Week 1 - the other games

[Topkent]

Lol already articles and discussion on whether Treloars booing was a disgrace.

Since when was it Collingwood's fans responsibility to make another teams player feel comfortable?
Sorry unless it's Luke Hodge or Steve Johnson playing for another club you boo the **** out of thst campaigner. Hopefully he crys at halftime and has a shocker.

 

[Dory_77]

The booing seems a bit dumb as Treloar was pushed rather than jumping ship (like Scilly or Cameron) but it's being precious to say it's a disgrace. If it keeps up beyond this game when he plays the Pies I'd be surprised.

 

[Topkent]

The booing seems a bit dumb as Treloar was pushed rather than jumping ship (like Scilly or Cameron) but it's being precious to say it's a disgrace. If it keeps up beyond this game when he plays the Pies I'd be surprised.

The situation doesn't matter though, Collingwood fans job is to support there team, if they can stifle Treloar by getting in his head they should. They shouldn't be making him comfy

 

[TheCount]

The situation doesn't matter though, Collingwood fans job is to support there team, if they can stifle Treloar by getting in his head they should. They shouldn't be making him comfy

Given he was still crying about it 3 days ago, it'd be irresponsible of their fans not to try and get in his head.

 

[Topkent]

Given he was still crying about it 3 days ago, it'd be irresponsible of their fans not to try and get in his head.

100%
I'm not saying abuse him in the street, but yeah mid game. Get in his head

 

[Grimesy87]

Well done anyone on sitting through the rest of this game.

I'm going to catch up on the last couple of episodes of your honour I've missed.

 

[GatesOfHell]

Pies look ordinary. Buckley is a dead man walking with that list.

Tim English developing into a very good player.

 

[Daemon]

I haven't watched 100% of the game but anyone else think Grundy seems way off best form?

 

[Daemon]

Pies look ordinary. Buckley is a dead man walking with that list.

Tim English developing into a very good player.

Would be surprised if Buckley and Goodwin are coaching next year.

 

[Proper Gander]

The Steph Martin Experience!

 

[TheCount]

I haven't watched 100% of the game but anyone else think Grundy seems way off best form?

I'm the same in that I haven't watched it intently, but I've almost not seen him. He's up against two blokes to be fair, but 2 years ago that didn't matter. Has continued on tonight from his form last season, which is a massive concern for them.

 

[Bluelegs]

Wtf is this nothing presentation?

 

[Bluelegs]

Pies look ordinary. Buckley is a dead man walking with that list.

Tim English developing into a very good player.

Without Eddie there Buckley's got no protection anymore. If pies miss finals they'll make a massive play for Clarkson.

 

[LeverPuller]

Without Eddie there Buckley's got no protection anymore. If pies miss finals they'll make a massive play for Clarkson.

Pies are more than a Clarko away.

 

[Topkent]

Without Eddie there Buckley's got no protection anymore. If pies miss finals they'll make a massive play for Clarkson.

I don't agree with this

Since 2016 pies have finished 13, 3rd, GF, 8th.
Dogs have finished 10,13,7,7

Only difference in the coaches is Sheed kicks the goal of the century in a GF.

 

[ImissFrosty]

I haven't watched 100% of the game but anyone else think Grundy seems way off best form?

He's terrible, if I ever hear somebody compare him to Gawn again I'm gonna be sick.

 

[Proper Gander]

Pies are more than a Clarko away.

Sam Mitchell is their VFL coach right? If they are looking at Clarko system, maybe someone like that might be useful? More useful for the medium to longer term anyway

 

[Dory_77]

I haven't watched 100% of the game but anyone else think Grundy seems way off best form?

Yeah, well done. English is better and Martin helps so he was gonna struggle a bit but it hasn't bothered him that much in the past. Very meh performance all round by the Pies.

 

[Bluelegs]

I don't agree with this

Since 2016 pies have finished 13, 3rd, GF, 8th.
Dogs have finished 10,13,7,7

Only difference in the coaches is Sheed kicks the goal of the century in a GF.

Dogs peaked at the right time and fluked a flag well before they were ready. They were smart enough not to rest on their laurels and have added a heap to their list since then.

Pies have wasted a few years of their premiership window and don't look close to getting back to their 2018 level.

Reckon Clarkson's as likely to leave Hawthorn now as ever and it will probably be a bit of a bidding war come the year's end.

 

[schmuttt]

Dogs have lowered their eyes on every inside 50 entry so far. Probably more than we do in a whole match.

This didn’t age well. They should have won by 10 goals.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

The Steph Martin Experience!

Every ****ing time I read the acronym SME at work this is the first thing my brain forces out. I'm certain Supermercado did that on purpose.

 

[schmuttt]

Geez I hope carlton lose to Collingwood next week.

 

[Bluelegs]

Geez I hope carlton lose to Collingwood next week.

Reckon whoever loses that game won't make finals.

 

[Meds]

The booing seems a bit dumb as Treloar was pushed rather than jumping ship (like Scilly or Cameron) but it's being precious to say it's a disgrace. If it keeps up beyond this game when he plays the Pies I'd be surprised.

After witnessing pies supporters boo David Neitz in his 300th game nothing surprises me about them.

 

[ImissFrosty]

After witnessing pies supporters boo David Neitz in his 300th game nothing surprises me about them.

Was bound to happen when the collective IQ of the crowd was in single figures.