Which Player......

Remove this Banner Ad

AFDogs

Premiership Player
Sep 9, 2014
4,496
5,612
AFL Club
Western Bulldogs
Unproven/inconsistent key forwards seem to have their career best games against us...

Carlisle kicked 8 against us once. Hipwood kicked 5. Charlie Curnow 6.
 

Instincts

Senior List
Sep 21, 2020
204
307
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Unproven/inconsistent key forwards seem to have their career best games against us...

Carlisle kicked 8 against us once. Hipwood kicked 5. Charlie Curnow 6.
Daw kicked 6 or 7 on your team as well I believe
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Ron The Bear

Come on Sydney, come on!
Jul 4, 2006
33,865
33,812
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Highest average coaches' votes 2004-current, min. 10 games

Avg
PlayerOppVotesGms
5.40​
Fyfe, NatN.M.8115
5.19​
Martin, DustinBris8316
4.92​
Selwood, JoelG.C.5912
4.80​
Sewell, BradMelb4810
4.75​
Fyfe, NatP.A.5712
4.71​
Martin, DustinGWS6614
4.60​
Ablett junior, GaryGWS4610
4.40​
Kennedy, Josh P.St.K6615
4.40​
Macrae, JackBris4410
4.40​
Bontempelli, MarcusN.M.4410
4.33​
Boak, TravisG.C.5212
4.30​
Rance, AlexGWS4310
4.23​
Dangerfield, PatrickG.C.5513
4.20​
Neale, LachieCarl4210
4.18​
Selwood, JoelMelb7117
4.09​
Hanley, PearceG.C.4511
4.07​
Pendlebury, ScottEss11027
4.06​
Pendlebury, ScottN.M.6516
4.06​
Dangerfield, PatrickFrem6917
4.00​
Martin, DustinEss7218
4.00​
Shuey, LukeG.C.4010
 

Tarkyn_24

Hall of Famer
Dec 23, 2006
39,424
46,163
AFL Club
Collingwood
Harry O'Brien always seemed to play well against us back in the day.

Paul Haselby almost lived for Western Derbies, I think he's won the Glendenning(-Allen) medal more than any other player which just backs up my point.

These days it seems to be the whole Brisbane Lions team
Alan Toovey used to routinely make Darling his b*tch whenever we met too for a while
 

Tarkyn_24

Hall of Famer
Dec 23, 2006
39,424
46,163
AFL Club
Collingwood
Highest average coaches' votes 2004-current, min. 10 games

Avg
PlayerOppVotesGms
5.40​
Fyfe, NatN.M.8115
5.19​
Martin, DustinBris8316
4.92​
Selwood, JoelG.C.5912
4.80​
Sewell, BradMelb4810
4.75​
Fyfe, NatP.A.5712
4.71​
Martin, DustinGWS6614
4.60​
Ablett junior, GaryGWS4610
4.40​
Kennedy, Josh P.St.K6615
4.40​
Macrae, JackBris4410
4.40​
Bontempelli, MarcusN.M.4410
4.33​
Boak, TravisG.C.5212
4.30​
Rance, AlexGWS4310
4.23​
Dangerfield, PatrickG.C.5513
4.20​
Neale, LachieCarl4210
4.18​
Selwood, JoelMelb7117
4.09​
Hanley, PearceG.C.4511
4.07​
Pendlebury, ScottEss11027
4.06​
Pendlebury, ScottN.M.6516
4.06​
Dangerfield, PatrickFrem6917
4.00​
Martin, DustinEss7218
4.00​
Shuey, LukeG.C.4010
Ron The Bear do you have a full collation of game by game coaches votes that far back? Very intrigued as I was never able to really find much in the 2000’s other than a leaderboard
 
Aug 24, 2017
10,096
42,678
AFL Club
Richmond
Mundy’s nailed the match winner against us twice.

A lot of Carlton players used to sh*t me back around 2008-12. Gibbs, Murphy, Ed Curnow, Jeff Garlett to name a few
Was gonna say the same about Mundy
Absolute iceman against us
 

PorcelainBus

Senior List
Oct 21, 2003
284
758
Perth
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Freo, swan districts
for port we had a run where "spuds will tear us apart again"

probably a sad reflection on where we were at
You should record a version of this - I'm sure you could come up with good lyrics and a suitable video

When the midfield is soft and ambitions are low
And resentment is spread and our youngster's don't grow
And we're changing our plan, trying different things

Then Spud's, Spud's will tear us apart again
Spud's, Spud's will tear us apart again
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

kid_a

Club Legend
Apr 5, 2010
2,293
1,127
Perf
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Hammarby IF, East Freo, Glory
Alan Toovey used to routinely make Darling his b*tch whenever we met too for a while
haha true, forgot about that bloke
 

Remove this Banner Ad