Competition "What If" Wednesdays - Time Traveller Sneezes Edition: List Development - COMPLETED

[BigChippa52]

dees stayed as the invincible whites?

 

[cannavo]

Got another one for you: What if Collingwood entered the SANFL in 1997 instead of Port in the AFL.

Great minds, that was my first idea when I brainstormed and it's first on my list albeit not worded exactly

dees stayed as the fushicas?

Added

dees stayed as the invincible whites?

This'll be interesting, Added

 

[terrybull]

What if Port Melbourne and Williamstown were invited to the VFL instead of Carlton and St.Kilda? How would that changed the course of history?

1908 - University and Carlton join VFL.

1925 - Richmond, Footscray and Hawthorn(?) join VFL

1987 - West Coast colours?

And would North Melbourne dominate the VFA? And St.Kilda, would they be more successful in the VFA?

How long would Port Melbourne be the Boroughs before the name being outdated in the VFL/AFL comp?

 

[BigChippa52]

mount gambier join the sanfl

 

[BigChippa52]

woodville and west torrens never merged

 

[BigChippa52]

limestone coast sanfl team

 

[cannavo]

What if Port Melbourne and Williamstown were invited to the VFL instead of Carlton and St.Kilda? How would that changed the course of history? -

1908 - University and Carlton join VFL.

1925 - Richmond, Footscray and Hawthorn(?) join VFL

1987 - West Coast colours?

And would North Melbourne dominate the VFA? And St.Kilda, would they be more successful in the VFA?

How long would Port Melbourne be the Boroughs before the name being outdated in the VFL/AFL comp?

A very interesting idea, I think this all would be more suited for a portfolio than a 1 time competition due to the domino effects and amount of kits to create eg. The VFL entrants, West Coast might have ended up with a different colour scheme etc. And for designing kits for the added teams, it would most likely be the same as their current kits at those times. Definitely look into making a portfolio to envision this timeline! The only part of this that would be great for a week long competition to design on would be West Coasts changed colours due to Williamstown being in the VFL, happy to add that one in if you like

mount gambier join the sanfl

limestone coast sanfl team

Could be the start of a new rivalry, added

woodville and west torrens never merged

Sounds good though the creativity would be limited for me because most SANFL teams around the era before the 2 merged stuck with their 70's or 80's kits ever since or had a very slight change eg. Glenelg, West Adelaide, Sturt, North Adelaide (albeit reverted to their 70's kit) etc.

 

[cannavo]

Thanks again to all who have contributed to the list
Please choose 1 of the community added ideas from the poll and the most voted one will kick off Week 1

For those who missed out on throwing in their ideas, if you happen to win one of the competitions, like usual you can choose an idea from the list to be done for the following week OR you can put forward your own idea that isn't listed (Can only be done once) or you can slide into the DM's of a winner and ask kindly for them to put your idea forward

 

[cannavo]

PNG were making quite the comeback from being 5 votes down to get within 1
The inaugural week belongs to 'Gold Coast - Southport Sharks merger'!

Comp thread up soon