West Coast deserved the 2005 premiership

[Poseidon]

This thread is sadder than my attempts at pleasuring my girlfriend last night.



And by girlfriend I of course mean Mistress Esmeralda on 1800-SEDUCEME

 

[Bombers 2003]

This thread is sadder than my attempts at pleasuring my girlfriend last night.



And by girlfriend I of course mean Mistress Esmeralda on 1800-SEDUCEME

you have a Girl Friend?
is she russian or thai?

 

[royals1922]

Everytime I hear this sheite about the freekick I remind myself about the 2005 Brownlow count when Cousins won with 20 votes and Kerr was second with 19 votes.

Both should have an asterisk against their name. Maybe Nick Dal Santo who came in 3rd with 18 votes should be given the 2005 Brownlow retrospectively as well.

There's a sense of fairness in that.

 

[Sialan]

Everytime I hear this sheite about the freekick I remind myself about the 2005 Brownlow count when Cousins won with 20 votes and Kerr was second with 19 votes.

Both should have an asterisk against their name. Maybe Nick Dal Santo who came in 3rd with 18 votes should be given the 2005 Brownlow retrospectively as well.

There's a sense of fairness in that.

Yeah - nah Royals, you are obviously offended about boomer coming in 20th with WCE having 3 in the top 10.
Besides Dal Santo plays for ST Kilda & has a small dick!
You should have said Westy the perennial bridesmade was the deserving winner, but being a dogs player that would have been too much for you to say without additional offended

 

[royals1922]

Yeah - nah Royals, you are obviously offended about boomer coming in 20th with WCE having 3 in the top 10.
Besides Dal Santo plays for ST Kilda & has a small dick!
You should have said Westy the perennial bridesmade was the deserving winner, but being a dogs player that would have been too much for you to say without additional offended

I don't think that Mr Harvey has mentioned Ketamine in a conversation except when possibly speaking about Kerr.

 

[Sialan]

Perhaps Mr. Kerr had a sick horse in surgery, or he was looking to help Nathan Thompson.
Heresay & malicious gossip Royals.

 

[Murraj1966]

There's a reason West Coast deserve the 2005 Flag, but that's not it...

 

[tesseract]

Sydney deserved the win because they were in front at the final siren.

 

[Sialan]

Sydney deserved the win because they were in front at the final siren.

Quoted for truth.
As much as it hurts you are on the money, no use crying over something that happened 6 years ago.

One of the funniest days I had, watching this with an auntie, she had a meltdown that would have been legendary on the bay. At the end of the game all she could say was "Barry Hall you c**t, you f*****g c**t, you c**t".

 

[Reginald Perrin]

Nice work MrZregory.

Everything in life should be so easy.

 

[Slash136]

Ha ha it's hard to be bitter when your this successful, made 06 so much sweeter

 

[royals1922]

Perhaps Mr. Kerr had a sick horse in surgery, or he was looking to help Nathan Thompson.
Heresay & malicious gossip Royals.

Hardly malicious gossip- google search Daniel Kerr and Ketamine if you wish.

 

[Double the Fist]

All BS aside, I think 1 flag each is about right. Those 2 teams battled is out for a few years with close margins and great contest's with a pretty even spread of wins each.

I have no problem with Sydney winning the 05 Premiership, its history and they did have a good side with a solid game plan.

Deserved it IMO.

As much as this post is not suited to teh bay, I have to agree with it.

 

[KardiniaPark]

As much as this post is not suited to teh bay, I have to agree with it.

Whatever helps you sleep at night. Should have been back to back, I am convinced of that now. A bold * can now go onto Sydney's flag. So now the last flag that isn't asterisked is 1995 I believe, unless someone has a problem with that one too?

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

you have a Girl Friend?
is she russian or thai?

Did you stop reading his post halfway through?

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

So to basically... the AFL changed the concessions rules because the West Coast Eagles were unfairly treated.... whilst the AFL changed the father/son rules because Geelong were unfairly favoured.

Geelong had the same father/son rule as everyone else

 

[Good_Burger]

Sydney deserved it, Not west coast

 

[Alesana]

Sydney deserved it, Not west coast

Pretty sure only the OP is saying they didn't. I think it was unjust, not undeserved. I don't agree with Barry's mark however

 

[Good_Burger]

Pretty sure only the OP is saying they didn't. I think it was unjust, not undeserved. I don't agree with Barry's mark however

Doesn't really matter anyways, You's were the 06 premiers justice was served

 

[Dougy12]

Never knew coaster fans were such f****** ****s.

 

[MrZregory]

Sydney deserved the win because they were in front at the final siren.

No they don't! The umpires won the game for them. They illegally stopped Sampi from taking a matchwinning mark. It's time for the AFL to take action and give us the cup.

 

[MrZregory]

Quoted for truth.
As much as it hurts you are on the money, no use crying over something that happened 6 years ago.

One of the funniest days I had, watching this with an auntie, she had a meltdown that would have been legendary on the bay. At the end of the game all she could say was "Barry Hall you c**t, you f*****g c**t, you c**t".

That's part of my point its been 6 years and yet the AFL haven't done a thing about it. We should take it up to them and force them to reverse the result. Everyone knows we are the true 2005 Premiers it's just Sydney's name is engraved on the cup.

 

[WCErevival]

We should be named the 2003 premiers too after finishing the year as the highest attacking team and belting Brisbane by 70 points at the Gabba.

 

[Reginald Perrin]

Freo should be named 2006 premiers, because they belted west coast in every game they played that year.

 

[Reginald Perrin]

Neither Sydney or west coast deserved to be named premiers in 2005 or 2006 because they played the most boring grand finals in the history of the game.