- Mar 27, 2018
- 7,220
- 18,886
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Cleveland Browns, Tony Ferguson
De Goey
Papley
Ben King
Whitfield
Heeney
Bont
Zurhaar
Rayner
Fritsch
McKay
Papley
Ben King
Whitfield
Heeney
Bont
Zurhaar
Rayner
Fritsch
McKay
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Stack for mine... does every part of tge game better than Sam walsh... didnt pickett get a norm smith vote?Cripps (3 kg lighter)
Docherty (my supercoach side will be greatful)
Walsh (AA in his second year?)
that’s enough of my time (I could easily name 6-7 more but I’ll leave it alone)
LDU (3rd year and should be ready to take on a substantial midfield role)
Kelly (How will he cope with the tag and the travel)
Ellis (Is it Richmond game plan or is it the individuals - I think Ellis will be irrelevant at GC)
Pickett (can he keep a spot - was it a one 2m blind turn)
Neale (How will he go with a permanent tag)
Rowell (can he have the same impact as Walsh)
Rozee (is the hype still there)
Buddy (can he get through his contract - can he play a full season)
Stephenson (will he ever return to the pre gambling condition or does he need that extra motivation)
Every part of the game? You’re kidding yourself.Stack for mine... does every part of tge game better than Sam walsh... didnt pickett get a norm smith vote?
Must have done more than a blind turn!
Every part of the game? You’re kidding yourself.
Lol. So does everyone else but you does then I reckon. Walsh is the best first year player since Judd. Some people even think he’s tracking better. He was top 3 (IN THE ENTIRE AFL) for distance covered. He was running 16 km a game. Wait till 2020 he will be number one off a full preseason. Don’t reply anymore you’re making a fool of yourself.No.. stack is a better kick, mark, tackler, decision maker., goal kicker, toughness... he just didnt get to play midfieid all year to accumulate numbers.
He kicking % is much better..best first year player ibhave seen since cyril and joel.
You have your Carlton blinkers on.
Interesting choice..Jake Riccardi from GWS
Lol. So does everyone else but you does then I reckon. Walsh is the best first year player since Judd. Some people even think he’s tracking better. He was top 3 (IN THE ENTIRE AFL) for distance covered. He was running 16 km a game. Wait till 2020 he will be number one off a full preseason. Don’t reply anymore you’re making a fool of yourself.
Better ball winner, clearance player, more tackles, more meters gained. So basically a better midfielder...So of the things I outlined, which one specifically is Walsh superior to stack in? WOW-he can run! helps when the side you are in is 1/11 and you play on the ball the entire time...please let me know all the areas he is superior to Stack and please don;t ignore the question
ThanksBetter ball winner, clearance player, more tackles, more meters gained. So basically a better midfielder...
I wouldn’t trade Walsh for Dangerfield. Does that answer your question.So of the things I outlined, which one specifically is Walsh superior to stack in? WOW-he can run! helps when the side you are in is 1/11 and you play on the ball the entire time...please let me know all the areas he is superior to Stack and please don;t ignore the question
One plays on ball the other doesnt ffs.... i typed it slowly for you. One is therefore involved in a lot more clearances. He played virtually every minute in the midfield.Better ball winner, clearance player, more tackles, more meters gained. So basically a better midfielder...
He didn’t kick that many goals though did he?He's a good one mate. Watched him play at Werribee and performed out of his skin the whole season
Well as Walsh spends most of the game in the midfield he is expected to have lower disposal efficiency... Walsh averages more tackles so i am not going to concede that. Yes Stack has superior speed but Walsh has a superior tank.One plays on ball the other doesnt ffs.... i typed it slowly for you. One is therefore involved in a lot more clearances. He played virtually every minute in the midfield.
So you are therefore conceding all the other aspects of the game i mentioned? Stack superior kick, mark, tackler, decision maker, speed, goalkicking.. freak
I note with interest you didnt mention sam “ up and down the mineshaft” Walsh kicking efficiency?
Well as Walsh spends most of the game in the midfield he is expected to have lower disposal efficiency... Walsh averages more tackles so i am not going to concede that. Yes Stack has superior speed but Walsh has a superior tank.
They are very different players with very different strengths. I am only arguing the fact that you think Stack is better at everything, that is just not true or even close to being true.