Remove this Banner Ad

We need to blood a small defender

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Kooley

Norm Smith Medallist
Oct 15, 2003
7,870
26
out west
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
arsenal
time for an armfield or browne to be blooded to play on scum like milne. i'm sick of seeing houlihan and gibbs playing in the last line. these two boys were reruited to play on dangerous forwards so ****ing use them.
 
You could throw Joey Anderson into that mix as well Kooley. Not sure Browne is ready for a senior call up just yet. Armfield gives you his all every week, yet I think a step up from WAFL to AFL in such a short space of time might be asking a bit too much of him.
the kid is 22 and has a ready made body for senior footy so it wouldn't hurt to see him given a role.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

the kid is 22 and has a ready made body for senior footy so it wouldn't hurt to see him given a role.

He certainly has the body to play AFL, however, i'm just not sure he's up to it at the moment. What's the harm in letting him play a few games with the Bullants?
 
Houlihan is not nimble enough and doesn't provide any run whatsoever. The amount of times we held up play between BP and HBF tonight was ridiculous. We miss Walker terribly. Houlihan has to go forward as an opportunist, or get the arse.
 
He certainly has the body to play AFL, however, i'm just not sure he's up to it at the moment. What's the harm in letting him play a few games with the Bullants?
I wouldn't suggest that VFL level footy is a whole lot better than WAFL if at all... give him a crack I reckon.
 
Houlihan is not nimble enough and doesn't provide any run whatsoever. The amount of times we held up play between BP and HBF tonight was ridiculous. We miss Walker terribly. Houlihan has to go forward as an opportunist, or get the arse.

This also stems from the problem that we didn't have a target accross HF tonight.
 
I agree - we cannot continue to persevere with Houlihan on the last line of defense. He's an incredibly creative player when given time and the only place he's going to get that is further up the ground.

Anderson, Armfield and Browne need to step up. We need one or more of them to develop into a close-checking small defender to negate the small ****s like Milne.
 
True, but these guys across half back couldn't or didn't want to run and create, or at least try and take on the opposition... things other team seem to do to us effortlessly.
 
I agree - we cannot continue to persevere with Houlihan on the last line of defense. He's an incredibly creative player when given time and the only place he's going to get that is further up the ground.

Anderson, Armfield and Browne need to step up. We need one or more of them to develop into a close-checking small defender to negate the small ****s like Milne.
He gets enough time to use the ball well enough from the back pocket, the only problem is is that it's not damaging. He could touch the ball the same amount of times as a half forward and do ten-fold the damage as what he does down back.
 
He gets enough time to use the ball well enough from the back pocket, the only problem is is that it's not damaging. He could touch the ball the same amount of times as a half forward and do ten-fold the damage as what he does down back.

When he gets the ball he is often on the last line of defense and under pressure to target a Carlton player up the ground, often with forwards bearing down on him. He isn't suited to that role and often panics and turns it over.

Up forward he could use his creativity to put pressure where we need it most - on the scoreboard. If we played him up forward I have no doubt he could chip in for a few goals per match.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Joey Anderson when fit, Dennis Armfield very soon, big chance for next week IMO. Steven Browne mid season or so will get his chance. Hopefully one out of the three will give us what we need!
 
We have some options long term for this role, I think Browne is the most likely.


How about our small forward crisis? More pressing than small defenders.

We have betts & that is where it ends.
 
Houlihan needs to go forward - we need to get these kids in.....we let the kids learn the game in the reserves, then in the defense, then eventually ....well actually gibbs is STILL there.

We neeeeed to do something. If ratten has decided to throw this season away - then lets at least do it on bringing the kids online...please.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

We need to blood a small defender

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top