We've lost someone

[Deaneus!]

If he wants to go, he goes, but what would we expect in return? Could we get their first round pick? Second round pick and a good player? If we're going to lose a great player coming into the prime of his career...

 

[TheLeftFist8]

We wont get pick 4 for Johncock.

Maybe Johncock + Griffen for pick 4

They should throw in another solid player into that equation.

Williams said he was willing to give up pick 4 so let's see it happen

 

[James23]

I have a feeling Thomson will be involved in this trade somehow

 

[dplggr47]

i think the highest Port would offer is their 2nd rounder and Thomson (as a sweetner)...who they don't want anyway... but i am pi$$ed about Johncock's decision.
*EDIT*
mentioned that Crows would most likely want Port's 2nd rounder (but Port would be reluctant)...and that Thomson might be involved...seriously, Johncock is worth higher than that...i hope he doesn't leave.
...what is it with crows players getting disciplined, can't hack it and wanting to leave.

 

[Macca19]

Is he contracted?

I think their pick 4 would be a good place to start if this is true.

Definately.

Maybe we can give you Travis Boak + Kane Cornes for Jericho and your 6th round pick as well while we're at it.

 

[Holden Hillbilly]

Thomson + pick 52 for Johncock since he wants to leave (and Lonie or a set of steak knives)

 

[TheLeftFist8]

erm, you do realise that port were doing the same thing at the same time to stiffys cousin dont ya?

erm...did i say i agreed with what Port did

 

[fryingpan]

Well if he's gonna turn his back on the club, I wont lose sleep over it. He can take his personal problems to Port Adelaide for all I care.

 

[morell]

Crow fans...

you're absolutely dreaming if you think pick 4 will be involved, unless its part of some sort of package deal.

 

[RoosterLad]

you guys forgot the sarcastic smiley.

we have an infinte number of his type, wouldn't think Port would sell the house.

Thomson + pick upgrade perhaps.

There isn't really a sarcastic smiley, there's a which can work or but that can also mean 'being a ****' as well.

Anyway we would want a decent trade, you might not want to offer much but then you might not get him. He could always go in the PSD then, we get nothing, but his career is ended (which would be sad).

 

[Homercles]

i think the highest Port would offer is their 2nd rounder and Thomson (as a sweetner)...who they don't want anyway... but i am pi$$ed about Johncock's decision.

They mentioned both those things on 9, for those of you who aren't/can't watching it.

 

[King Elvis]

i think the highest Port would offer is their 2nd rounder and Thomson (as a sweetner)...who they don't want anyway... but i am pi$$ed about Johncock's decision.

I think that's realistic.

We should be demanding their first round pick.

Or Johncock for Thompson, and a swap of our first/second round picks.

The guy on the news just said we'd be after there second round pick - he must be a ****ing idiot.

Stiffy is worth pick 8-12ish; pick 4 is too much, but he's worth a mid/late first rounder.

 

[morell]

There isn't really a sarcastic smiley, there's a which can work or but that can also mean 'being a ****' as well.

Anyway we would want a decent trade, you might not want to offer much but then you might not get him. He could always go in the PSD then, we get nothing, but his career is ended (which would be sad).

I am sure you and your interweb savvy smrts could have found a way Roostah.

Absolutely Johncock deserves something of merit from Port, but I cannot see us paying overs for someone we don't critically need.

 

[atcocc]

ITS STIFFY the news suggested that they would only get a 2nd rounder for him or thomson. That wont happen i would want at least both of them for the stifmeister

 

[Dogga79]

Definately.

Maybe we can give you Travis Boak + Kane Cornes for Jericho and your 6th round pick as well while we're at it.

You can keep the sarcasm. Surely a first rounder is fair.

 

[King Elvis]

I am sure you and you're interweb savvy smrts could have found a way Roostah.

Sure, Johncock deserves something of merit from Port, but I cannot see us paying overs for someone we don't critically need.

He's proven, he's close to AA level, and he'd give you at least another 4-5 years.

If you could get that out of pick 4, you'd do it in a heart beat.

 

[TheLeftFist8]

Ch9 speculating about a straight Johncock for 2nd rounder...would be spewing. Symes was a 2nd rounder and he is no Johncock.

Thomson also mentioned but value wise he isn't worth much.

Well, unless you are captain of the club don't even think about having any personal problems at all.

 

[Check-Raise !]

Thomson and their first pick.

I might think about that.

Your funny.....

You won't get near pick 4 but maybe Thommo and late pick or as someone else said Thommo and upgrade of your second or third rounder? Probably won't even happen but who knows.

 

[Macca19]

Keep in mind that Johncock to Port seems to come up on a yearly basis.

Not to mention two weeks ago on Channel 10 they said that Thomson has asked for a trade but neither the player, agent, or anyone at the club has said anything about that either.

Was it an actual quote or was it just Bickley/KG saying it?

 

[Power King]

We'll give you Thurstans for him.

+ lonie as a sweetener

 

[Cap]

Thomson + pick 52 for Johncock since he wants to leave (and Lonie or a set of steak knives)

you need to go here

for lessons on what to d when trying to talk about trading

 

[Macca19]

You can keep the sarcasm. Surely a first rounder is fair.

You think pick 4 is fair for a back pocket?

 

[KUNG FU]

Devastated.

He's worth something in the mid to late first round range.

#4 & Thomson for Johncock & #10 is the first trade that comes to my mind.

 

[birdmanptr]

Definately.

Maybe we can give you Travis Boak + Kane Cornes for Jericho and your 6th round pick as well while we're at it.

Boak yes Cornes no thanks

I would say this is going to end bad for us cause we dont know how to trade yet history shows that But if it was me pick 4 or no deal

 

[morell]

He's proven, he's close to AA level

and was dropped from an average side not a few weeks ago.

Also has numerous off field indescrestions.

Nowhere near worth a first round pick. As I said, Thomson and a pick upgrade is around the mark IMO.