Opinion What Team has the best midfield?

[tim_saints]

Geelong- Ablett, Bartel, Corey, Ling, Selwood, Ottens
St Kilda- Hayes, Dal Santo, Montagna, Jones, Gardiner
Collingwood- Swan, Didak, Pendlebury, O'Bree, Fraser
Bulldogs- Cooney, Boyd, Cross, Griffen, Hudson
Carlton- Judd, Murphy, Stevens, Gibbs, Kruezer
Hawthorn- Mitchell, Hodge, Lewis, Bateman, Campbell

That's myne in order.

 

[AG]

You forgot Sewell.

 

[StringyDog]

i'd say Carlton has the best midfield by some stretch.

Gibbs, Judd, Murphy, Scotland, Carrazo, Houlihan, Simpson, Stevens, Simpson, Walker

on top of that you have kreuzer who is as good as another midfielder.

that being said its rather dissappointing when you consider the circumstances in which some of those players were obtained but that is irrelevant to the thread.

From the 9 you have named;

3 stars Gibbs, Judd, Murphy
2 good with deficiencies Simpson Walker
3 turnover kings Carrazzo, Houlihan, Scotland
1 fatty Stevens

Compared to Geelong

4 stars Ablett, Bartel, Selwood, Chapman
4 very good underated players Ling, Corey, Enright, Kelly
1 rising star Hogan

There is certainly one that has the best midfield by some stretch, but it's not the one you named.

 

[George Washington]

Same goes for my comment, would have to object to the avatar change Aussie Gun.

I still think your midfield was exposed against Essendon, and I think we will see that happen again. Its a great time for you to bump this, but I foresee me bumping this in a couple of weeks time. It is possible for your top tier to carry your midfield and hide the other players. Of late Murphy, Gibbs, Judd have been playing extremely well, but eventually they will have an off patch and your lack of depth will be exposed.

Buuuuuuuuuuuummmmmmpppppp.

 

[100action]

From the 9 you have named;

3 stars Gibbs, Judd, Murphy
2 good with deficiencies Simpson Walker
3 turnover kings Carrazzo, Houlihan, Scotland
1 fatty Stevens

Compared to Geelong

4 stars Ablett, Bartel, Selwood, Chapman
4 very good underated players Ling, Corey, Enright, Kelly
1 rising star Hogan

There is certainly one that has the best midfield by some stretch, but it's not the one you named.

meh i think im too use to stevens, carrazo and scotland annihilating us.

 

[George Washington]

No Murphy, No Judd. No Carlton.

 

[Hawka08]

Hawthorn

Hodge,Sewell,Mitchell top 5 atleast

 

[Denty]

Geelong with the Blues looming!