WCE Pick 21 - Allen or Kelly

[Astro7]

It's Allen Kelly to Petrucelle...

 

[kerr87]

It's Allen Kelly to Petrucelle...

Brander to Allen to Kelly to Ryan to Petch

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Question should be Brander or Kelly, with a draft haul of Allen with our first pick, Kelly with our second and Ryan with our third.

Hopefully Brander has a chance to impress next year, and not because of injuries, but because his form is irrepressible.

 

[kerr87]

We've got all 4.

IN: Brander Kelly Allen Ryan + 2019 Pick 52 + 2020 3rd Round Pick

OUT: 2017 Picks 13, 21, 26 + 2019 Picks 14, 24, 33 + 2020 1st Round Pick

In other words, we gave up:
3x First Rounders
4x Second Rounders

For:
3x A-Grade Players: Kelly Ryan Allen
1x Talented KPP
2x Third Rounders

The 3 first rounders cancel out 3 A-Grade players.

2x 2nd Rounders for talented young KPP. Arguably best of the draft class.

2x 2nd Rounders were downgraded to 3rd Rounders.

If you look at our trading over that period of time we killed it, dpn't look at the Kelly trade in isolation this year.

We've had a clear stategy over a few years to improve our list. We've done that.

 

[Astro7]

Brander to Allen to Kelly to Ryan to Petch

was just making rhymes...

 

[eagles rule]

He's a graduate of the "Scotty Lycett School of Goalkicking".

The Nick Riewoldt grand final school of misses takes presedence and deserves mention..


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[The wily weagle]

I'm still not sold on Brander, he shows glimpses, and he has the tools, but he is inconsistent.

Unless he has some kind of epiphany moment and starts dominating the WAFL, which he should be, I am not entirely convinced he was the right choice

I truly hope he proves me wrong

 

[RookiePick]

Question should be Brander or Kelly, with a draft haul of Allen with our first pick, Kelly with our second and Ryan with our third.

Hopefully Brander has a chance to impress next year, and not because of injuries, but because his form is irrepressible.

The nature of Brander was i-ree-pressible!