Competitions West Coast Board Mock Draft V1.0

[Keys]

1. Gold Coast - Dylan Patterson (Bid matched using picks 18,21,24,27)
2. Brisbane - Dan Annable (Bid matched using picks 18,22,41,44)
3. Gold Coast - Zeke Uwland (Bid matched using picks 24,35,32,46)
4. West Coast - Willem Duursma
5. West Coast - Cooper Duff-Tytler
6. Richmond - Sullivan Robey
7. Richmond - Xavier Taylor
8. Essendon - Aidan Schubert
9. Essendon - Sam Cumming
10. Carlton - Harry Dean (Bid matched using picks 12,14 with pick 15 going back to Carlton)
11. West Coast - Dyson Sharp
12. Melbourne - Lachy Dovaston
13. Hawthorn - Oliver Greeves
14. GWS - Sam Grlj
15. Carlton - Josh Lindsay
16. Melbourne - Beau Addinsall (Bid not matched)
17. Western Bulldogs - Jacob Farrow
18. Essendon - Oskar Taylor
19. Sydney - Blake Thredgold
20. Geelong - Tylah Williams (Bid not matched)
21. Fremantle - Mitch Marsh
22. Hawthorn - Jevan Phillipou
23. North Melbourne - Archie Ludowycke
24. North Melbourne - Noah Hibbins-Hargreaves
25. Essendon - Harley Barker
26. Adelaide - Latrelle Sumner-Pickett
27. Sydney - Max King
    Multiple players found. Use birthday to differentiate. eg [PLAYERCARD="23/11/1962"]Joe Smith[/PLAYERCARD]
28. Western Bulldogs - Taylor Byrne
29. West Coast - Blake Oudshoorn-Bennier
30. Essendon - Hussein El Achkar (Bid matched by going into deficit )
31. GWS - Louis Emmett
32. Fremantle - Matthew LeRay
33. Carlton - Jack Ison (Bid matched using picks 38 and 46 with pick 48 going back)
34. Richmond - Jack Dalton
35. Collingwood - Fred Rodriguez
36. Geelong - Lachlan Carmichael (Bid not matched)
37. Essendon - Adam Sweid (Bid matched using next pick in draft)
38. West Coast - Leon Kickett
39. Sydney - Harry Kyle (Bid matched with pick 47)
40. West Coast - Charlie Banfield (Bid matched with pick 47)
41. Adelaide - Cameron Nairn
42. Collingwood - Riley Onley
43. North Melbourne - Cody Curtin
44. Melbourne - Sam Ainsworth
45. Adelaide - Avery Thomas
46. Port Adelaide - Hunter Holmes
47. Fremantle - Toby Whan (Bid matched)
48. St Kilda - Luke Hallett
49. Collingwood - Bryce Sanders
50. Carlton - Sam Swadling
51. North Melbourne - Max Kondogiannis
52. West Coast - Taj Murray
53. Melbourne - Clancy Dennis
54. Geelong - Tom Evans
55. Collingwood - Zak McCarthy

End R3

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

I think that means our resident wise old sage, txbyhull is up for Freo.

 

[KBLT]

Well done Woosha, very on brand cvntyness from Geelong.

 

[KBLT]

Also technically Geelong drafted Tyler Williams, not Tylah Williams. I dont know who Tyler is, but he's not one of ours.

 

[eaglevision]

I'm going to get flamed for this but I'm going to pass. I just think it's too early for my liking.

No good call way too early. Way too much emphasis on his combine results.

 

[txbyhull]

Alright I will finish making my roast beef, 3 cheese, pickle and mustard toastie then get back to you all.


Pick 21 + 40 or 50 is on the table for a trade back of 2 selections

 

[txbyhull]

I find myself in the position to take a premium talent with pick 21, an incredibly surprising one at that. It was a toss up between Phillipou and this guy.

Fremantle select ‘The Bison’ Mitch Marsh, 190cm Hybrid FWD out of West Adelaide.

Adept aerially, elite 1 on 1 and a fantastic kick on goal, Marsh has shown flashes further up field even as far as the wing late in the season, showing off an impressive field kick and endurance. 30 goals in SANFL u18s and 2 late games with 18 and 20 touches pushing closer to the action, as well as 12 goals in 4 games at champs, he’s too good to pass up here.

 

[txbyhull]

1Bally1 picking once again for the Hawks

 

[1Bally1]

hawthorn select jevan phillipou

 

[RustyShacklefordFalcon]

I find myself in the position to take a premium talent with pick 21, an incredibly surprising one at that. It was a toss up between Phillipou and this guy.

Fremantle select ‘The Bison’ Mitch Marsh, 190cm Hybrid FWD out of West Adelaide.

Pfft, I dunno...he doesn't look THAT good.

 

[txbyhull]

wadistance on the clock for the Roos

 

[Keys]

Dont match Ardent. Too early

I'm going to get flamed for this but I'm going to pass. I just think it's too early for my liking.

No good call way too early. Way too much emphasis on his combine results.

I feel it needs to be remembered that although this bid was made at pick 20, WCE don’t need to use that pick to match.

In this instance it was pick 29 with 35 sliding back to 46

So the comparison isn’t between Tylah and those players still on the board at pick 20, it’s between him and who is likely to still be available at pick 29

A club has to really like him to throw up a bid this early

 

[eaglevision]

I feel it needs to be remembered that although this bid was made at pick 20, WCE don’t need to use that pick to match.

In this instance it was pick 29 with 35 sliding back to 46

So the comparison isn’t between Tylah and those players still on the board at pick 20, it’s between him and who is likely to still be available at pick 29

A club has to really like him to throw up a bid this early

There’s players in the mid-late 30s I’d take before Tylah. Saw that ArdentEagle had pick 29, no way I’m burning that on Tylah. Looking forward to seeing who is selected at that pick.

 

[Jeremy McLovin]

I definitely couldn't be a list manager, first pick was fun but now I'm just sitting here salty as **** watching all the players I hoped would slide get picked up.

 

[SAweagle]

I'm going to get flamed for this but I'm going to pass. I just think it's too early for my liking.

 

[Wooshaaaa]

There’s players in the mid-late 30s I’d take before Tylah. Saw that ArdentEagle had pick 29, no way I’m burning that on Tylah. Looking forward to seeing who is selected at that pick.

It is a draft that these type of risky selections will be made.

Our recruiters needs to think long and hard about how much we value Williams Banfield and Evans.

My selection of Williams for the cats was probably too early. I toyed with taking barker but the ACL spooked me. The Poo wasn't interested in as I think the cats have enough mids. It really came down to Williams as speculative pick that would change the look of the forward 6 or taking a ruckman Emmett as the cats don't have a ruckman.

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

It is a draft that these type of risky selections will be made.

Our recruiters needs to think long and hard about how much we value Williams Banfield and Evans.

My selection of Williams for the cats was probably too early. I toyed with taking barker but the ACL spooked me. The Poo wasn't interested in as I think the cats have enough mids. It really came down to Williams as speculative pick that would change the look of the forward 6 or taking a ruckman Emmett as the cats don't have a ruckman.

I would urge them not to think hard about Banfield. If the Bode were to have placed a bid on Charlie at this point in the draft, I would bloody well hope we match it.

Not sure your point in considering Emmett. Geelong have 3 developing young rucks in have Conway (206cm 22 year old taken at pick 24) plus Edwards (206cm 20 year old taken at pick 32) and Pike (203cm 20 year old taken as a rookie from local Geelong). They also have Neale who is a KPF/Ruck at 203cm.

 

[Wooshaaaa]

I would urge them not to think hard about Banfield. If the Bode were to have placed a bid on Charlie at this point in the draft, I would bloody well hope we match it.

Not sure you point in considering Emmett. Geelong 3 developing young rucks in have Conway (206cm 22 year old taken at pick 24) plus Edwards (206cm 20 year old taken at pick 32) and Pike (203cm 20 year old taken as a rookie from local Geelong). They also have Neale who is a KPF/Ruck at 203cm.

Cats just sacked me as list manager!

 

[ArdentEagle]

I feel it needs to be remembered that although this bid was made at pick 20, WCE don’t need to use that pick to match.

In this instance it was pick 29 with 35 sliding back to 46

So the comparison isn’t between Tylah and those players still on the board at pick 20, it’s between him and who is likely to still be available at pick 29

A club has to really like him to throw up a bid this early

I did factor this into my thinking but I do have someone else I want to take that might last until my next pick.

I be think theyre going to be very good.

Also other NGAs I just like better.

Again, I'm just a video watching nuffie, although I think I've got a good eye.

Most recent example of a polarising player was Logan Morris. I was strongly on his camp

 

[RustyShacklefordFalcon]

I wonder which two inside mids Norf will take that they don't need?

 

[Carbine Chaos]

 

[archiemoses]

12 hours is almost up

 

[squashface]

Can’t fathom signing up for a mock draft then not following the thread

 

[Keys]

You snooze you lose.

AsterixTheGaul can jump in whilst we wait for wadistance to log on

 

[txbyhull]

Can’t fathom signing up for a mock draft then not following the thread

Just makes it easier to pick who takes part next time

 

[archiemoses]

Keys can you just do the north picks rather than shuffle them back.