Game Day West Coast Eagles v Essendon, Finals Week 1 - 18:10 AWST, Sep 05, 2019

[Barrysballs]

Please cite precedent to suggest that those punishments were lenient.

Please cite precedent to suggest that those punishments weren't lenient.

 

[Underdog]

Shouldn't of been overturned no I still would of given him 3 weeks.

But it wasn't mean words said something about ******* his underage daughter no? Unless you condone that sort of behaviour it's a weird one to bring up

I don't condone that behaviour, but they are just words. Sticks and stones and all that...

 

[Underdog]

Please cite precedent to suggest that those punishments weren't lenient.

You're the one arguing against the decision, it's up to you to justify why.

 

[Barrysballs]

I don't condone that behaviour, but they are just words. Sticks and stones and all that...

Wait till you have a family and someone says they would give your 6yr old daughter one and see if they are just words to you! . But like I said I wouldn't of overturned it

 

[Barrysballs]

You're the one arguing against the decision, it's up to you to justify why.

I must of missed that when I read the big footy rules

 

[Toump Ass]

Merrett deserves a fine which should be paid directly to NN. That's the sort of s**t we love seeing in footy.

 

[VicBased]

So basically you have nothing to add, so just make assumptions based on a supporters club of choice.

Gotta tell the truth when i see the obvious.

 

[VicBased]

It’s only West Coast supporters and Essendon despisers. I consider myself an Essendon despiser but that was still a stupid thing to do by Nic Nat. Could have ended very very badly.

Yep, the Boy does not know his own strength.

 

[Barrysballs]

Funnily enough, i do have a 6yo daughter. I absolutely would tell them to fu** off. I wouldn't start taking swings at them.

On SM-G950F using BigFooty.com mobile app

So how do you feel about someone pulling your hair ? surely that would then mean you were justified in giving them a choke slam yeah

 

[Numero Uno]

Wait till you have a family and someone says they would give your 6yr old daughter one and see if they are just words to you! . But like I said I wouldn't of overturned it

freo supporters love their lies

he was having a go at his s**t tat..he never mentioned his daughter or family

 

[Barrysballs]

freo supporters love their lies

he was having a go at his s**t tat..he never mentioned his daughter or family

Wrong, go Google it

 

[nameless]

Please cite precedent to suggest that those punishments weren't lenient.

Barry Hall punched Staker in the head in the most similar offence to Gaff, Hall got 7 weeks. Gaff got 9.
Not lenient.

James Frawley pushed J. Cameron into the fence in a similar manner to Gov. He got a fine. Gov got a week.

Frawley reported for Cameron fence bump

Hawthorn defender James Frawley has a case to answer from this incident with GWS forward Jeremy Cameron

www.afl.com.au

Not lenient.

Naitanui laid this identical tackle on Parfitt, received a free kick for it

Naitanui laid this identical tackle on Nick Smith, received a free kick for it https://www.afl.com.au/video/2018-03-25/nic-nat-goes-whack
Gets a week for Amon tackle.
Not lenient.

 

[Numero Uno]

Wrong, go Google it

yes im fully aware what freo cried about...too bad it was a lie

 

[ep2018]

Only a fine for NN. Thank *

 

[kane249]

Another week of West Coast tools claiming Vic bias when Naitanui inevitably gets rightly suspended for a gutless act

Nic Nat must be looking forward to his week off

Lulz

 

[HTPunter]

NicNat a fine, as it should be

 

[Brer Bear]

Another week of West Coast tools claiming Vic bias when Naitanui inevitably gets rightly suspended for a gutless act

Lol good luck tonight mate.

 

[Barrysballs]

Barry Hall punched Staker in the head in the most similar offence to Gaff, Hall got 7 weeks. Gaff got 9.
Not lenient.

James Frawley pushed J. Cameron into the fence in a similar manner to Gov. He got a fine. Gov got a week.

Frawley reported for Cameron fence bump

Hawthorn defender James Frawley has a case to answer from this incident with GWS forward Jeremy Cameron

www.afl.com.au

Not lenient.

Naitanui laid this identical tackle on Parfitt, received a free kick for it

Naitanui laid this identical tackle on Nick Smith, received a free kick for it https://www.afl.com.au/video/2018-03-25/nic-nat-goes-whack
Gets a week for Amon tackle.
Not lenient.

Staker wasn't injured so if it's outcome based and your using that incident to extrapolate to the gaff king hit should of been 12 weeks easily

Rich got 2

Redirect Notice

www.google.com

Regarding nic mats shocking tackling form he is lucky Amon isn't quadraplegic. Thank God he got the 1 week and has since learnt to tackle properly

 

[kane249]

Wrong, go Google it

Googled it, first hit

Headland sledge the biggest regret of Selwood’s career

Former West Coast midfielder opens up on an infamous moment in derby folklore.

thewest.com.au

The 2006 premiership Eagle, who remains at the club in a game development role, was adamant he didn’t realise at the time the ink on Headland’s arm was of his six-year-old daughter Madisan.

Sewlood only found out who it was a tattoo of after the event.

 

[Barrysballs]

As I posted earlier always guaranteed an eagles player will get the lighter sentencing from Christian. Add to that it's finals and it was always going to be a fine.

This will set a precedent for the next grading of a choke slam

 

[Numero Uno]

Googled it, first hit

Headland sledge the biggest regret of Selwood’s career

Former West Coast midfielder opens up on an infamous moment in derby folklore.

thewest.com.au

Sewlood only found out who it was a tattoo of after the event.

like i said freo luv their little lies

 

[kane249]

As I posted earlier always guaranteed an eagles player will get the lighter sentencing from Christian. Add to that it's finals and it was always going to be a fine.

This will set a precedent for the next grading of a choke slam

You had Ablett (twice), Fyfe and the Bont all escape with fines this year for incidents that should have been suspendable, so put away the tin foil hat and think this only extends to one team.

Merrett gets injured and Naitanui gets a week, Merrett got up and played the rest of the game. That's the long and the short of it.

 

[bh90210fan]

One of my greatest bigfooty pleasures is reading Freo posters sooking over us as we keep marching on, thanks guys

 

[sedders]

As I posted earlier always guaranteed an eagles player will get the lighter sentencing from Christian. Add to that it's finals and it was always going to be a fine.

This will set a precedent for the next grading of a choke slam

lol choke slam you are hilarious

 

[Barrysballs]

Googled it, first hit

Headland sledge the biggest regret of Selwood’s career

Former West Coast midfielder opens up on an infamous moment in derby folklore.

thewest.com.au

Sewlood only found out who it was a tattoo of after the event.

Yeah biggest regret of his career, called a 6yr old a **** even if she wasn't 6 still disgusting anti women behavior I'm more shocked your defending his actions