GreyCrow
Make me an Admin!
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2016
- Posts
- 92,723
- Reaction score
- 157,493
- Location
- Down South Corvus Tristis
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Sturt, White Sox, Tasmania
Forwards are defenders with no discipline
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Best defenders are the ones which are offensive & can still defend.Defending is for people with no talent.
Settle down all you defenders, I’m only (half) joking.
Midfield is where you put people who can't defend and can't kick for shit.Defending is for people with no talent.
Settle down all you defenders, I’m only (half) joking.
Feel like the wing would be his best position in an ideal world. He doesn't get exposed as much defensively and allows him to attack higher up the ground. Pre all the injuries, he was one of our best in the time trials for memory too. That said, hard to tell if he can get back to pre injury level or not just yet.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Midfield is where you put people who can't defend and can't kick for s**t.
I feel like hbf is one of the easier positions to play and shouldn't be all that difficult to fill - although who that is at the moment, im not too sure.agree all though, HBF might be the bigger need, from our currently listed players i'm more confident of finding another decent wingman than i am of developing a good hbf
We need to have the right balance of outside players who can use the ball, who ideally can switch between HBF & wing if need be.I feel like hbf is one of the easier positions to play and shouldn't be all that difficult to fill - although who that is at the moment, im not too sure.
But we had Brett Reilly looking elite one season off half back, no offense to him but he wasn't exactly flying prior to that, should be an easier position to fill and one used to blood up and coming players in.
Could probably add Sholl and Dawson to that list. Jones as well?We need to have the right balance of outside players who can use the ball, who ideally can switch between HBF & wing if need be.
Milera, Smith, Hinge, Hamill & Parnell are all in this category.
Sholl doesn't have the strength to play HBF, Dawson and Jones absolutelyCould probably add Sholl and Dawson to that list. Jones as well?
Feel like the wing would be his best position in an ideal world. He doesn't get exposed as much defensively and allows him to attack higher up the ground. Pre all the injuries, he was one of our best in the time trials for memory too. That said, hard to tell if he can get back to pre injury level or not just yet.
Agreed. Gave us a real taste last year with some of his lace out passes to a leading Fog last year. Seems to be a bit of chemistry there already, would love to see that continue to evolve.I think the list management team would be placing Milera close to the top of the list of players ranked by skills.
This positions Milera as one of the most important members of the team, and he started to show his value last year in his goal assists.
Given our potent forward line, the link up player is now a critical need. Our game plan is based from turnover, created by pressure particularly from the midfield.
The outside role player who can accept the ball, get through traffic and deliver to the forwards is crucial. This is Milera's role, and I can't think of a better player to execute. Maybe Dawson, but I'm not sure he has the deft touch of lowering the eyes and hitting the chest quite as well.
This is why IMO we will persist with Milera and his form/ injury inconsistencies, and I'll be watching him closely this year for the work he does approaching forward 50.
On SM-F926B using BigFooty.com mobile app
Just like how Brad Crouch was going to be our saviour every year.I see we're at the talking Wayne up stage
Yeah, I have jumped off the Milera train... hopefully reverse psychology.... but with all the young talent coming through, I think it's more likely we invest games elsewhere.I see we're at the talking Wayne up stage
Haha, there's no doubt he's skilful, it's just a matter of whether he can finally make an impact.I see we're at the talking Wayne up stage
We tried Cook but he flat out didn’t compete at timesWe really showed a lot of persistence with him last year when his performances didn't deserve a spot in the team.
He needs to start delivering in a big way this season, and not with only a couple of nice kicks a game.
Sometimes I wished we tried Cook a bit more instead of Milera last year
Haha, there's no doubt he's skilful, it's just a matter of whether he can finally make an impact.
On SM-F926B using BigFooty.com mobile app
They also played him hff alot late in the year which is not his position at all. Felt like they were just giving him games for fitness / keep up with the speed.We really showed a lot of persistence with him last year when his performances didn't deserve a spot in the team.
He needs to start delivering in a big way this season, and not with only a couple of nice kicks a game.
Sometimes I wished we tried Cook a bit more instead of Milera last year
I see we're at the talking Wayne up stage
Convince me I could not write exactly the same thing now after 79 games.Ok, he's only 11 games into his career, so it is waaaaay too early say one way or the other what type of career he is going to have.
But right now I just wish I was seeing more from him that had me thinking "yep, he's going to rip apart a game one day"
I'm not seeing top level skill, run or determination. He's clearly not a dud, but he's a first round pick and needs to judged by that level. And right at the moment I feel like his game is a bit... nothing.
Too often we see him stand back while the tackle is there to be made, the defensive effort is very poor, and I'm not getting any sense of him making up for that by being a goal scorer.
Started this thread after 11 games. And never since have I thought he has lived up to any expectations. Close a few times to think maybe. But nope.
Convince me I could not write exactly the same thing now after 79 games.