Which is Richmonds biggest draft blunder?

[Cynic]

Chrus J- (guess what word comes next)

Jidd?

 

[Philhawk]

Jidd?

No, silly.

Jugg. Chrus Jugg.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

F-U, eff you.

 

[Bombers 2003]

Why wasnt the question just what was Richmond's biggest Blunder?

 

[andypie]

fiora definately, but unfortunately the pies blunder was just as big swapping that pick for what ended up being danny roach.

 

[Broady Poker Tour]

You forgot Anthony Banik who was a number one draft pick and didn't play a game.

Out of the options given, clearly Fiora ahead of Pavlich was a F-up

 

[Croat tiger]

You forgot Anthony Banik who was a number one draft pick and didn't play a game.

Out of the options given, clearly Fiora ahead of Pavlich was a F-up

I think you need to do more research before you make stupid comments like that.

http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/players/A/Anthony_Banik.html

 

[grantyc77]

A good read, Aaron Fiora over Matthew Pavlich, is huge, and its pretty funny.

 

[W. Smithers]

Option 1 - Aaron Fiora over Matthew Pavlich. It was the beginning of the draft problems and they have just gotten increasingly worse since then. Interesting to see Fiora improve once he left Richmond...

We'd made plenty of draft blunders before this one.

 

[one_twelve112]

The Tambling debacle still makes me laugh......

 

[metallicamatty]

Who's Fiona?

 

[Croat tiger]

Who's Fiona?

Fiora.

 

[rumblah]

So so so so many to choose from. They really have developed a culure of horrible decisions whether that be drafting players or selecting coaches.

Option 1 - Aaron Fiora over Matthew Pavlich. It was the beginning of the draft problems and they have just gotten increasingly worse since then. Interesting to see Fiora improve once he left Richmond...

Option 2 - Tambling over Franklin. Both duds but for now Tambling is the bigger dud. Should be delisted in 1-2 years time

Option 3 - Adam Pattison over another human being. Quite simply the worst young talent playing the game atm next to Josh Kennedy. Woefully bad.

Option 4 - Jarrod Oakley Nichollls over Mitch Clark. Big mistake already it seems. Clark looks like once hes injury free he will be a gun. Nicholls looks like he will be delisted at years end

Option 5 - Jack Riewoldt over Mitch Brown - IMO it will end up there biggest draft blunder. Mitch Brown is the next big thing at CHF whereas Riewoldt looks unlikely to ever crack a AFL game.

yes Franklin sure is a dud huh?

And way to rate a player from your own team

 

[Benno_900]

Option 1 - Aaron Fiora over Matthew Pavlich. It was the beginning of the draft problems and they have just gotten increasingly worse since then. Interesting to see Fiora improve once he left Richmond...

Isn't it Simmonds over Pavlich now because of the trade? Pavlich is still better anyway.

Too early to say for the rest

 

[DeeKayLillee]

yes Franklin sure is a dud huh?

And way to rate a player from your own team

franklin is a gun
F-U is obviously disturbed if he thinks otherwise.........

unfortunately for you Richmond fans Tambling has a long way to go judging by his lack of body size development in 2 years - BUT lets settle down and hold judgement on the kid at the end of 2008 (he deserves that - I mean look at the development of Luke Hodge compared to Judd and Ball)

 

[don vito of fitzroy]

There isn't an all of the above option.