Which footballer do you feel is underrated because they played for an unsuccessful team?

Remove this Banner Ad

Damon_3388

Premium Platinum
Jun 23, 2008
33,485
27,142
Headed for Kirribilli House
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Norwood, Everton, Detroit Red Wings
Adelaide tried him permanently in the guts and he ended up in the reserves. Now Nicks has come up with the genius idea of putting him back to a black flank. Think the question on should he be a permanent midfielder has now finally been answered.
He was perfectly adequate in the guts in his first year in Adelaide, and during his final season at Carlton. Played some of his best footy, in fact.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Damon_3388

Premium Platinum
Jun 23, 2008
33,485
27,142
Headed for Kirribilli House
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Norwood, Everton, Detroit Red Wings
Adequate. That sounds awesome.
"Adequate" understates it.

From 2014-2018, which is supposed to be (for most players) and turned out to be Gibbs' prime (ages 25-29), he averaged:

25.54 disposals (40.36% contested, 1.39 kick-to-handball ratio, 67.72% disposal efficiency, 14.34 turnover rate)
5.12 clearances
4.06 inside 50s
0.71 goals per game
5.34 tackles
81.80% gametime over 98 games
0.44 Brownlow votes per game (43 votes from just 34 wins)

Those are quality numbers and a fine output, inside and all-round. Most players would be pushing for AA selection year in, year out with that level of performance.

The only reason Gibbs' output gets discounted and dismissed and doomed to irrelevancy is because he's a former #1 pick, and he doesn't look "hard" (and got given the "soft" "Bryce Squibs" tag early on), and he didn't play a final during that run. His prime unfortunately also coincided with a lot of injuries and wobbly form to teammates (namely Matthew Kreuzer and Marc Murphy, along with others once he got to the Crows), along with Chris Judd's retirement, so he never saw the team success that was probably expected at some stage either.

At his best (which he's passed now, much sooner than expected, unless he has a big bounce-back in 2020), Gibbs was a very good all-round footballer as a full-time mid.
 

Damon_3388

Premium Platinum
Jun 23, 2008
33,485
27,142
Headed for Kirribilli House
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Norwood, Everton, Detroit Red Wings

captain cotch 9

Brownlow Medallist
Dec 5, 2012
12,217
32,408
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Knicks, Giants
Non Victorian players are always underrated inside vic
Mundy is a star
Gray at Port
Martin at the Lions
Lloyd at the Swans
Tahlia at the crows
Davis at GWS
Hurn at WCE
If these guys played in Vic they would be talked about being top 10-15 players imo.
Vic players can also be overrated due to pumping teams up becuase they create more media ala Marc Murphy
 

Seeds

Hall of Famer
Sep 15, 2007
38,143
34,202
I don't know
AFL Club
Geelong
Non Victorian players are always underrated inside vic
Mundy is a star
Gray at Port
Martin at the Lions
Lloyd at the Swans
Tahlia at the crows
Davis at GWS
Hurn at WCE
If these guys played in Vic they would be talked about being top 10-15 players imo.
Vic players can also be overrated due to pumping teams up becuase they create more media ala Marc Murphy
What a load of rubbish, mundy and hurn and lloyd and brisbanes martin as top 15 players in the comp. are you off your rocker?

Victoria or no victoria has zero influence on average how players are rated overall. Sh** judd was rated better at west coast even though his stats are far superior at carlton.
 

Seeds

Hall of Famer
Sep 15, 2007
38,143
34,202
I don't know
AFL Club
Geelong
"Adequate" understates it.

From 2014-2018, which is supposed to be (for most players) and turned out to be Gibbs' prime (ages 25-29), he averaged:

25.54 disposals (40.36% contested, 1.39 kick-to-handball ratio, 67.72% disposal efficiency, 14.34 turnover rate)
5.12 clearances
4.06 inside 50s
0.71 goals per game
5.34 tackles
81.80% gametime over 98 games
0.44 Brownlow votes per game (43 votes from just 34 wins)

Those are quality numbers and a fine output, inside and all-round. Most players would be pushing for AA selection year in, year out with that level of performance.

The only reason Gibbs' output gets discounted and dismissed and doomed to irrelevancy is because he's a former #1 pick, and he doesn't look "hard" (and got given the "soft" "Bryce Squibs" tag early on), and he didn't play a final during that run. His prime unfortunately also coincided with a lot of injuries and wobbly form to teammates (namely Matthew Kreuzer and Marc Murphy, along with others once he got to the Crows), along with Chris Judd's retirement, so he never saw the team success that was probably expected at some stage either.

At his best (which he's passed now, much sooner than expected, unless he has a big bounce-back in 2020), Gibbs was a very good all-round footballer as a full-time mid.
A lot of those games were played on a back flank.
 

D23D

Club Legend
Apr 27, 2008
1,896
4,404
Brisbane
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Would that be the Farmer who is in the:

- West Perth team of the century
- East Perth team of the century
- Geelong team of the century
- VFL/AFL team of the century
I agree, Polly changed the game.
Also, you forgot:
WA team of the century and
Indigenous team of the century as captain
 

adammania9

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 18, 2013
10,775
22,319
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
University
Non Victorian players are always underrated inside vic
Mundy is a star
Gray at Port
Martin at the Lions
Lloyd at the Swans
Tahlia at the crows
Davis at GWS
Hurn at WCE
If these guys played in Vic they would be talked about being top 10-15 players imo.
Vic players can also be overrated due to pumping teams up becuase they create more media ala Marc Murphy
If anything, I reckon many players become overrated based on the notion that they don't play in Victoria. In my time, I've noticed that interstate players are able to avoid scrutiny for flaws, inconsistency etc. because they're not under the spotlight as much as Vic players are.

People often confuse media hype with the general consensus of football fans. Just because a handful of powerful folks in the media like to pump up marketable players, it does not make them overrated.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Remove this Banner Ad