man. Everyone needs to chill about players until we've seen them under Shaw and his game plan

 

[North Viking]

3 - Goldy and Cunners.
Honestly couldn’t split them.
1 - Jy.
Arrived!!!

 

[chairo]

3. Goldstein
2. Cunnington
1. Polec

 

[Twinkletoes]

2 threads?

Not anymore.

 

[HongKongRoo]

3. Cunners
2. Simpkin
1. Polec

 

[shintemaster]

Good man. Everyone needs to chill about players until we've seen them under Shaw and his game plan

Absolutely. Don't get me wrong - I still think there will be some team & fan favourites that will make way under this regime that never would under Scott but at the very least each player should be given the opportunity to find their place. Caveat being that not all will have, nor should have, the privilege of doing so only at AFL level*.

*In a normal season anyway...