Which backiline is better?

[AjsGuns]

Morris > Toovey
Lake > Presti
Hargrave > Goldsack
Shaw > Harbrow
Obrien > Williams
Gilbee > Maxwell
On player skill although collingwoods defence as a whole plays very, very well together
to hard to split for me, null vote.

 

[Dazb86]

Gilbee>Maxwell :O I don't think so. At least not purely defensively.

If anything Gilbees name should be up with Shaw and they'd break about even. Both players get a defensive forward trying to tag them out of the game.

In terms of being a good defensive unit collectively I'd say the pies might just have the better of the two teams. With regards to rebounding into attack the dogs might have a better group equipped for this.

The big question mark is Williams. If he lives up to the hype and stays out on the park it will take our backline to a new level.