Well you didn't 'go wrong' and the fact I disagree with you isn't criticism as you know more than me.I don’t mind people disagreeing, just curious where I went wrong. Constructive criticism always welcome.
But here goes from my perspective.
As an intellectual exercise I am always torn with whether you can separate the player from the man, and can see good arguments for and against doing so. Generally I am not a huge fan of cancel culture and deplatforming. But when it comes to thumping your wife, I can't have the Wiz on the best player list.
On McPharlin, the guy never finished higher than third in the Doig, and he got one AA. I know awards aren't everything but i just can't have him at the Sandi level even though he was an incredible player.
And to top if off, both of them were two club players.
Neither will ever be in tier one for me but that's only because tier one is rarefied air indeed. They're both still outstanding players.