webster

[dockervic]

luke is obviously nice guy ,good clubman but just not good enough for afl ..great in wafl but just doesnt measure up in the big stuff time to bring in a youngster ie duffield

 

[Cameron_K]

Where is Embers tonight asking about his game??

 

[ImperialPurple]

Hate to say it but I agree...

Also hate to say it, but Cookie just does not cut it away from Subi... And is definitely right on the fringe at home as well.... Quite simply, Cookie should not be selected for any games away from Subiaco from here on.

 

[turbo182]

Yeha I wondered what websters best position was.

Couldn't seem to have an impact at anytime in a variety of positions.

 

[sabre_ac]

I have never seen what all the fuss is about concerning Webster, no room for both himself and Solomon.

Solomon any day of the week.

 

[Kenny_01]

Webster > Cook

 

[estibador]

I thought Webster was ok tonight considering he seemed to spend a lot of time on the bench as usual. At least when he gets the ball he usually manages to hit someone on the chest.

 

[theGav56]

I thought Webster was ok tonight considering he seemed to spend a lot of time on the bench as usual. At least when he gets the ball he usually manages to hit someone on the chest.

His disposal last night was ordinary, missing people with handpasses when not under pressure. To me he is a very good example that shows that having a big heart is not enough. Webster is a genuine depth player, no more. The only time I have seen him play well is when the coaches have a very specific requirement for him. He carries out out to the best of his ability.

 

[raffrox]

Webster got found out with the intensity last night unfortunately. I agree Webster > Cook though.

 

[summerthebat]

He played an average match, but I still rate him. He laid a great tackle when it was tight, I don't think Webster and Solomon should be compared I think that Sol should be weighed up with Cook.

 

[theGav56]

I don't think Webster and Solomon should be compared I think that Sol should be weighed up with Cook.

If I was a Webster supporter I would think the same. They both generally play as defensive forwards, with a run in the middle occassionally, and at the moment Solomon is doing that way better than Webster.

 

[inferno66]

Next week I would like to see Duffield and Collard to come in for Webster and Cook. We need to get some game time into our younger kids.

 

[Tony_Clifton]

I think Webster should be getting regular games. Give him a chance to string a few together with more game time.

Cookie is pretty much finished away from Subi.

 

[dominguez]

I think only 2 of Cook, Webster and Solomon should play in dry conditions. Solomon won't be dropped, so either Cookie or Webster shouldn't play next week. Webster has by far the best kick of the three. Having Tarrant and Solomon in attack is a worry when Pav is missing the goals too. It would have probably been worth playing Mundy forward for the whole game and shifting Solomon to half back last night.

Stats from last night-
Webster 11 possessions 5 marks 6 tackles 0 goals in 87 minutes
Cook 8 possessions 1 mark 5 tackles 0 goals in 60 minutes
Solomon 11 possessions 2 marks 2 tackles 0 goals in 86 minutes

 

[Dr Ralph Dagg]

luke is obviously nice guy ,good clubman but just not good enough for afl ..great in wafl but just doesnt measure up in the big stuff time to bring in a youngster ie duffield

I'd rate him a lot higher the Duffield. Duffield's been in the system a while now -- he is 22. And we need to be playing our very best team.

Webster is being played as a defensive forward and doing a relatively good job. He did a fantastic job on Rhys (?) Shaw on Friday night. He did the job against McLeod. Here's the guy that kicked the winning point against Adelaide and people want him dropped for not handling the pressure.

Sorry I can't follow the rationale.

 

[Kenny_01]

I'd rate him a lot higher the Duffield. Duffield's been in the system a while now -- he is 22. And we need to be playing our very best team.

Webster is being played as a defensive forward and doing a relatively good job. He did a fantastic job on Rhys (?) Shaw on Friday night. He did the job against McLeod. Here's the guy that kicked the winning point against Adelaide and people want him dropped for not handling the pressure.

Sorry I can't follow the rationale.

I agree Ralph. Cookie however, is finished.