Wanted: 1 Ruckman

[Deenamite]

Are you kidding. Mundy has more value than Warncok. He is easily worth 17 and Warnock is worth 19 i reckon. It think its a good deal for both teams. But only if Mundy asks to be traded. I hope he doesnt

You're dreaming mate. I doubt we'd want to part with 19 for the 2 of them let alone both 17 + 19.

 

[RandB]

Are you kidding. Mundy has more value than Warncok. He is easily worth 17 and Warnock is worth 19 i reckon. It think its a good deal for both teams. But only if Mundy asks to be traded. I hope he doesnt

Not to Melbourne he doesn't, which was part of my point.

Warnock fills a direct void on our list where Mundy could be handy for a bit of flexibility - there is a difference.

FWIW Mundy would be a good pickup as he has a balance of youth/experience as he is about a year in front of most of our new defenders. With Whelan maybe with one more year and our hopes to push Buckley further down the ground we could use him. Compare this situation however to our obvious requirement for a #1 ruck and you should see where I am coming from.

 

[dee-molishon]

hi guys, just want to pose a question & would be intrested to hear your thoughts on this idea to stump carlton & get warnock to melbourne,

1. freo refuses to del with carlton
2. in return melbourne offer freo pick 17 + 19 for mundy
3.dont get your nickers in a knot & hear me out
4.freo forces warnock into the psd
5.probably nothing of any quality in the psd this year anyway
6.melbourne draft warnock in the psd

end result is

freo get 17 +19
melbourne get warnock & mundy

you guys would end up with 3 very good players with the first 3 picks
& the only sacrafice is the useless psd which only gets recycled hacks anyway & you get to really stick it up carlton.

pick 1 watts................the ff you really need
pick 17 warnock............the ruck you really need
pick 19 mundy............... very talented back/mid with very good disposal

if you guys think its a shit idea , please dont go overboard its only an alternative and you really do still hold the aces its upto your team if they want use them.

I have so many admires!!!
I posted this exact trade about 5 days ago in the warnock thread, takes a real wanna be to pass off my work as their own.

 

[THE_GUN]

I have so many admires!!!
I posted this exact trade about 5 days ago in the warnock thread, takes a real wanna be to pass off my work as their own.

i have not seen your post at all, & if somebody has posted something i agree with i would simply agree with the point they made.
i simply came across the thread where deamon supporters were upset about missing out on warnock , and made the point that by warnock saying carlton are his preffered club doesnt mean the dees cant do anything about it.
if you go through my posts you will see that i would hate for carlton to be the club that benefits the most.

 

[THE_GUN]

I have so many admires!!!
I posted this exact trade about 5 days ago in the warnock thread, takes a real wanna be to pass off my work as their own.

could you please give me a date & time as to when you posted your version of the post , but i cant see it in your posts.