- Joined
- May 16, 2015
- Posts
- 19,394
- Reaction score
- 27,335
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- WWTFC,Chelsea,Glasgow Celtic,Lech Poznan
I agree with this guy, how was that ever a throw. The umpire guessed it to be.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
I agree with this guy, how was that ever a throw. The umpire guessed it to be.
I'd like to hear him say that to the AFL. He assumed. I'd like to listen to their response.Howler, but that’s not the speed the ump saw it at. Pure guess I reckon and paid it because Milera didn’t really take possession, just assumed it must have been a throw as it was so quick.

I'd like to hear him say that to the AFL. He assumed. I'd like to listen to their response.
The commentator at normal speed says he got a hand to it.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
They get things wrong enough when they actually see what happened, we don't need umpires guessing when they haven't seen anything.It doesn’t really matter what he says, he couldn’t have seen a throw because it wasn’t one. Commentator also has potentially a very different angle. Ump should be dropped either way.
Given the way we use our wingers that's probably not going to get Milera more of the ball.
I'd like to hear him say that to the AFL. He assumed. I'd like to listen to their response.
The commentator at normal speed says he got a hand to it.
I think its worth a shot, but we'll get more out of Cumming that way than Milera.What would we lose doing a straight swap of Cummings and Milera. Reckon both would be better for it.
Milera was a 1st round draft pick heralded as a forward/mid with elite ball skills. What an overpay/ waste if he plays another 50 games as a small defender.
We have better options as that lock down defender than we do wing right now.
No we are all like you ignoring when I asked you pre-game who he would standYou not busy looking up the all the forwards who got hold of Milera this year? Admitting you’re wrong is a sign of strength.
I think its worth a shot, but we'll get more out of Cumming that way than Milera.
I think we need to park the 1st round pick stuff for Wayne, that was 10 years ago now and a lot of water has gone under the operating table.
I think hes got massive self doubt as to whether he can actually do what he used to be able to do.What the Milera defenders don't get is this is not a Murphy whipping boy thing.
It's that Milera has all the skills you could ever want, he should be a game influencer, but the outward appearance is someone who doesn't always bring the intensity. Good enough doesn't win premierships.
Milera was a 1st round draft pick heralded as a forward/mid with elite ball skills. What an overpay/ waste if he plays another 50 games as a small defender.
This is fairI think hes got massive self doubt as to whether he can actually do what he used to be able to do.
Just a hunch.
I think hes got massive self doubt as to whether he can actually do what he used to be able to do.
Just a hunch.
They get things wrong enough when they actually see what happened, we don't need umpires guessing when they haven't seen anything.
Don’t cry mate, I’m too busy later in the week to get on here much. It’s a no brainer anyway. Max gets the strong overheard mid/smalls like Elliot and Laird doesn’t have the pace to go with Bobby Hill. Milera’s had the more accountable defender role all season - except against Carlton cause they have no dangerous smalls and Hinge was out. All of you denying it like it’s some kind of wild conspiracy when you can just watch the freaking game and it’s right in front of your face.No we are all like you ignoring when I asked you pre-game who he would stand
Don’t cry mate, I’m too busy later in the week to get on here much. It’s a no brainer anyway. Max gets the strong overheard mid/smalls like Elliot and Laird doesn’t have the pace to go with Bobby Hill. Milera’s had the more accountable defender role all season - except against Carlton cause they have no dangerous smalls and Hinge was out. All of you denying it like it’s some kind of wild conspiracy when you can just watch the freaking game and it’s right in front of your face.
I think hes got massive self doubt as to whether he can actually do what he used to be able to do.
Just a hunch.
His only goal which came from a Cumming brain fade. He got 6 touches in 100 minutes of football. It’s like arguing with small children. Have your little whipping boy bubble and let the adults watch football.You must have had gone for a comfort break when lock down small defender Milera was 15 metres away from Hill at the fall of the ball for that soccered goal.
Spare us the patronizing on who does and doesn't watch games.
Practice what you preachLet the adults watch football.
His only goal which came from a Cumming brain fade. He got 6 touches in 100 minutes of football. It’s like arguing with small children. Have your little whipping boy bubble and let the adults watch football.