Which Cloke

[_RT_]

Jason and Cameron were delisted by the Pies today and if your club was to draft 1 of them in the PSD which 1 would you prefer they went for.

 

[Zeke]

Cameron.

 

[johnnyhoward]

Cameron.

Very cryptic Zeke...is that assuming you want a club to pick up the worst brother?

Cameron has more potential, but Jason was OK at times this season.

 

[duckboy]

Cameron. At least we already know Jason is a dud. At least there'd be some mystery for a while about Cameron..

 

[Grimmett]

Neither.

 

[Coin_Toss]

I might well have kept Cameron. He always appeared like a handy 'bash and crash' type footballer, on the eye.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Cameron is the biggest dud in the AFL.

Seriously, A talentless HACK!

Jason at least has a go.

 

[lethalselbow]

I thought C. Cloke was going to be a star after seeing his fat arse nudge aside blokes in the VFL.

I APOLOGISE. HE'S A HACK.

He's better than J. Cloke, though. But really, what does that say.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Jason at least has a crack and is serviceable, Cameron has zero ability at all, would prefer to stick needles in my eyes then have either of them, but gun to head, i would take Jason

 

[Bombers 2003]

Cameron seems to be more popular then Jason

 

[lethalselbow]

Funny how Richmond fans are starting to defend J.Cloke already. Me thinks he may be heading their way.

Dumping Kellaway and getting J. Cloke instead

 

[Aristotel]

Travis thanks......oops, I mean...um, Cameron.

 

[Talented Player]

Neither.

I'm with you

 

[Richo83]

Funny how Richmond fans are starting to defend J.Cloke already. Me thinks he may be heading their way.

Dumping Kellaway and getting J. Cloke instead

Jason's a hack. I remember when Malthouse said that he might as well have not played or something in that 2003 grand final, I laughed but it was so true.

Rather Cameron, younger at least he has a chance to turn it around, Jason is long gone.

I can't believe you bought the whole set Collingwood, David must be a really good salesman, or your footballing department must be really gullible or both.

 

[borgy]

there should be another option...... none

 

[thebigboy]

there should be another option...... none

Agreed, however i voted jason....but they are both just as bad.

 

[_RT_]

I thought about putting the obvious none option but then no-one would have voted for either of them. At least this way you get an idea of who is rated the better by not including it. Surprising that Cam was in front when most believe that Jason was the better talented of the 2.

 

[The Majestic]

Jason's a hack. I remember when Malthouse said that he might as well have not played or something in that 2003 grand final, I laughed but it was so true.

I think the quote was "Jason played better in last years grand final" after the 2003 one.

I can't believe you bought the whole set Collingwood, David must be a really good salesman, or your footballing department must be really gullible or both.

We took a punt, in 2002 Jason wasn't that bad for the club, he just couldn't continue on, and has lead to this. He started to come back a little this year, but wasn't really going to go far with the club.

I hope he can catch on to another club and get back to some good footy, but he and Cameron look VFL bound for life it seems.