Play Nice Was that Gaffs last game for WC?

Joined
Dec 6, 2009
Posts
1,048
Likes
1,878
AFL Club
West Coast
A QC who deals with criminal assault and (I think) assaults on the footy pitch had some interesting comments on SEN about 20 minutes ago. From memory:

- Said without a question was an assault. Says the suspension should be 12 to 24 months.
- Said the police can lay charges without Brayshaw's assistance. The video is enough to do that.
- Said he defends people regularly on assault charges and this is as clean cut an example as you will find.
- Said intent is immaterial. You swing the fist and you bear the consequences, regardless of what you thought may happen.
- Said the fact that the assault occurred on the field during a match is immaterial. Assault is not one of the risks you reasonably assume when playing the game.


Yowzers.
Sure. Wanna bet $1000 that none of the above ever makes it to court?

The media will be interviewing Judge Judy next.... :)


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Ghossein

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 16, 2009
Posts
7,123
Likes
5,586
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Team Arrogance
A QC who deals with criminal assault and (I think) assaults on the footy pitch had some interesting comments on SEN about 20 minutes ago. From memory:

- Said without a question was an assault. Says the suspension should be 12 to 24 months.
- Said the police can lay charges without Brayshaw's assistance. The video is enough to do that.
- Said he defends people regularly on assault charges and this is as clean cut an example as you will find.
- Said intent is immaterial. You swing the fist and you bear the consequences, regardless of what you thought may happen.
- Said the fact that the assault occurred on the field during a match is immaterial. Assault is not one of the risks you reasonably assume when playing the game.


Yowzers.
Wouldn't happen to be Tom Percy would it?
 

JackOutback

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 15, 2011
Posts
17,263
Likes
21,141
AFL Club
West Coast
A QC who deals with criminal assault and (I think) assaults on the footy pitch had some interesting comments on SEN about 20 minutes ago. From memory:

- Said without a question was an assault. Says the suspension should be 12 to 24 months.
- Said the police can lay charges without Brayshaw's assistance. The video is enough to do that.
- Said he defends people regularly on assault charges and this is as clean cut an example as you will find.
- Said intent is immaterial. You swing the fist and you bear the consequences, regardless of what you thought may happen.
- Said the fact that the assault occurred on the field during a match is immaterial. Assault is not one of the risks you reasonably assume when playing the game.


Yowzers.
And despite all this, I'll bet dollars to doughnuts it doesn't go to court. No one wants to open that can of worms, not the AFL, not the players. People need to stop raising it as a realistic possibility.
 

Ghossein

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 16, 2009
Posts
7,123
Likes
5,586
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Team Arrogance
That is pretty much the sole reason Nisbett said their relationship was strained with Freo at the moment (other than the hit obviously), the fact that their chief legal council decided it would be a good idea to go on social media and have a rant about how Gaff should be imprisoned. Someone with legal training should surely know better than to make impassioned public statements while in an emotional state.
 

basashi

Premiership Player
Joined
Jun 18, 2010
Posts
3,509
Likes
4,371
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
FFC Quay Club
Its pretty weird now that the most hot headed, ill thought out and silly comments have come from the Eagles CEO. He should have taken time to calm down and think rationally before acting as rashly as he has.
 

Scotland

Hall of Famer
Joined
May 5, 2006
Posts
47,251
Likes
48,740
AFL Club
West Coast
And despite all this, I'll bet dollars to doughnuts it doesn't go to court. No one wants to open that can of worms, not the AFL, not the players. People need to stop raising it as a realistic possibility.
It's almost like all the people on the internet calling for criminal charges haven't even considered the ramifications down the line...
 

Carl Spackler

All Australian
Joined
Jul 29, 2018
Posts
732
Likes
1,548
AFL Club
Hawthorn
And despite all this, I'll bet dollars to doughnuts it doesn't go to court. No one wants to open that can of worms, not the AFL, not the players. People need to stop raising it as a realistic possibility.
He agreed that it would open a huge can of worms which why he suggested the AFL provide him a heavy suspension so that the police do not get involved. Also he said it was the worst case of assault on the footy pitch that he's ever seen.

Hyperbole? I don't know. He sounded serious. And he obviously is a defending attorney, not a prosecuting one. So who knows?
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2009
Posts
1,048
Likes
1,878
AFL Club
West Coast
Its pretty weird now that the most hot headed, ill thought out and silly comments have come from the Eagles CEO. He should have taken time to calm down and think rationally before acting as rashly as he has.
Huh?

Nothing hot headed at all re Nisbet. He correctly told serial sex pest Lyon to not talk complete and utter crap in the heat of the moment. :)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Scotland

Hall of Famer
Joined
May 5, 2006
Posts
47,251
Likes
48,740
AFL Club
West Coast
Its pretty weird now that the most hot headed, ill thought out and silly comments have come from the Eagles CEO. He should have taken time to calm down and think rationally before acting as rashly as he has.
I assume you are only referring to public comments. Nisbett is a peanut but he's got nothing on the collective minds of BigFooty.
 

JD888

Debutant
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Posts
140
Likes
199
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Still not quite 24hrs since this thread started. Not quite at 100 pages yet. Wondering what the quickest time is that a thread went to 100 pages?
 

Fadge

Premiership Player
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Posts
4,285
Likes
2,858
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
The incident does raise an interesting question about where it does cross over to be a criminal offence.

I'd go as far as to say that if this incident happened anywhere other than a football field - workplace, pub, street - and there was video evidence, it would definitely be a criminal offence.

If a player absolutely kicked the living daylights out of an opponent, repeatedly, and left them as a vegetable, I don't reckon there would be too many saying that shouldn't result in time in the big house.

So where is the line?
 

threesixpio

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jun 28, 2013
Posts
23,638
Likes
30,687
AFL Club
Hawthorn
And yet we are seeking to punish Gaff for breaking a jaw which is far LESS serious than concussions. And we've seen a few punches resulting in concussions getting 2-4 weeks max...

Is the emotional over play because some folks saw blood and Brayshaw is young? Both pretty irrelevant in terms of the punishment warranted.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Breaking someone’s jaw is not far less serious than a concussion. What a crock of shit.
 

liz

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Nov 14, 2001
Posts
5,361
Likes
1,719
Location
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
And yet we are seeking to punish Gaff for breaking a jaw which is far LESS serious than concussions. And we've seen a few punches resulting in concussions getting 2-4 weeks max...

Is the emotional over play because some folks saw blood and Brayshaw is young? Both pretty irrelevant in terms of the punishment warranted.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Not sure that a broken jaw is conclusively "far LESS serious than concussions". There are long term implications of multiple concussions, many of which aren't properly understood yet, but the immediate impact isn't as severe as an operation to fix a broken jaw and the inability to eat solids for a year. And it's possible that Brayshaw suffered a concussion too - we haven't been told.

I doubt anyone would receive a 2-4 week penalty for an off the ball punch that was hard enough to cause concussion, even if it didn't break any bones. Can you cite any examples? The most recent comparable incident was Bugg just over a year ago. He got six weeks. Cameron's wasn't quite the same, given he was at least in the vicinity of the ball, notwithstanding the fact that the raising of the elbow in a marking contest is classified by the AFL as being intentional. And he got five - more than the two to 4 that you quote.
 

Tas

Premium Gold
Joined
Dec 23, 2002
Posts
52,068
Likes
33,038
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
There can be only one...
I doubt Brayshaw is going to be launching a claim against Gaff. I don’t see how this could possibly amount to a civil claim unless Brayshaw doesn’t return from his injuries. Insurance will cover off the rest of any expenses incurred in his recovery.
Yeah, I doubt it as well. Just saying that it is a possibility and should it be something that comes up I am sure it will be dealt with behind closed doors and they would come to terms so I don't believe there needs to be any real hysterics. I am sure they will look after Brayshaw and it is going to be extremely painful for him to be sucking his meals through a straw for a month.

Sadly, for victims of anything, you can't undo what has been done to them. It doesn't mean we need to resort to extremes or even be cruel to the perpetrator because I don't think it was something premeditated and malicious. If he is remorseful and if he will learn and be rehabilitated by more lenient punishment then that should be something that is looked at. Not suggesting he should get let off, but we are often motivated by vengeance rather than rehabilitation.

If it was a serial sniper who has been let of leniently for numerous issues then I would say perhaps being lenient hasn't got the message through and nor has he rehabilitated to an acceptable standard and something more severe would be in order.
 

Rich01

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Posts
6,348
Likes
5,210
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Richmond
Eagles fans at the game reportedly cheering Gaff after King hitting Brayshaw.

Strange behaviour from the same mob that booed Adam Goodes for some unknown reason.

They have really weird values those Eagles members.
 

Sir_Loin

Premium Platinum
Joined
Oct 20, 2015
Posts
17,577
Likes
39,717
AFL Club
Richmond
Yeah, I doubt it as well. Just saying that it is a possibility and should it be something that comes up I am sure it will be dealt with behind closed doors and they would come to terms so I don't believe there needs to be any real hysterics. I am sure they will look after Brayshaw and it is going to be extremely painful for him to be sucking his meals through a straw for a month.

Sadly, for victims of anything, you can't undo what has been done to them. It doesn't mean we need to resort to extremes or even be cruel to the perpetrator because I don't think it was something premeditated and malicious if he is remorseful and if he will learn and be rehabilitated by more lenient punishment. Not suggesting he should get let off, but we are often motivated by vengeance rather than rehabilitation.

If it was a serial sniper who has been let of leniently for numerous issues then I would say perhaps being lenient hasn't got the message through and nor has he rehabilitated to an acceptable standard and something more severe would be in order.
I agree with you on that. I have no interest in anything other than the AFL dishing up the appropriate sanction and then moving on.
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2009
Posts
1,048
Likes
1,878
AFL Club
West Coast
Its hard to deflect 2 prominent QCs. You have comprehensively argued Percy into a corner. What about Galbally?
Galbally didn't actually say anything.

"If he did that on the street he could get jail time "..

"I can't completely rule out the possibility of the police bringing charges"

"it's very unlikely to happen"

Thanks David. Really added something...
 
Joined
Dec 6, 2009
Posts
1,048
Likes
1,878
AFL Club
West Coast
Eagles fans at the game reportedly cheering Gaff after King hitting Brayshaw.

Strange behaviour from the same mob that booed Adam Goodes for some unknown reason.

They have really weird values those Eagles members.
The video of the incident wasn't played at the stadium.

Most Eagles fans at the game hadn't seen the incident until after the game...
 
Top Bottom