News Warnock Nominates Carlton

[Jeremias]

Are we talking about the same Murphy who kicked 5 against us at the Dome a couple of years back?

Yes.

I wouldn't mind getting him, but I wouldn't be giving up more than a 5th round pick for him.

 

[parrot]

I dont think we will get Bower, i just would like him. I think we will get Browne, Edwards, Armfeild etc and pick 24

What! lol. Keep dreaming. You'll get pick 24 if that. If you don't like that, you'll get nothing.

 

[EBUS]

Can't let stuff like this bother you. Would say it would be very doubtful that the player freo will take at 24 would be the player the blues would take there so it is all irrelevant. And i would be very surprised if Dalziell was on our radar last year.

Also i would be very unhappy if we traded Stevie Browne i for one rate him very very highly and think we would be very silly to trade away a player we felt was worth a pick well within pick 20 last year. So essentially alot of people are willing to swap a pick 24 and a player worth > pick 20. I remember Mike Sheehan mentioning how much he rates Browne and as do i. Just dont think we can afford to be giving away a player of his talent and footy smarts.

I read that the pick 52 that we traded for hadley was dalziell

 

[Salaryman]

I read that the pick 52 that we traded for hadley was dalziell

Yes, but it doesn't mean we would have taken Dalziell with that pick, or even rated him.

Ask TheGeneral what he thinks of Dalziell

 

[Silvagnis]

Warnock is not worth pick 24, more like Pick 40 but don't Carlton ever learn. FFS why can't Carlton just keep all there picks. With pick 24 we can draft a really good player.

Says the Rocket Surgeon who has no faith in Hughes picking players.

Unless you want to start being constructive, instead of being annoying, stop posting tripe that flatters Saintsational.

Carlton supporters who seek to piss off their own supporters are bigger w***ers than JeffDunne, The Fireman and that sook JoffaBoy.

Sorry to dampen peoples spirits, but ive got a funny feeling if we give pick 24 for Warnock, pick 24 will end up being a star...just like when we traded dalziell for hadley

Yeah, that Dalziell is a gun when Hadley had no influence in our drought breaking win.

If only we had kept that pick.

I'd rather have a 21 year old Aaron Joseph than Dalziell.

AJ might even be a better kick at that age, but he offer's us just as much pace, but more overall when we need a tough in and under player who will kick goals.

To be accurate

I think Adelaide has pick 28 in the second round because of the PP.

My bad.

 

[CFC16]

Says the Rocket Surgeon who has no faith in Hughes picking players.

Unless you want to start being constructive, instead of being annoying, stop posting tripe that flatters Saintsational.

Carlton supporters who seek to piss off their own supporters are bigger w***ers than JeffDunne, The Fireman and that sook JoffaBoy.

Yeah, that Dalziell is a gun when Hadley had no influence in our drought breaking win.

If only we had kept that pick.

I'd rather have a 21 year old Aaron Joseph than Dalziell.

AJ might even be a better kick at that age, but he offer's us just as much pace, but more overall when we need a tough in and under player who will kick goals.

I think Adelaide has pick 28 in the second round because of the PP.

My bad.

The Facts are Mr Hughes had a chance to draft Warnock at pick 36 in the 2005 draft when we had no ruckmen. '' but no he drafted Jake Edwards who has shown nothing''. Now you tell me is that rocket science

 

[BLUE BLEEDING]

now all we need is...

 

[markfarmer]

The Facts are Mr Hughes had a chance to draft Warnock at pick 36 in the 2005 draft when we had no ruckmen. '' but no he drafted Jake Edwards who has shown nothing''. Now you tell me is that rocket science

Just to let you know....When Warnock came to Freo, he was Skinny as a toothpick.. In a gastly kind of way... Honestly.. You would fear him breaking something.... Go back and check old post about him.. So I could see him getting passed on in the draft.....

But now, after a few years he's bulked up a bit and is in the mix. Though I think he broke/fractured something in his arm recently...ie the forearm guard he was wearing for awhile..

So you can see why Freo may have a few sour grapes...We took the risk of him filling out and trained him up for three years... Freo took the risk and made the investment in Him.....now hopefully we can get something back..

If there are problems, I think Robbie will nominate the Demons as a Secondary Club he would go to...to get a fair trade.

 

[thylacine60]

Just to let you know....When Warnock came to Freo, he was Skinny as a toothpick.. In a gastly kind of way... Honestly.. You would fear him breaking something.... Go back and check old post about him.. So I could see him getting passed on in the draft.....

But now, after a few years he's bulked up a bit and is in the mix. Though I think he broke/fractured something in his arm recently...ie the forearm guard he was wearing for awhile..

So you can see why Freo may have a few sour grapes...We took the risk of him filling out and trained him up for three years... Freo took the risk and made the investment in Him.....now hopefully we can get something back..

If there are problems, I think Robbie will nominate the Demons as a Secondary Club he would go to...to get a fair trade.

Yep, there's a pic of him around here somewhere, painfully thin is right. Apparently he broke his forearm in his excitement to pick up the phone when Steven Icke called.

 

[Bluebear]

The Facts are Mr Hughes had a chance to draft Warnock at pick 36 in the 2005 draft when we had no ruckmen. '' but no he drafted Jake Edwards who has shown nothing''. Now you tell me is that rocket science

The problem was Hughes like to watch from the wing......and from side on in 2005 you actually couldn't see Warnock.......he literally did not exist until ou saw him from the front he was that thin.

Hughes never knew he existed.

Honest mistake.

Dicks fixing it.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

So Warnock nominates us.

That means no other dealing, or he goes into the PSD,
and Freo get nothing.

So the offer would be our Forth Round pick,
wouldn't it?

 

[thylacine60]

The problem was Hughes like to watch from the wing......and from side on in 2005 you actually couldn't see Warnock.......he literally did not exist until ou saw him from the front he was that thin.

Hughes never knew he existed.

Honest mistake.

Dicks fixing it.

I'll wear that.

 

[thylacine60]

So Warnock nominates us.

That means no other dealing, or he goes into the PSD,
and Freo get nothing.

So the offer would be our Forth Round pick,
wouldn't it?

What, miss out on a Hoops or Fish?

 

[Stig O'Hara]

What, miss out on a Hoops or Fish?

Nah, i like Fisher,
Corowas pride and joy on the other hand.

This kinda, sorta, nearly Free Agency stuff,
works out pretty well for us.

We are a sneaky bunch.

 

[SS_Fury]

So Warnock nominates us.

That means no other dealing, or he goes into the PSD,
and Freo get nothing.

So the offer would be our Forth Round pick,
wouldn't it?

channel 10 tonight says he hasnt nominated any club as a preference, Carlton have just offered the most coin so far and the australian newspaper ran with it.

Anyway, your kidding if you think you will get away 'we will give freo a 4th round pick or he can go into the psd for nothing' sort of attitude. A) you wont trade with anyone else because you will be seen as dicks and 2) If you do say that and he goes to the Dee's, you will kick yourself for not offering something decent- especially if warnock goes on to be a great player.
Thankgod you dont run Carltons trades, you wouldnt attract talent with that line of thinking.

 

[thylacine60]

channel 10 tonight says he hasnt nominated any club as a preference, Carlton have just offered the most coin so far and the australian newspaper ran with it.

Anyway, your kidding if you think you will get away 'we will give freo a 4th round pick or he can go into the psd for nothing' sort of attitude. A) you wont trade with anyone else because you will be seen as dicks and 2) If you do say that and he goes to the Dee's, you will kick yourself for not offering something decent- especially if warnock goes on to be a great player.
Thankgod you dont run Carltons trades, you wouldnt attract talent with that line of thinking.

Geez, we do apologize. You'll let us know the correct protocol for all our trading in future?

 

[Stig O'Hara]

channel 10 tonight says he hasnt nominated any club as a preference, Carlton have just offered the most coin so far and the australian newspaper ran with it.

Anyway, your kidding if you think you will get away 'we will give freo a 4th round pick or he can go into the psd for nothing' sort of attitude. A) you wont trade with anyone else because you will be seen as dicks and 2) If you do say that and he goes to the Dee's, you will kick yourself for not offering something decent- especially if warnock goes on to be a great player.
Thankgod you dont run Carltons trades, you wouldnt attract talent with that line of thinking.

Yeah, you don't want to be seen as a "dick",
obviously that is a new stat to be filed away somewhere.

This is business, sunshine,
we don't do handouts.

 

[rgauci]

channel 10 tonight says he hasnt nominated any club as a preference, Carlton have just offered the most coin so far and the australian newspaper ran with it.

Anyway, your kidding if you think you will get away 'we will give freo a 4th round pick or he can go into the psd for nothing' sort of attitude. A) you wont trade with anyone else because you will be seen as dicks and 2) If you do say that and he goes to the Dee's, you will kick yourself for not offering something decent- especially if warnock goes on to be a great player.
Thankgod you dont run Carltons trades, you wouldnt attract talent with that line of thinking.

Its cool. When gibbs is out of contract in a couple of years. All Adelaide or Port will have to offer is a 4th rounder.

Because, you know, he wants to go home, he'll get a bigger slice of the pie, and thats his preferred destination.

I mean seriously, its his preferred destination. Why wouldn't Carlton just bend over?

 

[SS_Fury]

you dont think other teams will look at you trying to offer a 4th round pick for warnock and find you a difficult club to trade with based on offers like this?
In any event, if the papers are correct you have already put pick 24 as your starting block on the table. Freo want more. So in the least your pick 24 is gone.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

you dont think other teams will look at you trying to offer a 4th round pick for warnock and find you a difficult club to trade with based on offers like this?

That is essentially how we got Nick Stevens.

Point i make is, that if he nominates us, we have the whip hand,
and be sure as heck we won't bend ass backwards to accomodate Freo.

Probably will be pick 24,
but that won't be our first offer.

No matter what Channel 10 tells you.

 

[CFC16]

The problem was Hughes like to watch from the wing......and from side on in 2005 you actually couldn't see Warnock.......he literally did not exist until ou saw him from the front he was that thin.

Hughes never knew he existed.

Honest mistake.

Dicks fixing it.

Yeah Great excuse honest mistake, then he recruits a ruckman with a soccer background in the best draft over Jetta, yeah an honest mistake.

 

[thylacine60]

Yeah Great excuse honest mistake, then he recruits a ruckman with a soccer background in the best draft over Jetta, yeah an honest mistake.

standby...........

 

[Mike_blues]

as long as pick 6 is left out of this im rapped

 

[BLUE BLEEDING]

it was funny today.
after it was confirmed warnock had nominated carlton my friend's were telling me that he is shit!

it really displayed peoples hate for carlton.

 

[nutcase888]

i admit i don't know alot about Warnock however i am not as excited by this as some others. We already have two very talented ruck prospects. what we need is a ready made ruckman who can fill the position to help us with a finals push for 09. From what i heard Warnock is still very much developing and has only played 21 games. what is so exciting about him that would make him worth anymore than our 4th round pick?