Whats up with Maxie this year.

[mantraray]

Seems like he sits at the right hand of God.

But then again I would like to know what actually happened as it seems that you and a few others are running shotgun for him.

He is the worst Captain in the league and certainly the worst the Swans have had.
t)

 

[JennyJ]

If he was there why was he there?

But the original post said what was wrong with him and all of a sudden we were all over the place.

He is not the player he was and not that he was that good but he could at least kick straight, he cant even do that now and his accuracy is poor. Swans are a better than good side and probably have a great chance to play in the finals but I wish Goodes was leading them.

Now Matt get back to your job!!

 

[bricon]

Those who have insisted that Charlie name Swans players who think Maxfield is a good captain may like to get a copy of today’s (Sydney) Sunday Telegraph newspaper. The main feature article in the center of the sports section (pages 68-69) is a very long background piece on Maxfield called “The Max factor”.

Here are a couple of quotes from players:

From Barry Hall:

He's one of the best captains I've had

From Jared Crouch:

Stuey's just inspirational on the field ..... he's really stepped up and has been sensational.

The example he sets is second to none.

He's also very serious about his work and if you can pull a smile out of him during training you are doing well.

I'm sure that Charlie G will graciously accept all apologies.

 

[windbag]

Strange but true.

But is it true that Paul Williams is now the official mouthpiece for the side with the press, which suggest that Maxfield lacks a lot of skill in this area.

Its called spin Bricon and planted by the club. There is a question mark about it. The timing of the article suggest that there is concern around the club about Maxfield.

Every time Maxfield comes under pressure an article about his ethics and likeability appears with boring regularity.

I may be wrong on this but the questions being raised asked why he was a leader of MEN, not what individual players thought.

CharlieG does not warrant anything but an anger management coach. Said in a caring manner

 

[robbieando]

Really you ask us for proof yet I haven't seen you give any proof except for some moron's crap on some site that no one posts on anymore.

If he is such a bad captain and the players don't like him why not give us some proof

Windbag, JennyJ and Tully - PUT UP OR SHUT UP

 

[bricon]

Maxfield answered for himself today!

 

[mantraray]

Originally posted by bricon
Maxfield answered for himself today!

I was working so only caught glimpses but he seemed to me to be trying too hard again.

Was he amongst the best players.

Did he answer on camera or is he still frightened of them?

 

[CharlieG]

I was working so only caught glimpses but he seemed to me to be trying too hard again.

You're hard to please!!!

 

[mantraray]

Originally posted by CharlieG
You're hard to please!!!

For once in your life Charlie answer the question. Was he one of the best. The times he did appear on screen he was running into the backs of Geelong players.

If you read the papers all over Aus you will see that Williams is getting the hype that a Captain normally gets and he looks the goods not the goose!!!!

 

[CharlieG]

Windbag
Mantraray

It seems to me that both of these recent arrivals are busying themselves primarily with Maxfield... and now both have stated that there are heaps of Willo articles across the newspapers... I'm starting to get suspicious.

Now as for the question... I don't see why I should answer, you "two" have been attacking me incessantly, but expect me to be reasonable? But if it will get you off my back for once, yes, I thought he was in the best 4 or 5. That's only my opinion... and others are liable to disagree...

 

[mantraray]

Originally posted by CharlieG
Windbag
Mantraray

It seems to me that both of these recent arrivals are busying themselves primarily with Maxfield... and now both have stated that there are heaps of Willo articles across the newspapers... I'm starting to get suspicious.

Now as for the question... I don't see why I should answer, you "two" have been attacking me incessantly, but expect me to be reasonable? But if it will get you off my back for once, yes, I thought he was in the best 4 or 5. That's only my opinion... and others are liable to disagree...

Dont be paranoid Charlie and I think the scribes disagree with you.

 

[robbieando]

So please link the Williams articles for this week, because I surely haven't seen them. More articles on Roberts-Thompson than Williams and also Goodes and Kennelly got a write up more than Willo.

Again put up or shut up. You haven't given us proof yet

 

[CharlieG]

I'll ask you the same thing I asked "Windbag". Can you provide links to these articles? "Put up or shut up."

 

[mantraray]

Originally posted by CharlieG
I'll ask you the same thing I asked "Windbag". Can you provide links to these articles? "Put up or shut up."

Suggest you try Murdoch press in all states! I will discuss links with a guy in IT who can help me.

Now CharlieG what I want know is what was Stu Maxfield doing in a certain spot in Perth the night before the Swans/WCE match in 2002.\\

He may have been in a restaurant or a McDonalds but what was he up to. Someone on these boards must know and I think you do. Maybe he was getting stuck into a meal of french fries

Theres a sting in the tail!!!

 

[robbieando]

Originally posted by mantraray
Now CharlieG what I want know is what was Stu Maxfield doing in a certain spot in Perth the night before the Swans/WCE match in 2002.\\

He may have been in a restaurant or a McDonalds but what was he up to. Someone on these boards must know and I think you do. Maybe he was getting stuck into a meal of french fries

Theres a sting in the tail!!!

This is what the moron on SwansTalk has been talking about. As was said before he won't say what happen. You seem to know more about it than we do. Again put up or shut up

 

[mantraray]

Originally posted by robbieando
This is what the moron on SwansTalk has been talking about. As was said before he won't say what happen. You seem to know more about it than we do. Again put up or shut up

Trouble is Robbieando I dont have a clue but someone on these boards does and if it is minor then put it out for us to see. Maybe he had a McDonalds big Mac.

 

[CharlieG]

Originally posted by mantraray
Suggest you try Murdoch press in all states! I will discuss links with a guy in IT who can help me.

Now CharlieG what I want know is what was Stu Maxfield doing in a certain spot in Perth the night before the Swans/WCE match in 2002.\\

He may have been in a restaurant or a McDonalds but what was he up to. Someone on these boards must know and I think you do. Maybe he was getting stuck into a meal of french fries

Theres a sting in the tail!!!

It's easy enough. Copy and paste the address, then post it. Make sure the "automatically parse URLs" thing is ticked.

 

[robbieando]

Originally posted by mantraray
Trouble is Robbieando I dont have a clue but someone on these boards does and if it is minor then put it out for us to see. Maybe he had a McDonalds big Mac.

The person who is posting on Swans Talk got banned from here a few weeks back. Other than him I don't think anyone other than you know's anything about it.

 

[mantraray]

Originally posted by robbieando
The person who is posting on Swans Talk got banned from here a few weeks back. Other than him I don't think anyone other than you know's anything about it.

Only what I have read on the Boards but I dont think Maxfield would be thanking you for your hysterics.

 

[robbieando]

So why not quote what you have read on here and post links as well because until this thread I have seen nothing posted about it, only what has come up on SwansTalk

 

[Syd]

Originally posted by mantraray
Trouble is Robbieando I dont have a clue

I think he's got it in one!

 

[JennyJ]

Are but we have been doing our homework and the businesses in that area will be named and then we 'll put it to a vote where he is likely to have been.

And Charlie/Robbieando I dont think you are going to be popular boys...

We should have the list of all establishments by Friday at the latest.


Mock Shock and Horror.

 

[Bomber Spirit]

Originally posted by mantraray
Now ... what I want know is what was Stu Maxfield doing in a certain spot in Perth the night before the Swans/WCE match in 2002.\

I had a look at Swans Talk - and MtS's theory is entirely credible.

If anything untoward did happen in a Perth nightclub, you'll need to be more specific. And don't tell us, make a detailed statement to the WA Police, get them to lay charges and testify under oath in court.

 

[robbieando]

Originally posted by JennyJ
Are but we have been doing our homework and the businesses in that area will be named and then we 'll put it to a vote where he is likely to have been.

And Charlie/Robbieando I dont think you are going to be popular boys...

We should have the list of all establishments by Friday at the latest.


Mock Shock and Horror.

I thought you were banned Mark?????

I don't care what you saw, nothing is going to happen. As I said before why wait the best part of a year to make public this crap - I know it most likely took you that long to think it up. Go I dare you take it to the police.

If you witnessed the incident, why can't you get the names of where it happened??? Oh your going to look up citysearch on Friday aren't you

Pity no one believes you except usernames made up by yourself.

 

[mantraray]

From muy understanding it isnt that type of offence but nice try. Only offensive and not good form.