What was Thornton Worth?

[len_jet]

He wasn't worth no 1 in that draft obviously judd is the better player. How come nobody ever bags the saints over not picking him?

At least hodge plays and has achieved some success in his career. Has been aa won a best and fairest and is generally considered one of the better players in the leauge. So we got the 2nd best player in that draft.

What the **** has luke livingston done? No 4 you say.

have you gone to the richmond board and posed the same question about fiora? maybe to the doggies and asked them about walsh? how about freo and polak? but how about I ask you about the following:

Luke Brennan - pick 8 2002? I think in the end livingston has played a few more games than brennan...

 

[len_jet]

Lots of pressure on carlton to pick the right guy this year. You got the best one last year but lots of players are touted as good enough to be no 1 this year. Pick the wrong guy and you will be copping **** the same way we do.

no you see the difference this year is the top say 4 play in different positions:

gibbs - midfielder
luenburger - ruck
gumbleton - KPP (forward i think)
hansen - KPP (backman i think i may have them around the wrong way)

the year that you ****ed and up a cop a lot of **** for the top three were all the same players... midfield players... too bad ey!

 

[SA HAWK]

have you gone to the richmond board and posed the same question about fiora? maybe to the doggies and asked them about walsh? how about freo and polak? but how about I ask you about the following:

Luke Brennan - pick 8 2002? I think in the end livingston has played a few more games than brennan...

Yep brennan is **** i ain't gonna defend him.

If carlton supporters are gonna give dawson a player who came off the rookie list **** then expect some back for your players.I still think dawson can be a valuable player for us just not at full back. If we wasted pick 4 on dawson i wouldn't defend him.

As for the other players you mentioned yep they were draft **** ups too. Especially fiora. Ouch.

Anyway my post was a reply directly to budgie or parrot or whatever that ****ers name is.

 

[SA HAWK]

no you see the difference this year is the top say 4 play in different positions:

gibbs - midfielder
luenburger - ruck
gumbleton - KPP (forward i think)
hansen - KPP (backman i think i may have them around the wrong way)

the year that you ****ed and up a cop a lot of **** for the top three were all the same players... midfield players... too bad ey!

So if you pick gibbs and he only has an average career and gumbleton is the next jon brown you think people won't give you **** about it. Dream on pal.

 

[parrot]

Gee they're still going. I'm predicting it'll take a few more weeks for Hawks supporters to get over missing out on Thornton. The prospect of a solution to a problem area being taken away from them cut deep. The Hawks were repeatedly told that we weren't going to trade him. Could not have been clearer. Should have listened. Time to move on guys

 

[unstable punt]

he's only worth 33

 

[lethalselbow]

Gee they're still going. I'm predicting it'll take a few more weeks for Hawks supporters to get over missing out on Thornton. The prospect of a solution to a problem area being taken away from them cut deep. The Hawks were repeatedly told that we weren't going to trade him. Could not have been clearer. Should have listened. Time to move on guys

You keep repeating yourself. That why they call you parrot?

 

[parrot]

Well the news just gets better for the Hawks defense. Welcome the new Hawthorn defensive coach: Danny Frawley. Huge laughs.