WC's "ageing" squad

[Visro]

Reallistically if Freo did want Cummings they would only give us about a 3rd round draft pick at best as thats all he's worth at the moment.

Hey Rob, whats wrong with Trent Carroll? He's been good for us this year and although he does make occasional dumb mistakes he is quite accountable on his players and has shut down some dangerous forwards.

Vis

 

[jod23]

Rob - have you seen an Eagles games this year?? Carroll has been a highlight for us in defence, he's still young too.

 

[sabre_ac]

Carrol was always going to be a AVERAGE player.
He is nothing special, but I agree he didnt deserve to be delisted.He is a better player than that.

Im sure he will fit in nicely at your club, but we have a brown a very similar TYPE of player to Carroll.But a far better player

 

[Voice of Reason]

I was distinctly underimpressed with the way Carroll started the year, but to his credit he has really worked on his game and improved. Often he's had to take the opposition's best or second best forward, eg Richardson against Richmond, and has done very well.

Now, if you'd been talking about his mate Harding............